Alert Sign Dear reader, online ads enable us to deliver the journalism you value. Please support us by taking a moment to turn off Adblock on

Alert Sign Dear reader, please upgrade to the latest version of IE to have a better reading experience


Morsi’s ‘coup’


Your Name:

Recipient Email:

BUOYED up by his success in effecting a ceasefire in Gaza, President Mohamed Morsi has acted the wrong way — he has given himself sweeping powers in a move that the opposition calls “a coup against legitimacy”. The new decree issued on Thursday says decisions taken by the president cannot be overturned by any authority, including the courts. This negates the very spirit of the Arab Spring. Already, the president had enormous powers, because there is no legislature and he himself makes the laws. By pre-empting a judicial review of his actions, the president has armed himself with absolute powers. No wonder opposition leaders, who include such names as former Arab League secretary general Amr Moussa and Nobel laureate Mohamed ElBaradei, allege that the president has anointed himself “Egypt’s new pharaoh”. More menacingly, there is a hint of witch-hunting in his moves, because he has decided to reopen Hosni Mubarak’s trial and sacked chief prosecutor Abdel Meguid Mahmoud, a Mubarak loyalist. The charge against him was that he failed to secure adequate punishments for pro-Mubarak demonstrators who had attacked the security forces. He had earlier withdrawn his decision to fire Mr Mahmoud under pressure from Egypt’s powerful legal fraternity.

An acute and dangerous polarisation could grip Egypt, because Muslim Brotherhood activists have demonstrated in the decree’s favour, while the opposition has begun street protests and attacked Muslim Brotherhood offices. On Thursday, shortly after the decree was announced, Muslim Brotherhood activists staged demonstrations in front of the main court building, demanding that the judiciary be “purified”. This is a disturbing development. Unless such demands for purges are discouraged in time, the country could head towards authoritarianism. At present, Egypt has no parliament, and a Brotherhood-dominated assembly is still drafting a new constitution. The absence of any constitutional and legal checks on a head of state who already wields executive and legislative powers could throttle democracy, strengthen totalitarian tendencies and dash the populist hopes for which the people of Egypt had launched a valiant struggle against a despotic regime. As an opposition leader said, the anti Mubarak stir was not launched “in search of a benign dictator”.

Comments (12) Closed

Sakina Qamar (@SakinaQamar) Nov 24, 2012 09:39am
Well, this goes to prove once again that a Muslim man can never not abuse power. When will we learn that democracy, total accountability and secularism are the tools to prosperity? Without the absence of any one of them, you'll always be on the path of destruction, like we all are right now.
Shahid Nov 25, 2012 07:59am
No wonder muslims are in this state of affairs the world over. Some how our leaders wheather from military, kings or so called democrats cant stomach the power they get and immediately set out to entrench themselves as absolute rulers. They forget absolute is Allah Almighty only and the likes of Qaddafi, Mubarak, Zia ul Hq, ZA Bhutto have met a sorrow fate. May Allah bless us with the wisdom to acknowledge that absolute power lies with Allah and the ruler is only menat to work for the betterment of his people.
Shah Nov 25, 2012 06:00pm
Morsi?s current decree is aimed towards protecting the revolution. One should not forget that he has assumed this authority till the formation of new parliament. Supreme judicial counsel, which was formed by Husni Mubarak, has already dissolved a parliament and Egypt can not afford another coup on the constitution making process undertaken by Morsi, for it would further prolong the transition. When an army dictator grab all powers from an elected premier it is never titled as a coup, then why an elected president, who came after a long dictatorship and revolution is accused of coup ?
Vigilant Nov 24, 2012 08:49am
Trading one dictator for another
ahmed41 Nov 24, 2012 06:07am
EGYPT~~~~~~~~~from the frying pan into the fire. No genuine democratic spirit in the Arab SPRING
Aj Nov 25, 2012 09:11am
Give him some time and at least let him frame the constitution.i believe he will make a constitution on the basis of sharia (some call it talibanisation or whatever)
ahsan Nov 24, 2012 08:56am
Taliban, Pasdaran, Brotherhood...No mullah is different from any other.......never ever trust them with power..or for that matter, with anything
Aj Nov 25, 2012 09:20am
may i know what kind of powers does an american president enjoy???
gfellow Nov 24, 2012 04:13pm
True colors of muslim brotherhood now are coming forward. This is what everybody was afriad of
Aamir Nov 24, 2012 01:48pm
I can see a Zia ul Haq comming up in Egypt with a "trust me I promise thee......"
kanchis93 Nov 24, 2012 05:56am
Any time the powers of the state are concentrated in one or a few individuals, the powers that be playing the great game will be tempted to influence and control such people. Sadly, one can say that Egypt is the loser here.
kanchi Nov 24, 2012 05:53am
Any time the powers of the state are concentrated in one or a few individuals, it will be tempting for the powers playing the great game to influence and control such powerful individuals for the benefit of the powers. sadly one can say Egypt is the loser here.