Well said Mr.Ghani.

It time to sent all Afghani refugees back; no more political love for Pushtun brothers. There should be a time limit of 90 days, let India the best friends of Pusthuns help them. It will clean up Karachi and part of Pakistan.

Cribbing and complaining won't solve your problem Mr.president. If you have forgotten then let me tell you that Afghanistan was the country that never accepted Pakistan when it came into being and has always played negative against it. Look in the mirror and then complain. Your cribbing comes from the mind set that afghans have developed right from the inception.

Sadly, Ghani does not represent Afghan people. He represents western interests in Afghanistan.

very well said .

Very blunt and neatly articulated statement by Mr Ghani.

well said Mr Ghani that India has been a friend of Afghanistan historically thats why you have always stabbed us from the back. we gave you so much and in return you gave us narcotics and klashinkovs. please ask India to take your refugees also, your loving brother

Ya blame pakistan for your own failures. If you attacked TTP then why is it still thriving. If Afghanistan state is not sponsoring them then who else ? If you are unable to eradicate TTP then why you expecting us to open an another all out war in Pakistan. Law and order in Pakistan is perhaps not much better than Afghanistan. You have better chances to deal with Taleban than Pakistan with all mighty super powers military and financial supports in your pockets. If it's US or Afghanistan pakistan is always a scapegoat for their own failures. You shouldn't be angry at pakistan in any case because Afghanistan never accepted Pakistan. For Afghanistan pakistan doesnt exist. Always stabbed pakistan in the back until russians ran over you.

Time has come for Pakistan to stop tolerating the Afghan leadership. Since 1947 they have shown hostility towards Pakistan and Pakistan in the name of Islam have shown tolerance towards them and helped them in removal of Soviet forces from Afghanistan and letting their refuges live in Pakistan adding burden on Pakistan economy. It is about time that Pakistan should change their policy towards Afghanistan. To start with all Afghan refugees should be sent back, border should be closed for trade and Taliban should be actively supported to remove foreign forces and their agents from Afghanistan.

The only solution to afghanistan peace is we will deploy our armed forces in afghanistan and will call US to withdraw their troops and then we will bring all the factions on the table for negotiations where in those area where mutual or common interest can be achieved will be put into act.otherwise unfortunately this will continue.

Very clear statements and questions. Now need answers to these questions instead of scornful evasive answers.

Looks who is speaking....

How can our government even tolerate such hostile statements from the Afghan government, while silently extending our hospitality to its refugees.

On the other hand The Big Brother just keeps opening its consulates and sends agents disguised as emissaries.

Blaming Pakistan for your failures will do nothing to promote peace in your country Mr. Ghani. Our country continues to suffer on account of our support for your fellow countrymen who still claim refugee status in Pakistan. You continue to profess your undying love for India but I don't see that country accepting over three million afghans as we have here in Pakistan. We have suffered immensely over the last three decades for our support of your country Mr. Ghani. A simple thank you would have sufficed. Instead this is what we get from you. What a shame.

great leader Ghani.

Pakistan should have one point agenda with Afghanistan...Take all the Afghan refugees back immediately...Ashraf Ghani is not a leader of Afghanistan people he is the puppet of foreign powers in Afghanistan...Mr. please count the favours Pakistan has done you in the last 70 years in spite of your disfavour to us in 1947...

Afghanistan and afghani always hate Pakistan and allow our enemies to use Afghanistan against Pakistan. If you stop this and stop those elements and stop receiving dollars from our enemies then you will see Pakistan and Pakistani loyalty. You give place to our enemies and our enemies doing blast in your country but you afghani blame Pakistan. Because you never accept Pakistan as brother Muslim country. So then go to hell.

A Warn Torn Country and still non-serious blame game, What are you doing with yourself Afghanistan!

Seriously ... I too agree with him

Mr Ghani, Let me remind you, This is the Pakistan who Accepted more than 3 Million your Afghan nationals as refugees, This is the same Pakistan who helped you when Russia was attacking you and You know this is the Same India who SUPPORT Russia. You deserve US and India who ruin you by indirectly supporting Taliban.

I saw this interview on Jirga, the president did not mince his words he was straight to the face and it was good.

His statements are laughing stocks.

@Zak, No difference between Karzai and Ghani and the future leaders will not be different.

No one has ever been clearer than Ghani about this, well said Mr President!

Remember, like Karzai, the erstwhile 'Mayor of Kabul', Mr. Ghani does not speak on his own. He's being fed words by India, while counting on perpetual support from his sponsors - the US Government, who's never tired of asking Pakistan to 'do more'.

To add icing to the Afghan fake-cake, the CEO (ridiculous ceremonial post) of Afghan government, is none other than Abdullah Abdullah -- the former colorful anti-Pakistan commander of the Northern Alliance, and steadfast puppet of India, with hunger for power and visions of magnanimity for Afghanistan - yet cannot even control the grounds outside the Presidential Palace in Kabul. Hence the daily carnage of suicide bombings in the city.

