Chief Justice Mian Saqib Nisar on Monday took suo motu notice of water shortage and its lack of supply throughout the country.
On June 7, the Supreme Court will hear cases regarding water shortage in the capital, while the apex court's Karachi and Lahore registries will hold hearings on June 9 and 10, respectively. The chief justice will also hear cases related to water issues in the Peshawar and Quetta registries.
The SC issued notices to top officials from the Capital Administration and Development Division as well as the attorney general, advocate general, and others, and demanded an explanation regarding the water shortage in the capital.
Justice Nisar was heading a three-member SC bench that was hearing a 20-year-old petition filed by Barrister Zafarullah, a senior lawyer from Lahore, concerning the Kalabagh dam. He had argued that 20 per cent of Pakistan's growth rate depended on water supply, yet no dam had been built in the country for the past 48 years.
The CJ replied that water shortage is now the "top priority" of the court and took a suo motu notice of the matter. Justice Sardar Tariq Masood regretted that none of the political parties had taken the water issue seriously enough to include it in their manifestos.
Expressing concern over the dam built on the Kishanganga River by India as part of its Kishanganga hydropower plant project, the chief justice said that the Neelum River, which is a tributary of the Indian river, has dried up.
"What have we done for our children if we can't even provide them water?" he remarked.
Read more
Comments (41) Closed
About time. Spend your time on this rather the other temporary issues!
PML-Q,PML-N,PPP have brought destruction to country. They have filled their pockets and bank accounts and did nothing for the country. So, now we have to fight for water with each other.
Everything is directly or indirectly related to incompetence of the corrupt to the core PML-N and PPP governments we had for the last ten years. What we need to ensure is that we have a an electoral system that would ensure only trustworthy people reach the parliament. Unfortunately I see a lot more suo moto notices with the flawed electoral system we have at the moment.
Though court may not be able to do much on this issue, yet I hope the awareness of this at the highest level will initiate actions at all levels and hopefully the country will be able to come up with a long term multiple solutions and hope and pray will avoid the looming crisis of unthinkable consequences.
Neelam Jehalam perhaps started construction years ago, the government and related institutions were sleeping on this. Did not know the consequences. Is it ineptness or collusion with foreign friend?
The Apex Court has taken the right notice, simultaneously it would be wonderful if SC may please call top civil engineers and ask them to prepare feasibility reports on Dams Building on war footing. As the rivers are drying, The whole nation will praise SC and it will be historical if Dams Constructions are initiated in SC Orders. Today people have great expectations from SC.
Good step for future generations
As as long as we have Shareefs in Power, we can see some roads and trains, but no water or dams....this is a work of a visionary leader, who can put nation's interests over his own cheap publicity.....
Pakistan is getting crushed with the burden of debt and scarcity of water and 95% of blame goes to the Shareef family....
Bravo CJP.
Good development.
If political parties had the will they could have developed a consensus on the Kalabagh dam. CJ should also summon the leading experts who have worked on the Kalabagh dam project in the past to fully understand the issue.
General public need to know whether politicians have been fooling the them about the issue or there are genuine concerns of the provinces? An independent commission under a SC judge to investigate the issue with the help of expers and put forward recommendations would be a good idea.
Sir please first complete earlier taken suo motu notices.
Thank you CJP for taking notice of water shortages in Pakistan.I have pleaded several times for many years that we need two more big dams for electricity generation and water storage.We are basically Agricultural country and this sector alone contributes 26% of our GDP.But our politicians have neglected this sector for 46 years.It is about time dams become our top priority.
Dear CJ. Appreciate your concern. The Rangers are in Karachi since 1992, they have done a good job but why they haven't visited the hydrant in Karachi who are stealing peoples water and selling it back to the people of karachi at a cost. The hydrant owners have approx. 15,000 water tankers for this job.
This is only going to get worse.
It is good and appreciating that CJ is so much interested in public matters. But on the ground, since all these action, water supply reduced to 30% and water tanker prices jumped to Rs 5500 from 3500 in 2 months. This is for 3000 gallon tanker, also water is mixed with dirt and ground water.
I am talking about DHA Ph V, karachi water supply situation.
Stupid suo moto action. He should instead ask the authorities to build dams
An extremely timely and laudable move by the Chief Justice.
Water scarcity is now assuming dangerous proportions. Even the capital Islamabad still with a small population is suffering from acute water shortage.
