US soldier jailed in abuse case

Published October 22, 2004

BAGHDAD, Oct 21: A US military court on Thursday sentenced a US army reservist to eight years in jail for abusing Iraqi detainees at the US-led Abu Ghraib prison in Baghdad.

Sergeant Ivan Frederick on Wednesday had pleaded guilty to charges of mistreating and conspiring to mistreat prisoners as well as dereliction of duty and indecent acts.

Judge Col James Pohl also reduced Frederick's rank to private and ordered his dishonourable discharge from he army.

Frederick's defence counsel Gary Myers announced he would appeal against what he termed an "excessive" sentence and argued that there had been a "corporate responsibility" for the abuse that took place at Abu Ghraib.

Frederick, a military policeman, is the highest ranking of seven accused prisoners involved in the abuse scandal that prompted worldwide condemnation when it emerged last April following a Red Cross investigation and a report by US journalist Seymour Hersh.

On Wednesday's hearing, Frederick had told the court how he had wrapped electric cables round the fingers of an Iraqi prisoner who had been stripped naked and made to stand on a cardboard box, threatening to give him electric shocks.

He had punched another prisoner in the chest so hard that that he collapsed, had forced three prisoners to act indecently as they stood naked against a wall, and had failed to prevent colleagues from piling naked prisoners into a human pyramid.

Asked by military judge James Pohl why he had acted thus, Frederick said he had sought to humiliate the prisoners. He told the court he knew his behaviour was wrong "because I knew it was a form of abuse".

However, the atmosphere in the prison had been chaotic, dangerous and extremely stressful. He also said that when he arrived at the prison, he already "noticed detainees naked, handcuffed to their doors, some wearing female underclothes".

Myers argued it was "the defence's point of view that there is corporate responsibility", echoing on-going public and media criticisms that the abuse appeared to be encouraged by superiors possibly as high as the US defence department.

Prosecutor Major Michael Holley, however, said the matter was a simple one between right and wrong, adding: "How much training do you need to learn that it's wrong to force a man to masturbate?"

The abuse scandal had come to light in April of this year, with a series of photos depicting the physical and sexual humiliation of naked Iraqi prisoners by US soldiers.-dpa

Opinion

Editorial

Delicate balance
Updated 13 Mar, 2026

Delicate balance

PAKISTAN has to maintain a delicate balance where the geopolitics of the US-Israeli aggression against Iran are...
Soaring costs
13 Mar, 2026

Soaring costs

FOR millions of households already grappling with Ramazan inflation, the sharp increase in petrol and diesel prices...
Perilous lines
13 Mar, 2026

Perilous lines

THE law minister’s veiled warning to the media to “exercise caution” and not cross “red lines” while...
Collective security
Updated 12 Mar, 2026

Collective security

Regional states need to sit down and talk. They must also pledge and work towards collective security.
Spectrum leap
12 Mar, 2026

Spectrum leap

THE sale of 480 MHz of fifth-generation telecom spectrum for $507m is a major milestone in Pakistan’s digital...
Toxic fallout
12 Mar, 2026

Toxic fallout

WARS can leave environmental scars that remain long after the fighting is over. The strikes on Iran’s oil...