Alert Sign Dear reader, online ads enable us to deliver the journalism you value. Please support us by taking a moment to turn off Adblock on

Alert Sign Dear reader, please upgrade to the latest version of IE to have a better reading experience


Killings in Sindh

Updated Dec 07, 2014 09:19am


Your Name:

Recipient Email:

Jeay Sindh Mahaz activists hold a protest rally on Hyderabad bypass. —Dawn/file
Jeay Sindh Mahaz activists hold a protest rally on Hyderabad bypass. —Dawn/file

There are growing indications that the methods used by the security establishment to quell separatism in Balochistan are being replicated in Sindh.

As cited by the HRCP, over the last few weeks, a number of men associated with Sindhi nationalist groups have been abducted, allegedly by security personnel, with their bodies later turning up in different parts of Sindh and Balochistan.

In one particularly brazen incident, a young wounded man was taken away from Karachi’s Civil Hospital by over a dozen men, including some in police uniform; the man’s body was later found dumped near Hyderabad.

Read| Analysis: Sindhi nationalists stand divided

Sindhi nationalist groups have protested against such ‘custodial killings’ and have pointed the finger of blame at the state. The separatism debate is not new in Sindh; in fact it dates back to at least the early 1970s when G.M. Syed gave the call for an independent ‘Sindhudesh’.

From then onwards, nationalism in Sindh has taken on various forms and hues. The nationalists have ranged from those who choose to work for the province’s rights within the framework of Pakistan, to more militant outfits that support separatism through armed violence.

Also read: Qadir Magsi urges JSMM to give up armed struggle in Sindh

A group belonging to the latter category, the banned Jeay Sindh Muttahida Mahaz, has seen its profile rise over the last decade and of late has reportedly been responsible for numerous low-intensity bomb blasts in the province.

Activists belonging to this group have been among the victims of the recent enforced disappearances.

Also read: HRCP slams targeting of nationalists in Sindh

Of course, Sindh does not suffer from the type of insurgency that has affected Balochistan. In Sindh, the political process is very much alive, even though political forces have failed to give its people good governance, law and order and economic prosperity.

While Sindh did experience armed militancy during the Zia era, there is a need to address the current problem using foresight. If some of Sindh’s youths have lost faith in the state, they need to be engaged and their grievances addressed.

If some are genuinely involved in militancy, charges must be proved against them in court. If the security apparatus adopts reprehensible and patently illegal methods such as the abhorred abduct, kill and dump policy, it will only add to alienation against the state in Sindh and raise the profile of separatist forces.

As for fringe nationalist groups, they need to listen to the advice of leaders such as Qadir Magsi and shun the path of violence and struggle for Sindh’s rights politically instead.

Published in Dawn December 7th , 2014

Comments (7) Closed

M. Emad Dec 07, 2014 07:28am

East-Pakistan --- Balochistan --- Sindh --- ???

Abbas Ali Dec 07, 2014 09:53am

Nobody wants to live under the dominance of Punjab. People want out. It is a matter of fact.

Ali Dec 07, 2014 12:16pm

its not custodial killings rather Extra-judicial Killings.

Imran Dec 07, 2014 03:03pm

@Abbas Ali then go out nobody is stopping you

Haroon Rooha Dec 07, 2014 09:56pm

Theocratic dictatorships cannot allow freedom of expression, speech, religion, culture ,diversity, of free rational Thinking. The need for uniformal submission to the authority, guaranteed extrajudicial or judicial terror is the prime principle of their survival.

Shahzado Bhutto Dec 08, 2014 01:13am

i'm very thankful to dailydawn for drawing its attention towards a growing issue in Sind

ziavrep labqi Dec 08, 2014 09:05am

This should never have happened. Now that it unfortunately has, it should not be allowed to continue. Baluchistan should also undergo immediate healing process. Someone who wields real authority should do his duty for the good of the country.