Fake encounters

Published July 4, 2023

IT is time our institutions acknowledged so-called police encounters as murders committed by men in uniform. A report released in January presents startling statistics — 612 accused were killed by Punjab police in the last five years with the highest score of 186 in 2021 and 124 until September 2022. Meanwhile, Sindh’s grim state is easy to assess by the record of two SSPs. As reported in this paper yesterday, extrajudicial killings saw an upswing from July 2022 — the 10-month tenure of Hyderabad SSP, Amjad Shaikh, began with the killing of four suspects and ended with 100 ‘encounters’. These numbers shot past SSP Baloch’s earlier tally of some 241 in under two years. In Pakistan, the police illicitly execute thousands annually, citing resistance or assault attempts on officers as reasons in police records. But figures of police injury are scarce, and narrate tales that belie claims of armed exchanges. The rise in this menace makes for a dispiriting state of law and order; innocents are killed to either protect feudal or political powerbrokers, curry material favours or fill record books as officers race to surpass ‘encounter’ tallies, or settle personal enmities. While rogue officers stage murders, our failed legal system cannot be absolved, as such gruesome tactics are perpetrated to bypass it. A woeful aspect is the wild applause from the public; weary of legal processes, it is forced to prefer instant justice.

Glorified by some media as super cops and others as alleged ‘encounter specialists’ — Chaudhry Aslam, Abid Boxer, Rao Anwar — police officers embark on killing sprees with impunity. It is essential that the police hierarchy, administration, and the courts beat the clock with expeditious accountability. These crimes should have definite consequences as obsolete colonial laws, which gave the police a free hand, must be abandoned. Along with a toughened criminal justice system, law enforcers should have resources, equipment, training, confidence and encouragement to nurture a climate of safety and justice.

Published in Dawn, July 4th, 2023

Opinion

Editorial

IMF scrutiny
Updated 11 Feb, 2025

IMF scrutiny

Strengthening foundations of the economic superstructure will help make the economy competitive and boost growth.
Shadow voices
11 Feb, 2025

Shadow voices

OVER the weekend, another ‘open letter’ addressed to the army chief and attributed to former prime minister ...
Paradise at a premium
11 Feb, 2025

Paradise at a premium

PAKISTAN’S recent triumph at the New York Travel and Adventure Show 2025, winning the Best Partner Pavilion Award,...
A positive note
Updated 10 Feb, 2025

A positive note

With govt unable to press growth accelerator without upending fragile recovery, sufferings of low-middle-income households are unlikely to disappear soon.
Justice for all
10 Feb, 2025

Justice for all

ALONG with his domestic agenda, Donald Trump is busy ripping to shreds the post-World War II ‘rules-based...
Held back
10 Feb, 2025

Held back

IT is a crying shame how women are conspicuously absent from Pakistan’s civil services. Despite comprising half ...