Accountability court bars NAB from handling Toshakhana case, hands it over to FIA

Published September 9, 2024
Imran Khan and his wife Bushra Bibi attend a hearing at the Lahore High Court in this file photo from July 2023. — Dawn/AFP/File
Imran Khan and his wife Bushra Bibi attend a hearing at the Lahore High Court in this file photo from July 2023. — Dawn/AFP/File

An Islamabad court on Monday prohibited the National Accountability Bureau (NAB) from pursuing the new new Toshakhana reference against PTI founder Imran Khan and his wife Bushra Bibi, transferring the case to the Federal Investigation Agency (FIA) court.

Imran, 71, has been imprisoned at the Adiala Jail for almost a year upon his conviction in four cases — two Toshakhana references, the cipher case, and the Iddat case, in which his wife, Bushra Bibi, is also jailed.

Imran’s sentences in the Toshakhana references were suspended while he was acquitted by the Islamabad High Court (IHC) in the cipher case in June.

Shortly after the court acquitted him in the Iddat case, however, NAB re-arrested Imran and his spouse in a new Toshakhana case, leaving his possible release from prison hanging in the balance.

On Monday, Accountability Court Judge Muhammad Ali Waraich heard the post-arrest bail applications of the party founder and his spouse, who were brought before the court from jail.

The court declared that following the NAB amendments, the reference in question ceased to come under the anti-graft body’s jurisdiction. Therefore, it will now be transferred to the FIA court, which will rule on bail.

According to the written judgment, a copy of which is available with Dawn.com, the court ruled: “…In the light of the judgement of Hon’ble Supreme Court of Pakistan passed in intra court appeals… the 1st, 2nd & 3rd amendments made in National Accountability Ordinance (NAO), 1999 have been revived.”

It stated that the case “[does] not fall within the jurisdiction of this court in the light of amended section 5(0) of NAO, 1999, therefore, this court lacks jurisdiction to proceed with [the] case in hand.”

During the hearing, the NAB prosecution team opposed hearing the bail applications and asserted that this court did not have jurisdiction to hear them after the NAB amendments.

The court verdict read: “According to amended section 4(d) of NAO, 1999, the case which is not triable by this court under amended NAO, 1999 shall, after examination of the record and with the assistance of the National Accountability Bureau be referred it to the appropriate court.”

The verdict also noted that the offence was punishable under the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1947, which is a “scheduled offence cognisable under Federal Investigation Agency, Act, 1974 triable by Special Judge Central.”

Imran’s lawyer Salman Safdar argued that after the amendment of NAB’s laws, the case against Imran was over.

“Under the new law, it is no longer a crime. Right now, the PTI founder and Bushra Bibi are in the custody of the accountability court,” he said.

“While we accept the argument that the case has to be transferred following the amendment in (NAB’s) laws, we demand that the case is transferred after issuing a verdict on bail applications.”

After arguments from both sides were completed, the court reserved its decision. It later declared that after the NAB amendments, the case no longer fell under the bureau’s jurisdiction, adding that now, the case would be heard by an FIA court under the Corruption Act.

The case was transferred to a Special Judge Central, who will also decide on Imran and Bushra Bibi’s bail applications.

The judge ordered that a hearing be scheduled tomorrow on the Toshakhana case and the bail applications. He further ordered that all records of the reference would be transferred to the court of Special Judge Central.

Opinion

Editorial

The next deluge
Updated 16 Jul, 2025

The next deluge

Pakistan, and others vulnerable to climatic extremes, must heed the warning before the next deluge arrives — because it surely will.
FC revamp
16 Jul, 2025

FC revamp

WHAT’S in a name? The civilian paramilitary force hitherto known as the Frontier Constabulary will continue to...
Simplified tax forms
16 Jul, 2025

Simplified tax forms

THE rollout of a new interactive tax return form should ease filing by simplifying the procedure, addressing a...
Consolidating gains
Updated 15 Jul, 2025

Consolidating gains

It would not be incorrect to say that the economy is still just a shock away from relapsing into another crisis.
Second thoughts
15 Jul, 2025

Second thoughts

AND, just like that, the PTI’s ill-timed ‘Second Pakistan Movement’ seems to have been put to rest. The...
Wounded women
15 Jul, 2025

Wounded women

MORALITY is a woman’s burden to bear, and the chilling upsurge in gender-based crimes is a reminder of how...