Rights groups join hands to protest cyber-crime bill

Published April 20, 2015
Rights organisations are of the view that several provisions in the bill restrict freedom of expression and impinge upon internet users’ right to privacy. ─ Reuters/File
Rights organisations are of the view that several provisions in the bill restrict freedom of expression and impinge upon internet users’ right to privacy. ─ Reuters/File

KARACHI: Local and international rights groups have joined hands to speak out against the Prevention of Electronic Crimes Bill 2015 (PEC) which is currently being assessed by the National Assembly.

Human Rights Watch, Digital Rights Foundation (DRF), Privacy International (PI), Bytes for All and BoloBhi are among the signatories to a document drawing attention to the inadequate protection of internet users in the new cyber-crime bill.

Rights groups believe that the lack of scrutiny of the bill by individual stakeholders and the private sector prior to its being presented in the NA undermines the democratic process.

In addition, rights groups are of the view that several provisions in the bill restrict freedom of expression and impinge upon internet users’ right to privacy.

Know more: New cybercrime bill to criminalise spam mail, text messages?


Misgivings about the PEC bill

  • Lack of safeguards regarding right to privacy and freedom of expression breach Pakistan's obligations under international human rights law
  • Allows government to order service providers to block access to any kind of internet content without any court approval which could lead to abuse of power
  • A procedure to register complaints regarding the above with the right of appeal to an independent tribunal is not a requirement although it is permitted
  • The federal government will be able to share intelligence with international spy agencies like the United States' National Security Agency (NSA) without the oversight of an independent body
  • Telephonic and email data retention for up to one year expands powers of surveillance and is a regressive move compared to modern laws regarding electronic data retention
  • Use of broad terms without clear definitions or specification of procedures regarding handling of data, leaving creation for such procedures at the discretion of the government

Know more: Why Pakistan's cybercrime bill is a dangerous farce

In an extensive legal analysis of the PEC draft, Privacy Inernational and the Digital Rights Foundation have proposed that "information-sharing with foreign governments and entities should be regulated by specific laws and subject to independent oversight".

They have said that a clear legal regime which is compliant with international law should govern data copied by the state.

These two rights groups believe mandatory retention of traffic data by service providers threatens users' right to privacy and that service providers should not be required to keep investigation or real-time collection and recording of data secret. The power to obtain decrypted information also needs to be regulated, they said.

Know more: New cybercrime bill tough on individuals’ rights, soft on crime

Opinion

Returning to a repressive order
Updated 04 Aug 2021

Returning to a repressive order

There is no sign of the Taliban showing any flexibility in their position and taking a more moderate stance.
Capacity for cruelty
04 Aug 2021

Capacity for cruelty

Those who believe in the human capacity to eschew cruelty are believed to be stupid and naïve.
Education crisis
Updated 04 Aug 2021

Education crisis

It is imperative to avoid measures that could further dent an already weak and vulnerable school system.
Off the planet
04 Aug 2021

Off the planet

Billionaires are yet to match the accomplishments of 60 years ago.

Editorial

05 Aug 2021

A tragic anniversary

TWO years ago today, New Delhi took the condemnable step of revoking India-held Kashmir’s special status by...
05 Aug 2021

Currency pressure

THE increasing demand for dollars in the wake of surging imports and debt repayments has put significant pressure on...
05 Aug 2021

Protecting breastfeeding

A LOT has been said about the fact that 40pc of children under five years in Pakistan are stunted. The reasons...
PML-N’s dilemma
Updated 04 Aug 2021

PML-N’s dilemma

The road ahead for the PML-N is going to be long and bumpy no matter which narrative it follows.
04 Aug 2021

Attacks on cops

AMIDST cautious optimism that Pakistan may be finally beginning to achieve success in bringing the number of polio...
04 Aug 2021

Myanmar about-face

SIX months into the coup that sent Myanmar’s hybrid civ-mil government packing, the generals have made their...