Nothing as difficult as writing a book: Basharat Peer

Published
4

LAHORE: “I cannot comment on a solution to the Kashmir issue between Pakistan and India nor can I say anything about its future,” said Basharat Peer, the script/screenplay writer of Bollywood film Haider, at Faiz Ghar, Model Town, on Tuesday.

Peer visited Faiz Ghar and talked about the film at length while answering questions from the audience. The talk was moderated by Dr Ali Hashmi.

Haider is directed by Vishal Bharadwaj, and co-written by Peer and Bharadwaj. The film also has a few scenes borrowed from Peer’s memoir Curfewed Night.

To a question on how Bharadwaj contacted him to write the movie, Peer said Vishal’s wife Rekha had read his book and mentioned it to her husband. He said Bharadwaj had emailed him about writing an adaptation set in Kashmir and he decided to take it up.

While drawing a comparison between writing a book and a film script, Peer said nothing was as difficult as writing a book, however writing a script had its own mechanisms. A fan of Charles Dickens, Peer said even a blockbuster movie stood nowhere when compared to a Dickens novel.

Some clips from Haiderwere also screened during the talk, including the rendition one of Faiz’s popular ghazals, ‘Gulon Mein Rang Bharay’.

To a question that in both Pakistan and India many people were unhappy after watching Haider, Peer simply said it was up to them. When an audience member pointed out that Haiderwas not screened in Pakistan, Peer regretted the film was not even submitted for censor.

Earlier, Russian writer Vladimir Lesovoy, who has written a poem on Faiz, addressed the gathering in Russian and held Faiz in high esteem. His speech was translated in English by another Russian writer present, Vladimir Mikheev.

Published in Dawn, February 25th, 2015

On a mobile phone? Get the Dawn Mobile App: Apple Store | Google Play

Opinion

Editorial

Without consequence
Updated 02 Nov, 2026

Without consequence

From drone attacks to online harassment and legal intimidation, the methods of silencing reporters are multiplying, with little fear of punishment.
Climate diagnosis
02 Nov, 2026

Climate diagnosis

THE Lancet Countdown’s latest findings should change how Pakistan thinks about illness as much as how it thinks...
Fighting harassment
02 Nov, 2026

Fighting harassment

WORKPLACE harassment is often narrowly defined as sexual misconduct. A resolution passed by the National Assembly on...
Cost of provinces
Updated 01 Nov, 2026

Cost of provinces

Political parties demanding new provinces must explain how they intend to pay for them and what improvements citizens can expect.
Exchange hack
01 Nov, 2026

Exchange hack

ON Thursday, the largest cryptocurrency heist in history saw some $6.3bn drained from exchange platform Binance’s...
Cyber safety
Updated 01 Nov, 2026

Cyber safety

The state of freedom of expression in Pakistan is already quite poor, so any further attempts to clamp down on free speech must be resisted.