Chastening comments

Published October 21, 2022

INDIA has built a slick, PR-backed image of itself as a ‘shining’ country, a sort of giant amongst nations. But as chastening observations made by the UN secretary general during a visit to the country have illustrated, much remains to be done where the rights of minorities in the country are concerned.

António Guterres termed India a “partner of choice” of the UN. Yet other comments made by the global body’s chief were far less flattering. Mr Guterres called upon New Delhi to “protect … the rights of all individuals, including members of minority communities”, while urging his host country to nurture and strengthen diversity.

He also asked India to do more to advance gender equality and protect women’s rights, while calling upon the state to take “concrete actions” to protect the rights of journalists, activists, students and academics — who have all faced the wrath of the Hindutva state.

It is not too difficult to understand what motivated the UN chief’s observations. After all, ever since the BJP took power in 2014, India’s minorities, particularly its Muslims, as well as other citizens who disagree with the Sangh Parivar’s blinkered vision have had a rough ride. Indian Muslims have been lynched, and seen their homes bulldozed, while discriminatory laws have been passed to disenfranchise millions of them. Moreover, government officials and senior members of the ruling party have made incendiary comments about Muslims, as well as Islam’s sanctities.

Read: No place to pray — Muslim worshippers under pressure in India

India’s brutal tactics in held Kashmir have also been widely condemned. And while Pakistan, as well as independent watchdogs such as Human Rights Watch and Amnesty International, has called out New Delhi for these transgressions, the Indian PR machinery has brushed aside these concerns as partisan statements or meddling. Yet when the UN secretary general raises these concerns, Indian spin doctors will have a harder time brushing them under the carpet.

Mr Guterres praised Gandhi and Nehru during his Indian visit. The problem is that many in today’s India, piloted by the BJP, idolise Godse, Gandhi’s killer, as well as Savarkar, the rabid ideologue who fathered the concept of Hindutva, a toxic mix of Hindu extremism and European fascism, and who despised the Nehruvian vision for India. But the fact is that India is very sensitive about its ‘branding’, especially when powerful foreign entities chide it for its transgressions. That is why comments such as the ones made by the UN chief are important, perhaps to help change the Indian rulers’ behaviour.

Other powerful actors, such as the US and EU, also need to call out India’s bad behaviour, and not mollycoddle New Delhi in the hopes of using it to get even with China. Perhaps such criticism could eventually help loosen Hindutva’s grip over India and pave the way for a more moderate atmosphere in which minorities are treated like human beings, and friendship is pursued with neighbouring states.

Published in Dawn, October 21st, 2022

Opinion

Editorial

Soaring again
Updated 18 Jul, 2025

Soaring again

The lifting of the ban by the UK will lead to several welcome developments.
Terror in Kalat
18 Jul, 2025

Terror in Kalat

THE unrest in Balochistan is increasingly taking on an ugly and dangerous colour, with repeated, indiscriminate...
Economic exclusion
18 Jul, 2025

Economic exclusion

FOR all the progress made in Pakistan towards the inclusion of women across the sociopolitical divide, comprehensive...
Digital gaps
Updated 17 Jul, 2025

Digital gaps

Digital technology affords Pakistan a unique opportunity to transform itself into a dynamic digital economy.
A grave matter
17 Jul, 2025

A grave matter

IT is a weighty issue, and one which many would not touch with a barge pole, primarily out of concern for...
Vaccine paradox
17 Jul, 2025

Vaccine paradox

PAKISTAN has recorded its highest-ever coverage of the DTP vaccine — protecting children against diphtheria,...