LAHORE: An investigation team has alleged serious negligence by doctors and other staff of the Nishtar Hospital, where dozens of kidney patients have been infected with HIV/AIDS, according to officials.

The probe body was formed after reports that a patient suffering from kidney failure died while 30 others contracted Hu­­man Im­­m­unodeficiency Virus (HIV)/Acqui­red Im­­mu­no­defi­ciency Syndrome (AIDS) infections during dialysis treatment at the largest public sector hospital in south Punjab.

The fact-finding committee constituted by the Punjab government has confirmed the outbreak of HIV/AIDS in the hospital’s nephrology unit.

The committee included the Pu­­n­jab Human Organ Trans­planta­ti­­on Authority DG, Punjab Aids Con­trol Programme project director, Services Institute of Medical Sciences head of nephrology, and an official of the Specialized Healthcare and Medical Education Department.

Probe body finds violations of guidelines, SOPs during dialysis; Nishtar university vice chancellor rejects findings

The official told Dawn that strict SOPs were followed in hospitals across the world in pre- and post-dialysis assessment.

These SOPs were violated by the Nishtar Hospital staff and serious negligence was identified by the committee.

The claim has been rejected by the Nishtar Medical University (NMU) vice chancellor.

The official told Dawn that universal precautions like ensuring that dialysis machines were sterilised properly and safe for blood transfusions were not followed, which may have led to the potential risks of spreading HIV.

The institute had not properly performed tests on patients for dialysis at the hospital for the past year.

Patients’ medical records were not documented as per the standard guidelines to ensure they were not carrying infections before starting dialysis sessions.

The official said infection control committees are a key part of hospitals’ patient safety program­mes. The committee at Nishtar Hospital had not met for the last many months to assess the prevention and control of infections and ensure that the materials, products, and medical equipment were safe.

The report has been submitted to the provincial government for further action, the official said, adding that the transmission of HIV/AIDs at a tertiary care hospital has brought “bad name to the country”.

International health organisations have shown serious reservations over the lack of adherence to the standard guidelines for patients’ safety.

VC rejects findings

The NMU vice chancellor, Prof Mehnaz Khakwani, has rejected the committee’s findings.

She said the patients could have been infected at private clinics they visit for blood tests and scre­ening. She ruled out the possibility that they were infected by dialysis machines at the Nishtar Hospital.

Prof Khakwani said the institute had taken on board the Aids Con­trol Programme to rev­iew the SOPs further to avoid such incidents.

‘Scapegoat’

The official said that NMU’s top management and hospital administration were reportedly trying to make junior residents and nurses a “scapegoat”.

The postgraduate residents and the nursing staff of the nephrology department were being “pressured” into taking culpability for the negligence and submitting written apologies.

The official said that this was an attempt to “rescue” the head of the nephrology department and other senior medics of the university. There are also reports that Punjab Chief Minister Maryam Nawaz Sharif will visit the Nishtar Hospital in connection with the incident.

Published in Dawn, November 20th, 2024

Opinion

In fight mode

In fight mode

The bouts between political parties and establishment take a toll on country far more than they do on political parties.

Editorial

Meltdown
08 Apr, 2025

Meltdown

A full-blown trade war is upon us as the era of the rules-based, multilateral trading order is nearly over.
Settling differences
Updated 08 Apr, 2025

Settling differences

Unless there is a broad agreement on the path forward, the country will remain trapped in a cycle of recurring instability.
Glacial ingenuity
08 Apr, 2025

Glacial ingenuity

NECESSITY is indeed the mother of invention, as witnessed in Gilgit-Baltistan. In these areas, where climate change...
Going dry
Updated 07 Apr, 2025

Going dry

Authorities should refrain from undertaking any water scheme that infringes on rights of any federating unit to avoid more controversies.
Afghan return
07 Apr, 2025

Afghan return

AS expected, the government of Pakistan is moving ahead with its plan to forcibly repatriate Afghan Citizenship Card...
Hurting women
07 Apr, 2025

Hurting women

MONTH after month, the figures of crimes against women in the country indicate that our society is close to...