Gross overreaction

Published August 11, 2022

THE manner in which ARY News has been ‘off-aired’ and its journalists and PTI leader Shahbaz Gill either arrested or booked for serious crimes has created an unnecessary mess.

While the TV channel may have failed to properly exercise editorial controls during the live broadcast in which Mr Gill made his controversial statements, the way in which ARY’s transmission was abruptly pulled off the air by Pemra is violative of the regulator’s rules and procedures.

Facing the heat and a wide-ranging crackdown against its employees, the channel has distanced itself from Mr Gill’s statements, arguing that it could not possibly have anticipated what Mr Gill would say after he was taken on air. Be that as it may, the only proper way for Pemra to take any action would have been to issue a notice, conduct an inquiry and then decide on an appropriate penalty. Abruptly pulling ARY or any other channel from the airwaves without due process is tantamount to an attack on the freedom of the press and cannot be condoned.

Pemra has often been criticised for acting as a tool of censorship and control in the hands of successive regimes. Because the ruling PML-N has recently been expressing open disdain for the channel’s editorial lines, it is up to Pemra to dispel the notion that it jumped on an opportunity to put the channel in its place on behalf of the government.

Read: An inconvenient freedom

Relatedly, the brash manner in which Mr Gill and ARY journalists have been picked up and the flurry of serious charges now being brought against them warrant serious reflection. It must be asked why it is the government and not the supposedly aggrieved party that seems more eager to lodge cases because the government appears to be in an indecent haste to punish opponents, and it is creating the impression that the matter is being handled politically rather than legally.

It was indeed controversial for Mr Gill to suggest, even if offhandedly, that the armed forces’ rank and file are divided along political lines. However, the rest of his statement is arguably quite open to interpretation, and only a court can decide whether it amounts to sedition.

The government has already done considerable damage to itself with its indelicate handling of the situation. It would be well-advised to step back and desist from setting a precedent that it may be made to rue one day.

Published in Dawn, August 11th, 2022

Opinion

Editorial

No time left
Updated 06 Feb, 2025

No time left

Climate change concerns continue to remain a footnote as politics dominates national discourse, surfacing only when disaster strikes.
Karim Aga Khan
06 Feb, 2025

Karim Aga Khan

PRINCE Karim Aga Khan was a man who straddled various worlds and cultures. Beyond his role as spiritual leader of ...
Cotton production
06 Feb, 2025

Cotton production

PAKISTAN’S cotton crop is on the ropes. The crop output has been falling since FY15, when the country harvested a...
Kashmir question
Updated 05 Feb, 2025

Kashmir question

The important thing is to continue dialogue process, on bilateral disputes, Kashmir issue, and move beyond rigid positions.
Letters from jail
05 Feb, 2025

Letters from jail

OVER the past week, former prime minister Imran Khan has directly addressed his concerns to both the chief justice ...
Agriculture tax
05 Feb, 2025

Agriculture tax

WITH Sindh and Balochistan finally approving changes to their agriculture income tax laws to harmonise their AIT...