LHC grants Shehbaz Sharif conditional permission to go abroad for medical treatment

Published May 7, 2021
The Lahore High Court on Friday delivered an interim order allowing conditional permission to Leader of Opposition in National Assembly and PML-N President Shehbaz Sharif to go abroad once for medical treatment. — AFP/File
The Lahore High Court on Friday delivered an interim order allowing conditional permission to Leader of Opposition in National Assembly and PML-N President Shehbaz Sharif to go abroad once for medical treatment. — AFP/File

The Lahore High Court (LHC) on Friday issued an interim order, granting conditional permission to Leader of the Opposition in the National Assembly and PML-N President Shehbaz Sharif to travel abroad once for medical treatment.

Presiding over the hearing of Shehbaz's petition for the removal of his name from the travel black list, Justice Ali Baqar Najafi also directed the government and the Federal Investigation Agency along with the director-general of Immigrations and Passport (HQ) to submit a report to the court on or before the next hearing.

"Dispensation sought for is allowed subject to all just and legal exceptions.

"Keeping in view the past conduct and travel history, the fact that name of the petitioner is not in Exit Control List (ECL) at the moment, the name of the petitioner in blacklist, if already placed, will not stop the petitioner from one-time visit to UK from May 8, 2021, to July 3, 2021 for his medical checkup as per his personal commitment made before this court," said the interim order, a copy of which is available with Dawn.com.

Responding to the development, Federal Minister for Information and Broadcasting Fawad Chaudhry tweeted that Shehbaz had submitted a guarantee for PML-N supremo Nawaz Sharif when he was going abroad.

"Now instead of issuing notice to Shehbaz for giving a fake guarantee [and] recalling Nawaz, Shehbaz himself is being sent abroad."

Shehbaz had approached the LHC a day earlier to challenge the placement of his name on a travel blacklist/no-fly list and seek one-time permission to go abroad for medical treatment.

In the petition, filed through advocates Azam Nazir Tarar and Amjad Pervez, the opposition leader, who is on bail in multiple references of the National Accountability Bureau (NAB), contended that the government had previously placed him on the ECL. However, the LHC had suspended the government’s act, giving him one-time permission to travel to the United Kingdom for medical check-up in 2019.

Shehbaz stated that he recently came to know that his name had been placed on the blacklist at the behest of the present regime. He said the authorities concerned had refused to furnish the documents to him on the basis of which his name had been placed in the list.

The petition argued that the right to travel abroad was encapsulated in freedom of movement enshrined in Article 15 of the Constitution, which was subject to reasonable restrictions imposed by the law in the public interest. It said the impugned act of the respondents, after the removal of the petitioner’s name from the ECL by the court, showed malicious intentions.

Court proceedings

During the hearing, Shehbaz's counsel said that the government had put his name on the ECL in 2019 which was subsequently removed by the high court in March 2019. "After that, the government devised a new method and put his name in the blacklist."

He informed the court that Shehbaz had already booked an appointment with a doctor in the UK for a check-up and his flight was booked for tomorrow.

"No notice was given to include his name on the blacklist," said Pervez, adding that he was the leader of the opposition and it was "illegal" to include his name in the blacklist.

"Is Shehbaz Sharif's name on any blacklist?" Justice Najafi inquired from Deputy Attorney General (DAG) Rana Abdul Shakoor who responded that the request had been based on an assumption and he couldn't assist the court without taking further instructions.

"Inform the court after taking instructions," said Justice Najafi, adding that the case would be heard after 30 minutes. Appearing in the court after the break, the DAG said he hadn't been able to take instructions and requested for the case to be heard after the holidays.

The court summoned Shehbaz and asked where he was, to which his counsel, Pervez, responded that he was in Lahore. Justice Najafi questioned why Shehbaz hadn't bought a return ticket. "Due to the coronavirus, it is not possible to get a return ticket immediately," said his lawyer, adding, "If the court wants the time of return to be fixed, then [he is] ready to give assurance in this regard."

At this point, Shehbaz reached the court, along with PML-N spokesperson Maryam Aurangzeb and Ata Tarar.

The DAG said that no emergency was indicated in Shehbaz's health condition and a doctor's appointment could be made online as well. He added that the quarantine was of 14 days and he had never heard of a 10-day quarantine period.

"The doctor's appointment story is unbelievable," he said. "Shehbaz made claims of making so many medical projects. Get your treatment done over here."

"It was asked whether the name is on the blacklist," said Justice Najafi, further asking that what were the reservations of the federal government on an individual whose name wasn't in the ECL. "Do you think Shehbaz Sharif will not return?"

"Does the federal government need any guarantee? The applicant has already left the country before and returned," he stated.

The DAG responded that some time was needed since people had gone on holiday. He read out Shehbaz's affidavit to go to the UK with Nawaz and stated the conditions that had been part of it to which he was told that case was not about the latter.

"Shehbaz is the main accused in the money laundering case and witness statements are being recorded," he said and was asked whether court proceedings would be affected by Shehbaz going abroad.

Justice Najafi then questioned the PML-N president: "What is your emergency to go abroad?"

"I have been a cancer patient. It was treated in New York and London," said Shehbaz, adding that he had been told to get regular check-ups from the doctor in UK. "The treatment was stalled due to being in jail."

He added that in light of the medical test report conducted in jail, there was need for immediate treatment. "My name was included in the blacklist, am I anti-state?"

The judge questioned Shehbaz when he planned to return, to which he replied: "As soon as the doctors say after the treatment I will come back immediately," adding, "I have never run away from court before."

"Would you like to celebrate Eid in Pakistan?" Justice Najafi asked to which Shehbaz responded: "If it was not a matter of treatment, I would have preferred to celebrate Eid in Pakistan."

Justice Najafi questioned whether Shehbaz could provide any guarantee of his return, to which he responded that he had returned immediately after seeing his mother who had passed away in London.

"I am a son of this earth. I want to remain healthy for service to this country."

Opinion

Story of the last tamarind leaf
Updated 22 Jun 2021

Story of the last tamarind leaf

These journalists speak for all the troubled features of India’s democracy that Mr Modi didn’t tell the G7 about.
Understanding abuse
Updated 22 Jun 2021

Understanding abuse

Condemnations have been rare while there is no debate on the prevalence of such abuse beyond the Mufti Azizur Rehman case.
The roots of hate
Updated 21 Jun 2021

The roots of hate

The reference to being ‘out-populated’ is a popular theme in modern neo-Nazi and white supremacist thought.

Editorial

Describing OBL
22 Jun 2021

Describing OBL

FM Qureshi’s non-committal reply to question about Osama being a terrorist or a martyr has sent the wrong message to the world.
22 Jun 2021

A neglected sector

THE PTI legislators joined forces with opposition lawmakers in the National Assembly the other day to take their own...
22 Jun 2021

Air safari

THE resumption of PIA’s air safari flights to Skardu will hopefully attract international and domestic tourists,...
Poll consensus
Updated 21 Jun 2021

Poll consensus

If the govt is reluctant to take part in an APC on poll reforms, then it must ensure that parliament can be used for this purpose.
21 Jun 2021

Global displacement

THE number of globally displaced persons shared by the UN’s refugee agency in a report released on Friday is...
21 Jun 2021

KP budget

THE KP budget 2021-22 is a sort of please-all document that hands out something to almost everyone in the hope of...