Unequal citizens

Published May 25, 2022

INDIFFERENCE would have been bad enough, but the state’s attitude towards non-Muslims falls squarely in the category of religious discrimination to the extent of considering them as being less than human. It is a shameful indictment of the promise upon which this country came into being nearly 75 years ago, when it pledged to protect its minorities and treat them on a par with the rest of its citizenry. According to a report compiled by the National Commission for Human Rights, with support from the EU, nearly half the posts reserved for religious minorities in government jobs are vacant and — to add insult to injury — 80pc of the non-Muslims who have been appointed under the 5pc quota for them are working in low-paid sanitation jobs. The document, titled Unequal Citizens: Ending Systemic Discrimination Against Minorities, highlights a slew of other problems that many non-Muslims in government jobs related to garbage disposal and sewerage management face every time they show up for work in return for a pittance. These include hazardous working conditions, inadequate safety gear and equipment, lack of job security and low compensation to those injured or the families of those who die in the course of their work.

The report should be a much-needed wakeup call for a state that is failing spectacularly in its constitutional and international obligations towards an entire section of the citizenry. According to the NCHR, between 2011 and 2021, more than 65pc of sanitary workers who died while unclogging gutters belonged to minority communities. Repeatedly, concerned citizens have pointed out that notices advertising government posts for sanitation workers display blatant faith-based discrimination by clearly stating that only non-Muslims need apply — as though these tasks essential for keeping our environs clean and disease-free are beneath Muslims. In September last year, the Supreme Court had asked the government why 30,000 jobs set aside for non-Muslims were still vacant. And yet, this institutionalised discrimination persists in our society, furthering a majoritarian mindset that then becomes a breeding ground for other problems.

Published in Dawn, May 25th, 2022

Opinion

Editorial

Digital deal
19 Jun, 2026

Digital deal

THINGS have moved rapidly where the Iran-US memorandum of understanding is concerned. While the physical document ...
Failing the public
19 Jun, 2026

Failing the public

WHETHER it is Sindh’s struggle to secure clean drinking water or Balochistan’s difficulty in improving the...
Crushed lives
19 Jun, 2026

Crushed lives

COURTS and commissions have often been up in arms over the health and ecological hazards associated with...
Words that wound
Updated 18 Jun, 2026

Words that wound

Hate speech rarely begins with physical attacks.
‘New urban province’
18 Jun, 2026

‘New urban province’

CONSIDERING the advance state of urban decay that affects Karachi, voices are often raised calling for the megacity,...
Punjab budget: mixed bag
18 Jun, 2026

Punjab budget: mixed bag

PUNJAB’S budget for FY27 is a mix of good and bad political choices, with a cash-strapped centre tightening the...