So, I say, hollow threats, with no substance or justification. Not worth taking seriously.

Mr. Ghani be remember that Pakistan give defeat to Soveit union in Afghanistan.

Sent all Afghan refugee to Afghanistan, they would know the importance of Our country.

Ghani whynot move all your refugees to beloved India. They suppose to be your"true" friends. Get your own house in order instead blaming everyone else. Even mighty US and NATO couldnt help you, so stop relying on others. Keeping Pakistani enemies in safe havens in Afghanistan will never work when killers of Pakistanis are protected by you on behest of India.

Very strong words in public, it shows frustration and immaturity. Such sensitive issues should be discussed in closed door meetings among Afghanistan and Pakistan officials. His statement proves he is puppet of India indulging in mud slinging on Pakistan, everybody in the world knows actions and policies of destroying all kinds of terrorists in Pakistan. Pakistan is honest and very serious about its policy against terrorists and result is visible on ground for all world to see.Agghanistan should seek advice on dealing with terrorists rather than playing blame game copying Indian rehetoric regarding terrorism.

I guess Indian money is sweeter than having good relations with Pakistan. Answer one question Mr. Ghani. When Pakistan decides to seal the border to prevent anyone illegally crossing it you complain and bring your rag tag army to challenge us. Make up your mind which way you want to go. You can have relations with India BUT dont make it at the expense of relations with Pakistan. It will be your loss.

Mr Ghani and the like if him seen to have forgotten the asylum given to them ub Quetta during the wae with Russia. He also forgets that we took minions of refugees during the war and many millions are still living within our city and towns as Pak citizens and refugees. The govt of Pakistan should cancel their citizenship and refugee status and send them back. Let them go to India.

"The Afghan president claimed he can provide addresses of Taliban leaders in Quetta."

Funny, I can provide the address of the US bank where you you deposit your paycheck, and can even provide the name, address and phone number your employer - and it is not in Afghanistan!

Heck, I can even provide the address of your holiday home in India.

We also have three demands; 1- Take back all the Afghans currently in Pakistan who are mostly responsible for all the crimes and involved in terrorism 2- Seal the border. We don't want you or your containers to pass through Pakistan. Majority of smuggled good come from the same containers. 3- Stop claiming you have taken any action till the time people like Fazlullah are very much alive. All our most wanted are in your country so either accept being the sponsor or stop blaming others when the same happens across the border

Who cares what he says, he is the weakest president of the world.

@Skeptic Hear hear, well said.

Apply first point to yourselves. Second and third points are not worth it.

Every nation has its own priorities. As an immediate and close neighbor Afghanistan must prefer Pakistan than any other country.There should be rational balance of your relations with India and Pakistan,can't you see the atrocities being carried out in Kashmir, so far you have not condemned . It is better if you directly talk to Pakistan,which you earlier said is your second home.

The real problem is that the world listening to Ghani and do not believe what Pakistan has to say

Thank you Mr.Ghani, You are not only bold, you are also able to identify who is your foe and who is your friend. Your statement shows your frankness.

Excellent statement. Well said.

Mr. President you, your government and we may add your people at large needs to change collective mindset. We are in 21st century n cannot worry or care your medival mindset. Fix your country, take your refugees back, develp relations with any country, we are not concern, just makesure your friendship with any other country does not challenge our country stability or threaten our peace.

Just show the advisor of Imran Khan this statement. Because for the last days Imran Khan is talking about Afghans and KP connection on twitter and even using Racist language in claiming that there is only one ethnicity known as Pukhtoons who are the most respectable and honorable so they should help Afghans ( As if other ethnicites of Pakistan do not care or they are not hospitable).

Afghanistan does not respect the Pakistan, they ( Afghnistani's people) forget everything who done Pakistan for them, but Afghnistan blame Pakistan for making their country weak and unstable.So this kind of statement can not bring good mutual relationship, and this will create further stresses between them

If Afghanistan is proud of its friendship with India, then we should take the bitter-pill and accept it. There is no use for us being friends with Afghanistan. They are the most dubious Muslims and history is the proof that they were the first nation after our creation who opposed our entry into the United nations.

Any hits on TTP in Afganistan was not done by Afghans but by US, Mr, President. Send all refugeses back to Afganistan.. Conficate all illegal properties, IC cards and passports of Afghans in Pakistan. No exit or entry without visa...

What was the result of the 11 attacks on Fazlullah? Get serious Mr. President - you are supporting Fazlullah, Baloch insurgents and many anti Pakistani groups in your own country - get your act together before pointing fingers all the time towards Pakistan.

Mr Ghani, if you have an iota of dignity, why don't you publiclly invite all Afgan refugees in Pakistan to come back to Afghanistan. That would be a very good start.