The Chief Justice is requested to take relevant officials to task and tell them to ensure water supply to residents.
The country is over 70 years old. THis is not a new phenomena. Yet only the CJP has taken notice. Not the PM in the just ousted government, not the previous PPP governments, and not the Governors of either provinces.
Something is inherently wrong with the entire setup in the country, where the government fails to do its job of providing basic services to the public including amenities like Electricty, Water, Gas, Transportation, Roads, Bridges, Security. Medical Care and Education. These are fundamentail rights of all citizens. Yet only a CJP newly appointed to his post, in the first time in the history of Pakistan has finally noticed people are thirsty!
I hope in the next 5-10 years, someone at the Supreme Court will also start addressing contaminated food and lack of aforementioned facilties around the country - before it is too late.
The water shortage problem in the country has already become existential in its magnitude and due to the fast developing tipping points in the climate dynamics, it is going to get even worse.
CJ sahib. Please take notice of things which are possible during your tenure and take it to logical conclusion. Also see what is happening in our judicial system.
we need dams, But our illiterate politicians are quarreling among themselves.
Since last 14 years, I have been writing to all Federal and Provincial Governments of Punjab and Sindh that, there is a clear solution for water shortages for the next 500 years, rotting in archives, but not even a lice crawls on any valued ear. I therefore request the Caretaker Prime Minister who is also a former CJP, to take notice of my request and get the solution out of the deep storage for immediate action. There is no tomorrow for this golden opportunity.
Don't we need money to build more dams to store Water?
All thanks to Jiyai Bhutto, qadam barhao Nawaz Sharif and clueless dictators.
So, will he take any action or just a sou moto notice?
last 48 years no dam is built .. that says all.
More than this - we the people should also start a water shortage awareness campaign. In these times, we need to take actions @ federal and provincial level. We need to conserve water in homes, land. Stop irrigating home lawns with potable water etc etc. And ofcourse we absolutely need to build dams on an emergency basis.
The fact of the matter is that the leaders of the nation are only interested in short term fixes ignoring the ground realities, that is turning into maga problem or problems. No leader or the political party wants to spend on projects that can not be completed in their tenure. Average voter does not see such looming issues until it hit them. Media at large does not care to ask such hard questions to any party leadership to address such issues. Perfect recipe to keep the nation under developed.
This is a major long term environmental issue that people have been bringing to the notice of successive governments since the 1970s and 1980s. No one paid any attention and now crisis time is here. Why blame the Indians only? We are all responsible for wasting water at individual level.
If every decision cjp will take then no use to do elections
It is clear and obvious that among the upper echelons of our system, it is ONLY the Chief Justice who is well in tune with the priorities in terms of what the public wants and needs. Those who claim to be the public representatives and those politicians who are demanding "respect for vote", are oblivious to the needs of the people and have shown no respect to the voters. In my view, it is the current Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of Pakistan who is practically giving respect to the public. Thank you Sir.- you are the best and the most courageous Chief Justice in the history of Pakistan
Pakistan don’t have money to build dams. The country will soon run out of water unless government build dams and storage water. India built so many dams in IOK and Pakistan is can’t build even one dam. Shame
No doubt dams should be constructed which will take time.There should be a high power department to stop waste of fresh water, contamination of sub soil sweat water and recycle of waste water for use in irrigation, foresting, gardening and fish farming. While planning cities there should be around green belt for the use of recycled waste water. This issue of contamination of under ground water, wastage in irrigation is as important as construction of dams.
Most important case of all. A couple of year ago pmlQ launched a khala bhag and pagani campaign. Due to their unpopularity the movement didnt get far, but I hope with CJP Saqib Nisar it reaches a fruitful conclusion
"no dam had been built in the country for the past 48 years" - mind boggling
CJP should order the army to take all necessary actions to safeguard Indus Water Treaty. War is being imposed by India and US ; and we Pakistani welcome it. We will get our water or India is ours. Ghazal-e-hind
Barrister Zafar is wrong, Gomal Zam Dam was completed in 2013.
Hundreds of suo motu actions , since past so many years , from packed milk to fake doctors and clinics, what is the out come . Not a single issue is resolved. Something concrete should be done to solve the problems of Pakistan.
CJ, you have taken suo motu notice of a number of things in the last few months. While the dispossessed masses are happy to learn that somebody somewhere has heard their plaintive cry but since there has been no real action on the ground on your previous suo motu notices the hope and value attached to your suo motu notices / actions have diminished.
