Alert Sign Dear reader, online ads enable us to deliver the journalism you value. Please support us by taking a moment to turn off Adblock on

Alert Sign Dear reader, please upgrade to the latest version of IE to have a better reading experience



Your Name:

Recipient Email:

pakistan football, pakistan football federation, pff, pakistan singapore football, Mohammad Ali (BK Avatra) and Hassan Bashir (HIK), Saeed Ahmed (Muslim FC Chaman) , Kaleemullah, Muhammad Adil, Zia-us-Salam
-Photo courtesy The Football Association of Singapore

Pakistan’s much awaited Singapore trip – the team’s first proper senior international outing since the 2011 SAFF Championship disappointment almost a year ago – came to a humbling conclusion.

A well-oiled and well-prepared Singaporean side, gearing up for the prestigious AFF Suzuki Cup 2012, showed some key weaknesses of the Pakistan national team. After a 0-1 loss at the hands of a Singapore Selection side (U23s), the international friendly finished 4-0 in favour of the hosts on 19 November.

It was evidence of the fact that the fortunes of the national team will not change by simply stocking up the team with overseas-based players. Those players need maximum opportunities to play more matches together to form a good combination.

The discovery of Denmark-based strikers Mohammad Ali (BK Avatra) and Hassan Bashir (HIK), who both came close to scoring on debut, were one of the few positives from the tour.

There is a lot to ponder for the next set of games. While local players such as Saeed Ahmed (Muslim FC Chaman) have shown promise, ‘flat track bullies’ such as Kaleemullah (KRL) and Muhammad Rasool (KESC) have struggled to show their domestic scoring prowess at international stage. Kaleemullah has yet to score since graduating from the U19s to the senior side in 2010 and topping the PPFL scoring charts effortlessly.

It was unfortunate for former Manchester United trainee Adnan Ahmed (Nelson FC) to miss the main game due to an injury he had sustained in the loss to Singapore Selection side. The midfielder would have no doubt tried to control the tempo of the game, something which the KRL duo of Muhammad Adil and Zia-us-Salam could not cope with at all.

It also showed Pakistan’s coach Zavisa Milosavljevic that without Adnan, Pakistan’s midfield is paper thin and retaining possession and creating chances a worry. Once Adnan is available for next game, Zavisa must look to team him up with a midfield partner of similar calibre.

Another young Pakistani-origin player Luke Dean, formerly at Bradford City, seems to be an ideal double act who could work with Adnan. Also, the most experienced but now low on pace Amjad Iqbal (Bradford Park Avenue) can move into defence.

Luke has been rock solid for his new club Harrogate Town AFC in the Blue Square Bet North (Conference North), collecting various Man of the Match performances alongside player of the month in August. He now plays in same league as Shabir Khan (Worcester City) and Amjad.

KRL’s Rizwan Asif and Kaleemullah can provide ample support on the wings if Zavisa decides to stick with 4-4-2.

With Wales-based defensive favourite Atif Bashir out for long term due to injury, Zavisa has a few options at the back.

While some may say, with overseas players, Pakistan concedes more goals such as in 2011 AFC Challenge Cup Qualifiers and 2014 WC Qualifiers vs Bangladesh, the reality of the situation is that it is a combination of these players and the locally based ones that leads to such a situation. The partnership just does not work because of the limited time these play together as a unit.

The 2009 SAFF Cup showed that when playing together at the back these overseas players can do a great job. In the Cup they held firm in defense and did not concede even a single goal in 3 games. The line-up included three overseas-based players out of the four at the back. They were Shabir Khan, Atif Bashir and Amjad Iqbal.

Zavisa now has Danish Superliga’s Nabil Aslam (AC Horsens) at his disposal alongside Zesh Rehman and Shabir Khan, but what is lacking is leadership and experience. For that he must turn to Amjad Iqbal. The science lecturer maybe 31 and has broken his leg twice in last two years but he is still as fit as ever and more experienced with natural ability to lead.

Pairing Amjad and Nabil at heart of the defence the coach can make use of Zesh's attacking instinct by playing him right back and Shabir as left back.