Pak should close the border, let the already bankrupted Afghan economy drag down by using Iran as a port, for how long the Iranians and Indians will subsidise the trade with Afghanistan, they cant survive without Pakistan, great that pak is engaged with CPEC and the central asian states can use China and eventually CPEC.

Afghanistan on one side, India on the other, Iran on the third. China is our only friendly neighbour, and can help us put Afghanistan in its place. China can put pressure on Ghani through their many mining contracts and stop this Indian agenda for Afghanistan once and for all.

As a president of Afghanistan can you take back the Afghans refugees who are living in Pakistan for decades. Under your leadership now Afghanistan is democratic and prosperous country and you should take back and accommodate your all nationals. This will help Pakistan to take actions against those who target both Pakistan and Afghanistan.

Mr President let's build a big fence between pakistan & Afghanishtan border , & start strict visa system , so we will not treat terrorist people in our hospital in peshawar . How we know that this afghan is good & this is bad terrorist.Your countrymen are leaving & doing business since 1980 in our country . And you are telling that India is your historic friend. , why not recall all your refugee and send them to India.

We gave u shelter all these years and now it's difficult for u to develop relationship with Pakistan. Typical AFghan mentality

@Tufail Khan no need we can handle India without problem. Afghanistan is tricky because the government works for foreign interests while the people like Pakistan. Iran and China are our close friends.

we as pakistanis..do not agree with your statement... Thanks

@Ravi Vancouver Great to see a sane voice.

@Ravi Vancouver I have no problem with your feelings and comments. You have a right to express yourself the way you want. However I have problem with the fact that you are pretending to someone you are not. You have no guts to use your real name and trying pretend as if you are Indian and I double anyone believe in what you say in either country.

@Ishrat Salim please listen once again, Mr President mentioned all refugees issues!

Clearly South Asia is getting divided into two groups. Asian countries opposing each others more than westerns. Only If we were working on bestowed interests, we would have been stronger than EU or USSR.

@Maqsood Oh....really...? big question.

@Zak Vow excellent interpretations ZAk !!!

Ghani claimed that Afghan forces have bombed the chief of Tehreek-i-Taliban Pakistan (TTP), Mullah Fazlullah, eleven times along with attacks on his close aides.

11 times and he is still alive. Now, is'nt it fishy.

I love this "...India is building dams ....". If India would have wanted, the Soviets would never have entered Afghanistan. Thanks to your Indian buddies you have spent 4 decades in turmoil and Kudos to your intelligence how smart you are in blaming Pakistan. You do not want to share space with your own countrymen and blame Pakistan instead. Pakistan even being culturally closer to India has always treated you with respect and this is what we get.

@Mr.White . This from citizen of the only free world country that supported Russian occupation of Afghanistan.

Instead of making distractive statements, does Pakistan have answers to the cogent questions raised by Dr. Ghani?

You need to establish a balance in the conduct of your relation with India and Pakistan.

Afghanistan has to choose between brother Pakistan and new friend India. You cannot have the cake and eat it too.

Why Fazullah still alive and in Afghanistan? Why there are so many Indian consulates in Afghanistan along the border with Pakistan. Mr. President you are talking the language of Indians and you are harboring Indians in Afghanistan against Pakistan. Mr. President you are nothing but a voice of our enemies. We will still feed and pretect your people in Pakistan besides you being unthankful. Furthermore you are a president of a country which is under occupation.

Mr. President you are a president of a country which is under occupation. You are not a country right now. Fix up yourselves and feed your own refugees before raising any of your dirty Indian fingers on us. Be good under occupation.

The only commentators here supporting this PUPPET man are the indians.

My admiration only grows for Dawn, who facilitates publication of very terse, yet apt views on Pakistan and its policies on foreign affairs.

Dawn is doing a great service to the nation as it is allowing dissemination of views which are contrarian in nature, and general public may not like to hear them, but they nonetheless contain elements of truth and factors of realism.

Good work, Dawn.

@Mumtaz The reason there are so many consulates is because India is helping develop infrastructure in Afg. There are thousands of workers and they need consulare help often

@Zak if that is the case then Pakistan represents Chinese interests .

@anony And why not?

Why even have any relations with them ? Israel and Palestine have no relations right ?

@Khilari does that mean its tit for tat?

@asad you well said

Sad to hear the statement from Afghan president and deeply hurt to know their feelings about Pakistan. I think they have a short memory and forgot the past when Pakistan have been fighting for them against the than super power and had lost thousands of our people and offered million of refugees a respectful living in the country. Lets not go so far in the enmity neither create more troubles for the refugees by giving disgraceful and unbearable statements against Pakistan. We should live as a good neighbor and support each other in eradicating the terrorism across the boarder. You are free to pick your friend and no one stopping you to develop relations with the other countries but there are some facts which could not be denied that you have to pass through Pakistan to reach India or will have to take a long flight to reach their, so choice is yours which way you choose !

Indian agents will not be allowed to succeed wherever they are, whoever they are and whatever they are.