THE case of Khadija Shah, a prominent PTI supporter, has once again brought the prolonged detention of PTI women into sharp focus. Ms Shah, who had been granted bail in the last of her cases relating to the May 9 protests, has now been handed over to Quetta police. This development raises serious questions about the motives behind her continued detention — which has lasted more than six months — and the treatment of jailed PTI women in general. Ms Shah’s legal troubles, following her alleged involvement in the May 9 protests, have been marked by a series of detentions and rearrests, highlighting a troubling pattern of harassment and intimidation. The HRCP has strongly criticised the decision to grant Quetta police her transitory remand, noting that it appears to be a continuation of harassment, especially given Ms Shah’s separation from her children. Ms Shah has, in an open letter, shared heart-wrenching stories of separation and suffering among the detainees, emphasising the heavy toll of these long-drawn-out imprisonments. The issue has also echoed in the Senate, where concerns have been raised about the rights and freedoms of political rivals and activists.

The state’s handling of Ms Shah’s case and those of other PTI women highlights a need for transparency and adherence to the rule of law. The repeated rearrests and lack of clear legal processes not only undermine the credibility of the justice system but also raise concerns about political vendetta. Those who wield this sword of political vendetta so wantonly would do well to remember that when the winds change, the sword may swing the other way. Therefore, it is crucial for the authorities to ensure due process and fair treatment, particularly in politically sensitive cases. The situation demands reflection and a re-evaluation of the approach towards political detainees. Upholding the rights and freedoms of all citizens, regardless of political affiliation, is essential for the health of our democracy.

Published in Dawn, December 13th, 2023