CJP grills Musharraf's lawyer on 'brave commando's' overdue return to Pakistan

Published October 2, 2018
Former president Pervez Musharraf. — Photo/File
Former president Pervez Musharraf. — Photo/File

Chief Justice of Pakistan (CJP) Mian Saqib Nisar on Tuesday grilled Pervez Musharraf's counsel over the former president's failure to come back to the country and face ongoing cases against him, warning that Musharraf's return may not be 'graceful'.

Musharraf's lawyer told the three-judge bench today that his client "respects the court" but was unable to return due to his medical condition and reservations over the provision of security.

Last week, during a press conference, All Pakistan Muslim League (APML) leader Muhammad Amjad had said that the former president was "growing weaker rapidly" due to an unspecified illness and, therefore, could not return to Pakistan.

The former military ruler left for Dubai in March 2016 for medical treatment and has not returned since.

The lawyer argued that there were no charges against Musharraf in the Lal Masjid operation case and demanded to know what the case against his client was.

He may not face any charges in the Lal Masjid case, but he is facing a treason case for which he must appear in court, replied Justice Nisar.

If Musharraf returns voluntarily, he may be able to do so respectably otherwise he may be compelled to return under circumstances which are not "graceful", the CJP cautioned.

"The commando who used to describe himself as a 'courageous commando' should today display that courage," the top judge said.

"Why is the courageous commando not returning?" he asked.

"I told you before that if he returns, he will be provided security," the CJP asserted, wondering why the "courageous commando" continues being afraid to return to the country despite assurances of "constant security". He also advised that the former military dictator should get medical treatment in Pakistan.

"I am giving you this assurance. It is the assurance of the highest court in the country," Justice Nisar said and added that: "As long as [Musharraf] is alive, it is his duty to appear before the court."

The CJP further said that it was not acceptable for a citizen to leave the country and not return while a case against them is underway in courts.

He also promised that the former military ruler would not be arrested upon his return, and that whatever the outcome of the cases, it would be strictly in line with the law.

The court ordered Musharraf's counsel to submit his medical report within a week and adjourned the hearing until Oct 11.

Opinion

Editorial

Back in parliament
Updated 27 Jul, 2024

Back in parliament

It is ECP's responsibility to set right all the wrongs it committed in the Feb 8 general elections.
Brutal crime
27 Jul, 2024

Brutal crime

No effort has been made to even sensitise police to the gravity of crime involving sexual assaults, let alone train them to properly probe such cases.
Upholding rights
27 Jul, 2024

Upholding rights

Sanctity of rights bodies, such as the HRCP, should be inviolable in a civilised environment.
Judicial constraints
Updated 26 Jul, 2024

Judicial constraints

The fact that it is being prescribed by the legislature will be questioned, given the political context.
Macabre spectacle
26 Jul, 2024

Macabre spectacle

Israel knows that regardless of the party that wins the presidency, America’s ‘ironclad’ support for its genocidal endeavours will continue.