Alert Sign Dear reader, online ads enable us to deliver the journalism you value. Please support us by taking a moment to turn off Adblock on

Alert Sign Dear reader, please upgrade to the latest version of IE to have a better reading experience


Budget cuts may abolish position of US special envoy for Af-Pak region

Updated Mar 20, 2017 08:21am


Your Name:

Recipient Email:

WASHINGTON: The Trump administration’s budget cuts may lead to disbanding of the office of the US Special Representative for Pakistan and Afghanistan, a key diplomatic position devoted to restoring peace to the region, according to diplomatic sources.

The sources, who spoke to Dawn and US media outlets, said an unprecedented 28 per cent cut in the State Department’s budget would mainly affect the foreign assistance that the department provides to US allies. But the cut, proposed in the Trump administration’s 2018-19 budget, would also force the State Department to cut down its size.

Publications that specialise in posting, transfers and sackings in the US government reported that President Donald Trump and his aides were reviewing whether to eliminate many special envoy positions. The proposal, if approved, will affect the “diplomatic staff assigned to key regions and issues, including climate change, anti-Semitism and Muslim communities”.

The Chicago Tribune, while reporting on how the budget cut announced last week, would affect the State Department, noted that although the Trump administration had completed its second month in office, “many key national security and foreign policy positions still remain vacant”.

Vacancies at the State Department include both key positions that deal directly with the greater South Asian region, US special representative for Afghanistan and Pakistan and the Assistant Secretary of State for South and Central Asia.

The last assistant secretary, Nisha Biswal, was let go soon after the new administration took charge. The last special representative was Richard Olson, who served from Nov 17, 2015, to Nov 17 of last year. He was replaced by an acting representative, Laurel Miller.

The State Department defines the special representative’s role as that of coordination “across the government to meet US strategic goals in the region while engaging Nato and other key friends, allies, and others to support these efforts”.

Dan Feldman, who served in the special representative’s office since its creation in 2009 and also as its head from 2014 to 2015, argues that the office was created to combine diplomacy with the US military offensive to restore peace in Afghanistan.

“Any long-term Afghanistan resolution requires integrated and comprehensive military and diplomatic leadership from the United States,” he said in a piece he wrote for The Chicago Tribune.

“And if that was the case when international forces were at their apex in Afghanistan several years ago, with close to 150,000 foreign troops on the ground, that’s even more the case now, with 13,000 international troops remaining,” he added.

Mr Feldman wrote that “the only feasible, sustainable, cost-effective, long-term resolution for Afghanistan is a negotiated political settlement between all parties, including the Taliban”.

And this will “unequivocally require sustained US diplomatic leadership to achieve. In the interim, continued US diplomatic leadership, as an equal counterpart to military leadership,” said the former US diplomat while explaining why he believed the Trump administration needed to continue the office of the US Special Representative for Afghanistan and Pakistan (SRAP).

The special representative also engages with the key nations of the region, which will need to support any long-term resolution. “Doing all this effectively requires not just diplomacy, but an empowered, credible, experienced US diplomat,” Mr Feldman wrote.

But reports in other US media outlets say that such arguments are not having much impact on the Trump administration, which is determined to reduce the size of the State Department. Trump advisers believe that the job assigned to SRAP could also be done by a section within the office of the Assistant Secretary of State for South Asia.

But there are also proposals to combine the offices of the assistant secretaries for South, Central and East Asia. If such proposals are accepted, the new assistant secretary will be required to look after an area that will stretch from the borders of Russia to Japan. This will not only cover three huge nations — China, India and Indonesia — but also close US allies like Japan and South Korea.

The combined office of South, Central and East Asia will also include two major crisis zones, the Korean peninsula and the Pak-Afghan region. That’s why think-tank and media experts say that this merger may not happen, although merging the SRAP’s office in the South and Central Asian bureau is more likely.

Published in Dawn, March 20th, 2017


Your Name:

Recipient Email:

Comments (18) Closed

No to Envoys Mar 20, 2017 07:56am

if this happens it will be a good news for both Pak and Afghanistan.Special envoys pressurises both countries in illegal ways for their nefarious ambitions.

dr.arshad Mar 20, 2017 08:13am

A blessing in disguise. The other day an Indian colleague was bemoaning over restrictive ban on Indian man power working as computer technicians,office clerks ,bell hoppers and tea walas. Trump is proving dangerous even to its closest allies.

Bond Mar 20, 2017 08:39am

Has peace been restored in Afghanistan-Pakistan region since special envoy's position was created ? No. Time has come to remove them. But the money should be allocated for more drones to fight the terrorists which will automatically restore peace in the region

Alba Mar 20, 2017 08:47am

The State Department defines the special representative’s role as that of coordination across the government to meet US strategic goals in the region... " - That is one of the major flaws in American government - the State Department defining what America's strategic goals are. Trump as president of the United States wants to take back decision making. There are no State Department powers defined in the US Constitution. In fact there is no State Department mentioned in the Constitution. It is certainly not a recognized branch of government, and has no constitutional powers. That is why the State Department has moved into the West Wing of the White House to tell presidents what to do. However, Trump has decided to crop their powers to interfere.

Zak Mar 20, 2017 08:55am

Sensible move. The AF-Pak rep is not required. The one that is required is Pak-Ind-Kashmir, PIK. Kashmir is key issue that needs to be resolved to bring peace and avoid a possible Nucleuar conflagration over kashmir.

Alba Mar 20, 2017 09:00am

I find it odd publications that specialize in posting, transfers and sackings in the US government even exist. I can see the need for Washington bureaucrats want to know when and if their jobs are at risk. There is a built in specialized market for them no doubt. Bureaucrats do not exist to manage governments. Bureaucrats exist to manage their careers.

Mohammed Mar 20, 2017 09:01am

what could be better then this for the region.

Alba Mar 20, 2017 09:03am

@dr.arshad ... Then don't worry, because Pakistan is not one of America's closest allies.

oSD Mar 20, 2017 09:08am

Afghanistan and Pakistan will finally have peace!

aleem Mar 20, 2017 09:26am

That will be good. It was a waste of money in the first place

Azad kashmir Mar 20, 2017 10:53am

Thank God!

N K Ali Mar 20, 2017 11:02am

The fewer the Americans in South Asia, the better will be our inter-state relations. What is his contribution to peace and stability in Afghanistan is anybody's guess. Salams

nHM Mar 20, 2017 11:09am

Glad that Trump administration is taking a non interference stance in the region

Muhammad Sajid Mar 20, 2017 11:34am

Pragmatic move by Trump. He must have seen ZERO results from the past experience on such appointments, which, as pointed out by an ex-Defence secretary in his biography that "Specil envoy" position as a matter of fact adds to confusion since the incumbant on the position has no decision making authority, which lies with the Secretary of state.

TR Mar 20, 2017 12:27pm

Mr. Trump's team has necessary knowhow to save wasteful expenditure.

Saif ZulFiqar Mar 20, 2017 12:48pm

Special Envoys have never solved any problem but have created more problems.

kerala Mar 20, 2017 01:54pm

Thank God. Let the US aid stops.

lost cause Mar 20, 2017 07:27pm

Even after investing huge sums US has not gained any respect in Pak Af region or with its people. It is best for them to let go this region.