Ground water in most areas of Punjab, is laced with toxic chemicals because of the stupidity of our rapid industrialization process which totally disregarded the environmental impact. So installing tube wells all over Punjab is not an option. The matter is compounded because India controls or at least has the potential to control the headwaters of our rivers and therefore while we must engage India on the water issue we must also think about other avenues - desalination plants among them.
Water is a serious matter, more important even than Food Security, because our ability to produce food is dependent on the availability of water.
@Alia Khan You and your leaders slept for the last 10 years and now you have this comment to make! Really?
Comments (41) Closed
About time. Spend your time on this rather the other temporary issues!
PML-Q,PML-N,PPP have brought destruction to country. They have filled their pockets and bank accounts and did nothing for the country. So, now we have to fight for water with each other.
Everything is directly or indirectly related to incompetence of the corrupt to the core PML-N and PPP governments we had for the last ten years. What we need to ensure is that we have a an electoral system that would ensure only trustworthy people reach the parliament. Unfortunately I see a lot more suo moto notices with the flawed electoral system we have at the moment.
Though court may not be able to do much on this issue, yet I hope the awareness of this at the highest level will initiate actions at all levels and hopefully the country will be able to come up with a long term multiple solutions and hope and pray will avoid the looming crisis of unthinkable consequences.
Neelam Jehalam perhaps started construction years ago, the government and related institutions were sleeping on this. Did not know the consequences. Is it ineptness or collusion with foreign friend?
The Apex Court has taken the right notice, simultaneously it would be wonderful if SC may please call top civil engineers and ask them to prepare feasibility reports on Dams Building on war footing. As the rivers are drying, The whole nation will praise SC and it will be historical if Dams Constructions are initiated in SC Orders. Today people have great expectations from SC.
Good step for future generations
As as long as we have Shareefs in Power, we can see some roads and trains, but no water or dams....this is a work of a visionary leader, who can put nation's interests over his own cheap publicity.....
Pakistan is getting crushed with the burden of debt and scarcity of water and 95% of blame goes to the Shareef family....
Bravo CJP.
Good development.
If political parties had the will they could have developed a consensus on the Kalabagh dam. CJ should also summon the leading experts who have worked on the Kalabagh dam project in the past to fully understand the issue.
General public need to know whether politicians have been fooling the them about the issue or there are genuine concerns of the provinces? An independent commission under a SC judge to investigate the issue with the help of expers and put forward recommendations would be a good idea.
Sir please first complete earlier taken suo motu notices.
Thank you CJP for taking notice of water shortages in Pakistan.I have pleaded several times for many years that we need two more big dams for electricity generation and water storage.We are basically Agricultural country and this sector alone contributes 26% of our GDP.But our politicians have neglected this sector for 46 years.It is about time dams become our top priority.
Dear CJ. Appreciate your concern. The Rangers are in Karachi since 1992, they have done a good job but why they haven't visited the hydrant in Karachi who are stealing peoples water and selling it back to the people of karachi at a cost. The hydrant owners have approx. 15,000 water tankers for this job.
This is only going to get worse.
It is good and appreciating that CJ is so much interested in public matters. But on the ground, since all these action, water supply reduced to 30% and water tanker prices jumped to Rs 5500 from 3500 in 2 months. This is for 3000 gallon tanker, also water is mixed with dirt and ground water.
I am talking about DHA Ph V, karachi water supply situation.
Stupid suo moto action. He should instead ask the authorities to build dams
An extremely timely and laudable move by the Chief Justice.
Water scarcity is now assuming dangerous proportions. Even the capital Islamabad still with a small population is suffering from acute water shortage.
The Chief Justice is requested to take relevant officials to task and tell them to ensure water supply to residents.
The country is over 70 years old. THis is not a new phenomena. Yet only the CJP has taken notice. Not the PM in the just ousted government, not the previous PPP governments, and not the Governors of either provinces.
Something is inherently wrong with the entire setup in the country, where the government fails to do its job of providing basic services to the public including amenities like Electricty, Water, Gas, Transportation, Roads, Bridges, Security. Medical Care and Education. These are fundamentail rights of all citizens. Yet only a CJP newly appointed to his post, in the first time in the history of Pakistan has finally noticed people are thirsty!
