RUMOURS are rife that Pakistan and Indonesia are participating in peace talks with Israel, which, if true, is nothing but a step in the direction of recognising Israel. This stems from age-old move of the two-state theory i.e., Gaza and the West Bank make Palestine, and the rest is Israel.

Even if this proposition is acceptable to the Palestinians — and it might well be for the sake of peace and to end their decades of suffering — Pakistan should not recognise Israel.

There is a reason for this suggestion. This should be based on the principle that our Quaid has left for us. The Quaid-i-Azam called Israel “an illegitimate child of the West”. Recognising it would amount to recognising illegal occupation, oppression, tyranny and ruthlessness. The entire land belonged to Palestinians prior to 1948. It should be returned to them.

Moreover, recognising it would mean letting them into Pakistan. Knowing their subversive activities and covert operations, it would be too risky for Pakistan. I hope the rumours are just that; rumours.

Rubina Jan
Karachi

Published in Dawn, October 6th, 2022

Opinion

Editorial

Beyond declarations
Updated 15 Jul, 2026

Beyond declarations

States that fail to harness the talents of half their population limit their own growth and resilience.
A timely authority
15 Jul, 2026

A timely authority

EVERY summer now seems to bring fresh warnings from Pakistan’s northern mountains. This week was no different, ...
India voter purge
15 Jul, 2026

India voter purge

AFTER over 12 years of BJP rule, minorities in India — particularly its Muslims — face fascist thuggery at the...
Dire straits
Updated 14 Jul, 2026

Dire straits

FOR some time, the escalating confrontation between the US and Iran has been playing out round the strategically...
Ethnic targets
Updated 14 Jul, 2026

Ethnic targets

THE murder of five workers from Punjab in Mashkel is another grim reminder that ethnic violence remains a persistent...
Poverty punished
14 Jul, 2026

Poverty punished

THE challenge of illegal migrations should be viewed through a humanitarian lens. Harsh punishments for the poor...