South Africa asks ICC to withdraw 'flawed' proposals

Published January 21, 2014
Cricket South Africa has termed the proposals to restructure the ICC as ''fundamentally flawed''. -File photo
Cricket South Africa has termed the proposals to restructure the ICC as ''fundamentally flawed''. -File photo

CAPE TOWN: South Africa asked the International Cricket Council on Monday to immediately withdraw proposals for reform believed to favor the game's big three countries: India, England and Australia.

Cricket South Africa said it wanted the ICC to take back the draft of new regulations drawn up by a working group of the ICC Finance and Commercial Affairs Committee for more discussion, describing it as ''fundamentally flawed'' because it hadn't followed proper procedure.

CSA said its president, Chris Nenzani, asked ICC President Alan Isaac in a letter to refer the proposals ''to the relevant ICC committees or sub-committees for proper consideration and to make recommendations to the ICC board.''

Although details of the proposals haven't been made public, they are reported to give India, England and Australia control over the ICC, Test cricket and its revenue in a major shake-up of the way the sport is run, including a greater say in when and where they play series.

The changes reportedly would see the three countries hold dominance over the ICC's decision-making executive board.

South Africa's opposition to the document appeared to back up the theory that India, England and Australia would be given overwhelming control, although CSA chose its language carefully in its letter, saying in its ''respectful opinion, a more considered, inclusive/consultative, and properly constitutionally-ordained approach is required.''

''Although there is nothing to prevent a review of the ICC funding model or finances, the proposal self-evidently is inextricably tied up with a fundamental restructuring of the ICC, which has far-reaching constitutional implications,'' CSA said.

''The draft proposal is, therefore, fundamentally flawed as regards the process and, therefore, in breach of the ICC constitution.''

South Africa has the top-ranked Test team and a string of top players but struggles to match the commercial might of the other three nations, a situation made clear when the powerful Board of Control for Cricket in India dictated terms, including the dates and number of games, to South Africa on India's tour last month.

South Africa also arguably has the most to lose by being left off cricket's top table.

CSA said Nenzani's letter had been copied to the other nine full member countries of the international cricket body, which may be asked to vote on the reform proposals at the ICC executive committee meeting at the end of this month.

Opinion

Editorial

Al Qadir ruling
Updated 18 Jan, 2025

Al Qadir ruling

One wonders whether the case is as closed as PTI’s critics would have one believe.
Atlantic tragedy
Updated 18 Jan, 2025

Atlantic tragedy

The only long-term solution lies in addressing root causes of illegal migration: financial misery and a lack of economic opportunities at home.
Cheap promises?
18 Jan, 2025

Cheap promises?

TALK is cheap. Can electricity also be? The government has recently announced that Pakistan will benefit from the...
Never again
Updated 17 Jan, 2025

Never again

The Gaza genocide has also revealed the utter helplessness of the Palestinian Authority in projecting Palestine’s case globally.
World Bank loan
17 Jan, 2025

World Bank loan

THAT the World Bank will give $20bn to Pakistan in the next 10 years to address some of the country’s most acute...
India’s dangerous game
17 Jan, 2025

India’s dangerous game

THE latest inflammatory remarks by India’s military brass about Pakistan mark a troubling departure from the...