I hope in the next 5-10 years, someone at the Supreme Court will also start addressing contaminated food and lack of aforementioned facilties around the country - before it is too late.
The water shortage problem in the country has already become existential in its magnitude and due to the fast developing tipping points in the climate dynamics, it is going to get even worse.
CJ sahib. Please take notice of things which are possible during your tenure and take it to logical conclusion. Also see what is happening in our judicial system.
we need dams, But our illiterate politicians are quarreling among themselves.
Since last 14 years, I have been writing to all Federal and Provincial Governments of Punjab and Sindh that, there is a clear solution for water shortages for the next 500 years, rotting in archives, but not even a lice crawls on any valued ear. I therefore request the Caretaker Prime Minister who is also a former CJP, to take notice of my request and get the solution out of the deep storage for immediate action. There is no tomorrow for this golden opportunity.
Don't we need money to build more dams to store Water?
All thanks to Jiyai Bhutto, qadam barhao Nawaz Sharif and clueless dictators.
So, will he take any action or just a sou moto notice?
last 48 years no dam is built .. that says all.
More than this - we the people should also start a water shortage awareness campaign. In these times, we need to take actions @ federal and provincial level. We need to conserve water in homes, land. Stop irrigating home lawns with potable water etc etc. And ofcourse we absolutely need to build dams on an emergency basis.
The fact of the matter is that the leaders of the nation are only interested in short term fixes ignoring the ground realities, that is turning into maga problem or problems. No leader or the political party wants to spend on projects that can not be completed in their tenure. Average voter does not see such looming issues until it hit them. Media at large does not care to ask such hard questions to any party leadership to address such issues. Perfect recipe to keep the nation under developed.
This is a major long term environmental issue that people have been bringing to the notice of successive governments since the 1970s and 1980s. No one paid any attention and now crisis time is here. Why blame the Indians only? We are all responsible for wasting water at individual level.
If every decision cjp will take then no use to do elections
It is clear and obvious that among the upper echelons of our system, it is ONLY the Chief Justice who is well in tune with the priorities in terms of what the public wants and needs. Those who claim to be the public representatives and those politicians who are demanding "respect for vote", are oblivious to the needs of the people and have shown no respect to the voters. In my view, it is the current Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of Pakistan who is practically giving respect to the public. Thank you Sir.- you are the best and the most courageous Chief Justice in the history of Pakistan
Pakistan don’t have money to build dams. The country will soon run out of water unless government build dams and storage water. India built so many dams in IOK and Pakistan is can’t build even one dam. Shame
No doubt dams should be constructed which will take time.There should be a high power department to stop waste of fresh water, contamination of sub soil sweat water and recycle of waste water for use in irrigation, foresting, gardening and fish farming. While planning cities there should be around green belt for the use of recycled waste water. This issue of contamination of under ground water, wastage in irrigation is as important as construction of dams.
Most important case of all. A couple of year ago pmlQ launched a khala bhag and pagani campaign. Due to their unpopularity the movement didnt get far, but I hope with CJP Saqib Nisar it reaches a fruitful conclusion
"no dam had been built in the country for the past 48 years" - mind boggling
CJP should order the army to take all necessary actions to safeguard Indus Water Treaty. War is being imposed by India and US ; and we Pakistani welcome it. We will get our water or India is ours. Ghazal-e-hind
Barrister Zafar is wrong, Gomal Zam Dam was completed in 2013.
Hundreds of suo motu actions , since past so many years , from packed milk to fake doctors and clinics, what is the out come . Not a single issue is resolved. Something concrete should be done to solve the problems of Pakistan.
CJ, you have taken suo motu notice of a number of things in the last few months. While the dispossessed masses are happy to learn that somebody somewhere has heard their plaintive cry but since there has been no real action on the ground on your previous suo motu notices the hope and value attached to your suo motu notices / actions have diminished.
Ground water in most areas of Punjab, is laced with toxic chemicals because of the stupidity of our rapid industrialization process which totally disregarded the environmental impact. So installing tube wells all over Punjab is not an option. The matter is compounded because India controls or at least has the potential to control the headwaters of our rivers and therefore while we must engage India on the water issue we must also think about other avenues - desalination plants among them.
Water is a serious matter, more important even than Food Security, because our ability to produce food is dependent on the availability of water.
@Alia Khan You and your leaders slept for the last 10 years and now you have this comment to make! Really?