Mexico becomes first country to approve popular election of judges

Published September 12, 2024
Miguel Angel Yunes Linares and his son Miguel Angel Yunes Marquez look on after members of Mexico’s Senate passed the highly contested proposal on judicial reform presented by the government of President Andres Lopez Obrador, in Mexico City, Mexico September 11, 2024 — Reuters
Miguel Angel Yunes Linares and his son Miguel Angel Yunes Marquez look on after members of Mexico’s Senate passed the highly contested proposal on judicial reform presented by the government of President Andres Lopez Obrador, in Mexico City, Mexico September 11, 2024 — Reuters

MEXICO CITY: Mexico became the world’s first country to allow voters to elect judges at all levels on Wednesday, after protesters invaded the upper house and suspended debate on the issue.

Outgoing President Andres Manuel Lopez Obrador had pushed hard for the reform and criticised the current judicial system for serving the interests of the political and economic elite.

The reform was approved with 86 votes in favor and 41 against, garnering the two-thirds majority needed to amend the constitution, in an upper chamber dominated by the ruling Morena party and its allies. Debate on the reform had sparked mass demonstrations, diplomatic tensions and investor jitters.

Senate leader Gerardo Fernandez Norona declared a recess after demonstrators stormed the upper house and entered the chamber, chanting “The judiciary will not fall.” Lawmakers were forced to move to a former Senate building, where they resumed their debate as demonstrators outside shouted “Mr Senator, stop the dictator!” Obrador, who wanted the bill approved before he is replaced by close ally Claudia Sheinbaum on Oct 1, said that protesters were protecting the interests of the political elite.

“What most worries those who are against this reform is that they will lose their privileges, because the judiciary is at the service of the powerful, at the service of white-collar crime,” the leftist leader said at a news conference.

‘Demolition of the judiciary’

Opponents, including court employees and law students, have held a series of protests against the plan, under which even Supreme Court and other high-level judges, as well as those at the local level, would be chosen by popular vote.

Around 1,600 judges would have to stand for election in 2025 or 2027. “This does not exist in any other country,” said Margaret Satterthwaite, United Nations special rapporteur on the independence of judges and lawyers.

“In some countries, such as the US, some state judges are elected, and in others, such as in Bolivia, high-level judges are elected,” she said. Mexico’s overhaul puts it “in a unique position in terms of its method for judicial selection,” Satterthwaite said ahead of the vote.

In an unusual public warning, Supreme Court chief justice Norma Pina said that elected judges could be more vulnerable to pressure from criminals, in a country where powerful drug cartels regularly use bribery and intimidation to influence officials. “The demolition of the judiciary is not the way forward,” she said in a video released on Sunday.

Pina said last week that the top court would discuss whether it has jurisdiction to halt the reforms, though Lopez Obrador has said there is no legal basis for it to do so. The reforms were passed last week in the lower house by ruling party lawmakers and their allies, who were forced to gather in a sports centre because access to Congress was blocked by protesters.

Published in Dawn, September 12th, 2024

Opinion

Editorial

Disaffected voices
11 Oct, 2024

Disaffected voices

A FRESH stand-off is brewing between the state, and the recently banned PTM, principally over the tribal jirga that...
Joint anti-smog steps
11 Oct, 2024

Joint anti-smog steps

CLIMATE change knows no borders. Hence, much of the world is striving to control the rapidly rising global...
Agri taxes
11 Oct, 2024

Agri taxes

IT is not a good omen that reforms are once again being delayed. According to the finance minister, a new tax regime...
Mental wellness
Updated 10 Oct, 2024

Mental wellness

On this World Mental Health Day, the message is clear: mental health at work must become a priority.
IHK poll results
10 Oct, 2024

IHK poll results

AN interesting political arrangement has emerged after polls concluded in India-held Kashmir. It appears that the...
Demonstrating intent
10 Oct, 2024

Demonstrating intent

THE finance minister appears confident about the direction his ministry is taking and seems firmly committed to...