BACK in the early 1960s, Mossad, the Israeli spy agency, hunted down Adolf Eichmann, brought him to Israel, tried him for crimes against the Jews under laws that were non-existent at the time the said crimes were committed and eventually executed him.

Not long ago, the International Criminal Court (ICC) gave a judgement that the court has jurisdiction over crimes (read: ‘war crimes’) committed in the occupied territories of Palestine by Israel.

The judgement earned contrasting reaction from Israel and Palestine. The former rejected the decision with sharp criticism, whereas the latter hailed it as the decision could possibly pave the way for trying the ‘involved members’ for charges similar to the ones put forward in the case of Eichmann.

The ICC judgement is being criticised for the reason that Israel is not a signatory to the ICC, and, as such, the court has no jurisdiction over the crimes committed in the occupied territories of Palestine. This is a fair legal position.

Having said that, this is where the theory of justice dealing with moral philosophy comes into play to decide on the legality of trial in the first case and the jurisdiction in the second case.

Judging by the doctrine of ‘legal positionism’, the trial was legitimate in the first case as Israel was mighty enough by that time to assert its authority, whereas the ‘jurisdiction’ in the second case would be legitimate depending thoroughly upon the strength of ICC in implementing its writ.

Muhammad Tayyab
Rawalpindi

Published in Dawn, April 7th, 2021

Opinion

Poll language
17 Apr 2021

Poll language

There is a distinction between angry rhetoric and the language of the gutter.
Exempt from accountability?
Updated 17 Apr 2021

Exempt from accountability?

PM Khan has done a disservice to Pakistan by exempting certain institutions from performance requirements.
Education disrupted
Updated 16 Apr 2021

Education disrupted

The cost of not doing anything about them in terms of learning losses and dropouts are going to be very large.

Editorial

17 Apr 2021

Pak-India mediation

QUESTIONS had been swirling about what and who has prompted the latest detente between Pakistan and India. Now, it...
17 Apr 2021

Energy exploration

SOME exploration and production companies want the government to prioritise offshore exploration — a high-risk...
17 Apr 2021

Professor’s removal

IN a step that will go far in sending a message of reassurance to female students and academic staff in ...
Ban is no answer
Updated 16 Apr 2021

Ban is no answer

The ban will not dilute the narrative that fuels the party, it may even fan it.
16 Apr 2021

Slow recovery

THE pace of growth in large-scale manufacturing output continues to slow down, with LSM production contracting by...
16 Apr 2021

Ramazan profiteering

WITH the month of Ramazan underway, people have begun to feel the effects of galloping inflation even more. Prices...