Fresh probe into Model Town episode: Govt empowered to form multiple JITs: counsel

Published November 3, 2021
A file photo of the Lahore High Court. — AFP
A file photo of the Lahore High Court. — AFP

LAHORE: Senior lawyer Barrister Syed Ali Zafar, the counsel for a woman who lost her mother in the Model Town incident, on Tuesday argued before the Lahore High Court that the provincial government had powers to constitute as many joint investigation teams (JITs) as it wanted and whenever it deemed necessary to investigate a criminal case.

He said section 19 of the Anti-Terrorism Act 1997 empowered the government to form a JIT at any stage of a case. He argued that the law had no prohibition, whatsoever, with regard to the extent or number of JITs.

The counsel had resumed his arguments before a seven-member larger bench headed by Chief Justice Muhammad Ameer Bhatti hearing petitions against the formation of a new JIT by the Punjab government to hold a fresh probe into the 2014 Model Town incident.

Barrister Zafar argued that a new ‘independent’ investigation could be initiated anytime to ensure that justice was served.

He, however, said it was his personal interpretation of section 19, when Justice Aalia Neelum, a member at the bench, asked him to cite any judgment in support of his arguments.

The counsel also argued that the LHC did not have the jurisdiction to review a judgment passed by the Supreme Court to constitute a JIT. He said the petitioners had an opportunity to challenge the formation of the JIT by seeking a review of the order before the apex court which they did not avail.

Justice Malik Shahzad Ahmad Khan, a senior member at the bench, noted that the main argument of the petitioners was that there was no direct order by the apex court for the constitution of the JIT and they were free to assail the notification of the JIT issued by the government.

Mr Zafar argued that both parties – the woman applicant and the government – had consented to the order before the SC.

Justice Neelum, however, pointed out that the petitioners were also a party to the apex court’s proceedings and they had not given any consent.

The counsel also argued that the Supreme Court’s 2016 judgment in Mustafa Impex case, which requires cabinet’s approval, was not applicable in the instant case as the impugned JIT was not a new one, but the government lawfully changed composition of the JIT originally formed in 2014.

However, Mr Zafar withdrew the argument when the bench noted that the government’s notification about the constitution of the new JIT did not support his claim.

The counsel cited different judgments whereby fresh investigations had been allowed in cases even after the submission of challan (police report) under section 173 of Criminal Procedure Code (CrPC).

The bench, however, observed that the petitioners had an argument that the trial court, in the case in hand, had taken cognizance of the matter, conducted the indictment and the recording of evidence was also in progress.

The bench asked Zafar to come up with more arguments and case law in support of the fresh investigation into the Model Town incident.

The bench also directed Advocate Azam Nazir Tarar, counsel for the petitioners, to render his assistance on the scope of section 19 of the ATA.

Chief Justice Bhatti summoned a letter of the SC written to the government on Dec 8, 2018, and a complete record of the cabinet’s decision right from the initiation of the summary for the JIT.

The bench will resume hearing on Nov 5.

Justice Syed Shahbaz Ali Rizvi, Justice Sardar Ahmad Naeem, Justice Sardar Muhammad Sarfraz Dogar and Justice Tariq Saleem Sheikh are other members of the larger bench.

Published in Dawn, November 3rd, 2021

Opinion

Editorial

No pardon for rape
Updated 07 Feb, 2023

No pardon for rape

Cultural filters and biases can often lead to faulty applications of the law.
Health insurance
07 Feb, 2023

Health insurance

THE planning ministry is reported to have raised objections to Punjab’s flagship universal health coverage...
The people’s demands
07 Feb, 2023

The people’s demands

AS the people of KP are literally on the frontline of the battle against terrorism and violent extremism, they are...
The Musharraf enigma
Updated 06 Feb, 2023

The Musharraf enigma

The Musharraf era holds numerous lessons for Pakistan’s ruling elite, civilian and military.
Staying neutral
06 Feb, 2023

Staying neutral

THE Election Commission of Pakistan has what is perhaps one of the most thankless jobs in the country. The countless...
Wikipedia ban
06 Feb, 2023

Wikipedia ban

THE country was back in a familiar, dark place last week when the PTA blocked Wikipedia over the charge that it...