India comedy pulled from YouTube amid free speech fears

Published February 5, 2015
Indian comedy troupe AlB.
Indian comedy troupe AlB.

MUMBAI: The producers of an Indian comedy that “roasted” celebrities have pulled it from YouTube following a furore over its “vulgar” content that renewed fears for freedom of speech.

The show hosted by filmmaker Karan Johar in December comically insulted several Bollywood actors in front of a large star-strewn audience in a format common in Western countries but rarely seen in India.

A video of the show, called AIB Knockout, which is heavy with profanities and sexual references, attracted more than eight million hits in just a few days when it was uploaded on Youtube late last month.

But the show sparked a fierce backlash, with religious groups urging police to file charges against the producers, and the right-wing Maharashtra government, of which Mumbai is the capital, ordering an investigation.

Late Wednesday, the producers said they were pulling the video for “pragmatic” reasons, but added that India needed to confront the fact that freedom of expression was being curtailed.

“There's a larger cultural conversation going on here, where we're at the very edges of what it's okay to say,” the Mumbai-based comedy collective, AlB, said in a statement.

“And it's a conversation we need to have now because the world we live in is entirely too complicated to be run by silences.

“We still stand by our belief in the right to absolute freedom of expression for us and for anyone who has anything to say about anything at all,” the statement added.

India has a history of official and self-censorship, with British author Salman Rushdie's 1988 book “The Satanic Verses” banned for insulting Islam.

Acclaimed Tamil-language author Perumal Murugan announced last month he was quitting writing following protests by right-wing Hindu and caste groups over one of his books.

The “roast” sparked a storm on social media this week, with a member of India's powerful censor board slamming it on Twitter as “a porn show on stage”.

But hundreds of supporters including Bollywood actors and producers also hit back, urging the right to freedom of artistic expression.

“I hope our humour gets sharper, our dissent more rigorous, our satire more offensive - and till we arrive there, we stand by AIB Knockout!” independent filmmaker Anand Gandhi tweeted.

Opinion

Editorial

Yearly trouble
Updated 25 Oct, 2024

Yearly trouble

Both Pakistan and India need a strategy that not only penalises harmful practices but also provides long-term solutions.
Countering cybercrime
25 Oct, 2024

Countering cybercrime

THE new National Cyber Crime & Investigation Authority appears to have landed in limbo, with the authorities...
Controversial guest
25 Oct, 2024

Controversial guest

INDIAN preacher Dr Zakir Naik is not known for his subtle approach to faith. Controversies have surrounded him for...
Curtain call
Updated 24 Oct, 2024

Curtain call

There is hope that under Justice Afridi, SC can move beyond the discord and heal the fractures that developed under CJP Isa’s watch.
IMF’s estimate
24 Oct, 2024

IMF’s estimate

THE IMF’s economic growth projection of 3.2pc for Pakistan falls short of the 3.5pc target that the government has...
Religious exchanges
24 Oct, 2024

Religious exchanges

STRAINED relations between Pakistan and India prevent followers of different faiths from visiting sacred sites on ...