Alert Sign Dear reader, online ads enable us to deliver the journalism you value. Please support us by taking a moment to turn off Adblock on Dawn.com.

Alert Sign Dear reader, please upgrade to the latest version of IE to have a better reading experience

.

‘Khabaristan Times’ ban

Updated Feb 04, 2017 08:46am

Email


Your Name:


Recipient Email:


It has a small but dedicated readership — a smart, knowledgeable online publication catering to a young, politically savvy class of readers. In short, ‘Khabaristan Times’, the satirical Pakistan website poking fun at state and society in equal measure, is a project worth admiring — and vigorously defending when it comes under attack by a paranoid state.

As disclosed by the publishers of ‘Khabaristan Times’ and corroborated by a report in this newspaper, the Pakistan Telecommunication Authority has blocked the website.

No official notification has been sent to the website’s publishers; they were not given a chance to respond to the allegations against them; and, according to unnamed sources at the PTA quoted in this newspaper, the action was taken because of so-called, unspecified objectionable content in ‘Khabaristan Times’.

What is clear is that the PTA action is unwarranted, ill advised, an assault on a thoroughly democratic tradition — and probably illegal. The ban on ‘Khabaristan Times’ should be reversed immediately and the PTA must be forced to disclose the complainants if they are state agencies, as well as explain the basis for taking such an extreme step.

The widening and deepening assault on free speech and particularly on the media is a source of great worry for right-minded and sensible people in the country.

With internet usage growing swiftly in an age of relatively cheap smartphone technology and expanding coverage nationally of mobile data, the state is ramping up its oversight of the online market in Pakistan.

Part of that is necessary, for example, when it comes to militant propaganda and online crime, but a great deal of it is arbitrary or designed to muzzle speech that the state is uncomfortable with. Poorly drafted laws and regulators who are beholden to state authorities are causing the very worst impulses to be acted on.

That is simply unacceptable, and in the case of the ban on ‘Khabaristan Times’ it appears to be rooted in an ignorance of satire. Whimsical, politically motivated bans have no place in the great, democratic online space.

Published in Dawn February 4th, 2017


Comments (9) Closed



Syed F. Hussaini Feb 04, 2017 08:44am

They are insecure.

They are scared of the word and feel threatened by it.

They are afraid that the people would know the word.

They fear they would lose power if the word came out.

It all begins with the word.

Thank you, Dawn!

jithin Feb 04, 2017 09:00am

My love for Pakistanis grew by another step after going through the Khabaristan Times! Please folks, don't let them take down your freedom of speech and expression!

An Indian here.

Dott.Rathore --Middle East. Feb 04, 2017 08:56am

STATE is right.

Yohoyohohoho Feb 04, 2017 09:03am

Let Khabaristan Times plead the case in a court of law against PTA's unwarranted and illegal action against it. The PTA's action is a stab into democratic norms and freedom of expression.
Long time ago we used to have an Urdu magazine "Namakdan" and Majeed Lahori was its senior columnist. No one repeat no one was safe from his pen. It was well tolerated. It provided laughter. It was a valve to let the steam out. It performed a valuable social function. Khabaristan Times is trying to be a social valve although in a much tamer way than 'Namakdan' did. Every society needs such a valve. What is it that PTA is afraid of?

Shalone Feb 04, 2017 10:25am

This is really shameful to ban Khabristan Times just because it points out the shortcomings of our system and represents young readers.

Imtiaz Feb 04, 2017 10:48am

There are two types of people in the world, those who appreciate satire and oppose

Indian Feb 04, 2017 11:26am

They also have content on India and I enjoyed it. Nice website. Ban is unfortunate.

RIP Feb 04, 2017 01:44pm

I feel you but they were criticizing everyone except themselves. So guess that's their fault.

Shahzad Feb 04, 2017 05:06pm

KT is one awesome paper. I am now reading the back issues. There is truth hidden in satire. A nation who cannot laugh at itself will never prosper. Btw i am in usa