The art of resistance

Published December 12, 2017
Refugees in Germany, one of many photos used in ‘The Citizen’ by Tobias Zielony./ Photos by White Star
Refugees in Germany, one of many photos used in ‘The Citizen’ by Tobias Zielony./ Photos by White Star

KARACHI: Immigration, political resistance and digital influence are some of the themes explored in the Venice Biennale 2015 on tour exhibit which opened on Monday at Alliance Française de Karachi.

Titled Fabrik — On the Circulation of Data, Goods and People and part of the German Pavilion at the 56th Venice Biennale, the exhibit features four works on display by the artists Olaf Nicolai, Jasmina Metwaly, Philip Rizk, Tobias Zielony and Hito Steyerl. Using video installations, photos and interactive instalments, each work explores the power of images and narratives.

In the ‘The Citizen’, Zielony questions the European media’s stereotyping of refugees as agitators. Using photos of African refugees in their everyday lives — laughing, cooking, sleeping and hanging out with their friends — the artist humanises them; the blank spaces framing the photographs a reminder of how the media often leaves out the other side of the story.

Zielony also asked African journalists and authors to comment on the photographs he had taken — the resultant articles push back against a negative Western narrative and capture the refugees’ spirit of resistance and resilience.

A similar technique is used with ‘GIRO (Tableaux)’ where Nicolai invites the viewer to examine the iconography of rooftops: two installations play footage captured by flying boomerangs while a wall displays various images.

There are snapshots from across history and places such as the first selfie taken in 1920 on the roof of the Marceau Studio in New York; Soviet soldiers hoisting a flag at the top of the Reichstag in Berlin in 1945 and Mexican prisoners

protesting their poor conditions in Tijuana in 2008 — all images that show how the rooftop can be a symbol of freedom, resistance, creativity and punishment.

First Selfie. Photographers from the Byron Company on the roof of the Marceau Studio, New York, 1920 (Part of ‘GIRO (Tableaux)’ by Olaf Nicolai). / Photos by White Star
First Selfie. Photographers from the Byron Company on the roof of the Marceau Studio, New York, 1920 (Part of ‘GIRO (Tableaux)’ by Olaf Nicolai). / Photos by White Star

Metwaly and Rizk, on the other hand, use theatre, acted out on an apartment rooftop terrace in Cairo, to explore the impact of neo-liberalism on labourers’ rights in Egypt. The artists invited workers — both employed and unemployed — to act out a play on the privatisation of a factory.

Their art installation, ‘Out on the Street’, includes a video that captures the challenges and complexities of protesting in the country as well as mobile phone records of a worker documenting the destruction of a former factory.

While ‘Out on the Street’ invites the viewer to debate about neo-liberalism, ‘Factory of the Sun’ by Steyerl uses the concept of sunlight to explore the impact of the digital age. Using video depicted as a computer game, the artist forces viewers to re-examine their relationship with technology.

Fabrik — On the Circulation of Data, Goods and People will be on display till Jan 14, 2018.

Published in Dawn, December 12th, 2017

Opinion

Editorial

Battling hate
Updated 15 Mar, 2026

Battling hate

In the current scenario, geopolitical conflict, racial prejudice and religious bigotry all contribute to the threats Muslims face.
TB drugs shortage
15 Mar, 2026

TB drugs shortage

‘CRIMINAL negligence’ is the phrase that jumps to mind when one considers the disturbing consequences of the...
Chinese diplomacy
Updated 14 Mar, 2026

Chinese diplomacy

THERE are signs that China is taking a more active role in trying to resolve the issue of cross-border terrorism...
Fragile gains at risk
14 Mar, 2026

Fragile gains at risk

PAKISTAN is confronting an external shock stemming from the US-Israel war on Iran that few of the other affected...
Kidney disease
14 Mar, 2026

Kidney disease

ON World Kidney Day this past Thursday, the Pakistan Medical Association raised the alarm on Pakistan’s...
Delicate balance
Updated 13 Mar, 2026

Delicate balance

PAKISTAN has to maintain a delicate balance where the geopolitics of the US-Israeli aggression against Iran are...