While the youngster Omar Malik from Norwegian side FK Tønsberg has shown promise, he needs more opportunities with the team to come to terms with what is required from him. Coming from rural Norway and 2nd Division football he is new to this stage but there is no doubt about the talent and ability of Omar.

There is also Yaqoob Butt, the brother of goalkeeper Yousuf, playing in 2nd Division of Denmark after returning from a long injury lay-off. The 6’4 Yaqoob is a tough tackling and versatile player who can operate as a defender or a defensive midfielder.

Some may say that this type of approach will hurt domestic talent but the matter of fact is not much of it is up to the required standard. The players can go on tours and play against international sides but they cannot improve very much due to the substandard league they play in. No matter what a national team coach does with them, they will go back into same old crash-bang routine with their departments at home. This is why the locals and overseas players must compete for places for the best players to get the nod.

Pakistan in this regard should learn from Philippines who have extensively utilized this approach for short and medium term since only a handful of their local players are good enough to compete with the foreign-based players from Europe.

The Philippines have gone from being whipping boys of ASEAN region to hot favourites for the regional competitions because they have decided to pick the best Filipinos players from all over the world to form the best team. It shouldn’t be about local versus foreigner, but it should be about putting the best side out for Pakistan.

Just because one is from Europe doesn’t mean he should be an automatic choice nor should be the local just because he plays for an influential government department. Only genuine competition for starting spots, as well as more regular international friendlies for senior team, can gradually help Pakistani football.

Comments (10) Closed

Akram Dec 01, 2012 11:43am
I have played for a team that was at the same level as Bradford Park Ave and I did not thought that I was ever going to play for Pakistan National team! This level is, if I could put it to you is playing for your neighbourhood team - the standard of football is very poor for a local level never mind for a national level. My point for the post was to raise the issue that if Pakistan was ever going to be recognised as a decent national football team then a national structure needs to be put in place with grass-root at its heart; going around Europe picking local team players will not take you anywhere short or long term. Ever if we had a brilliant world class player, playing for one of the top team in Europe, what can one person do, not much. George Weah if any of you remember was named world player of the year in 1995 but he was Liberian and with no decent players in the team they got nowhere. The world of football has now become more competitive the ever, Pakistan needs to catch-up or put-up with rankings below American Samoe and Tonga in 180 position.
shah Nov 29, 2012 09:44am
you have not seen those players play then i take it..those from bradford park avenue...matter of fact is nobody from our current premier league is even good enough to play at park avenue standard .. while every1 is right that we need to focus on domestic front which we should but right now domestic talent isnt good enough to for short term u need to rely on the mix of players to get u results and generat interest in football from public and corporate world so you can invest that money into systems are made for decades to come, not hiring a coach for a year and expecting him to perform wonders.
Salman Nov 27, 2012 04:42pm
This is a terrific article! One of the best reads on Pak Football in a long time. My question is how do the overseas players get selected in the first place? Do they apply with PFF?
Ahmed Nov 28, 2012 10:06am
at least I am hopeful. My humble opinion, keep politics out and we are your well wishers.
Akram Nov 28, 2012 11:35am
No disrespect to anybody but when players from Bradford Park Avenue are playing for the national team then do not expect anything from the team. Pakistan football has a million miles to go, PFF is just working for the funding. With a population topping 180m (similar to Brazil!!) I just wonder why? Success for Pakistan will lie in producing home-grown players - Pakistan have proved that they can play at the highest level in many other sports and I think this will be no different. Pakistan football needs some sort of competitive structure, carry-on like this and we still be here in 100 years. Pakistan need a miracle, maybe that is around the corner..
Masood Ali Nov 27, 2012 06:50pm
yes very good idea .this approach ,will make the local players work harder.keep it up.
shah Nov 28, 2012 09:55am
they get scouted by the coach..previously they have been scouted by and put forward to PFF..they have to be playing at a certain standard ofcourse...with a good playing CV..
Mystic Nov 28, 2012 05:58am
The color and font of the 'links' is very annoying. Dawn please fix it.
BH Nov 27, 2012 05:28pm
I fully endorse the writers views.
vaikom James Dec 06, 2012 11:33am
to improve Pakistan football standard, Pak should play regularly With India, this will ignite public attention and thereby popularise the game in Pakistan and India. Not only Football, Hocky, volleyball too