Ex-SA skipper Graeme Smith hits back at race bias claims

Published August 15, 2020
CSA cricket director and former captain Graeme Smith is accused of allowing black players to feel isolated during his time as captain. — AFP/File
CSA cricket director and former captain Graeme Smith is accused of allowing black players to feel isolated during his time as captain. — AFP/File

JOHANNESBURG: Former South Africa captain Graeme Smith late on Thursday responded to allegations of bias against black players by stating that he had ‘personal relationship challenges’ with several other players during his time in charge.

Smith, currently Cricket South Africa (CSA)’s director of cricket, has come under fire in recent weeks for appointing former Test wicket-keeper Mark Boucher as national team coach.

He has also been accused of allowing black players to feel isolated during his time as captain.

Smith, who captained South Africa in a world record 108 Test matches from 2003 until 2014, as well as 149 One-day Internationals, said he realised early in his captaincy that it would not be possible to please everyone in his team.

Former wicket-keeper Thami Tsolekile was particularly critical of Smith during a radio interview on Tuesday, blaming Smith for keeping him out of the Test team after Boucher suffered a career-ending injury on a 2012 tour of England.

Fast bowler Makhaya Ntini earlier said he felt ‘lonely’ as a player despite playing in 101 Tests and he also felt he was unfairly dropped from the team towards the end of his career.

Although Tsolekile, who has subsequently been banned for 12 years for his role in a match-fixing scandal in a domestic competition, was in the squad as a reserve wicket-keeper, the gloves were handed to leading batsman A.B. de Villiers.

“I look at many respected captains around the world and there are plenty of players who felt they were not given a fair chance,” said Smith in a statement which he said was issued in his personal capacity.

He said Australia’s Steve Waugh was an example of a highly regarded captain who had his detractors from former team-mates.

Smith cited Shaun Pollock and Lance Klusener as two leading players who were dropped from the team before they were ready to retire. “There were very emotional discussions because they are both legends of our cricket history.”

He said Pollock and Ntini had to make way in similar circumstances because South Africa were seeking more bowling firepower.

Smith added that he personally was ‘gutted’ when he was not selected for the 2003 World Cup — he eventually came into the squad as an injury replacement — and again later in his career when he was dropped from the one-day side.

“I felt I still had more to give in ODI cricket but [replacement] Quinton de Kock has shown that it was his time,” he said. “And, over time, I have grown to understand that it was the right call for the team. And that has always been the crux of the decisions made in my time.”

Smith sympathised with Tsolekile because wicket-keeping was a specialist role and it was a trend in international cricket for wicket-keepers to have long careers, keeping other capable glovemen out of the team.

He said the decision to pick de Villiers ahead of Tsolekile in 2012 was made by ‘a whole panel of selectors’ and that then-head coach Gary Kirsten had told Tsolekile he was reserve to de Villiers following Boucher’s injury.

In recent weeks, a group of former black players and coaches have criticised events in South African cricket, including the appointment of Boucher as national coach ahead of black coaches who have stronger formal coaching credentials.

Boucher has only a level two coaching certificate which is given to former players without having to attend courses.

The group, describing themselves as ‘concerned former cricketers and coaches’ had a virtual meeting with the board of Cricket South Africa last weekend.

Smith said allegations and insinuations against him were “extremely hurtful and I deny them in the strongest possible sense.”

Published in Dawn, August 15th, 2020


Police & prosecution
16 Jan 2021

Police & prosecution

Yasin Malik’s case is a revealing example of Modi’s political vendetta.
Changes in privacy policy
16 Jan 2021

Changes in privacy policy

It is indeed a blunder by WhatsApp to move towards a model that is less private than before.
A national dialogue?
15 Jan 2021

A national dialogue?

Fundamental reforms are needed to change the ‘system of spoils’, not save it.


16 Jan 2021

Gas liberalisation

AFTER drawing much criticism from both consumers and the opposition over its mismanagement of the energy sector that...
16 Jan 2021

Osama Satti inquiry

THE findings of the judicial inquiry into the Jan 2 killing of 21-year-old Osama Satti in Islamabad merely confirms...
Updated 16 Jan 2021

British MP on IHK

DESPITE sustained efforts by New Delhi’s rulers to remove India-held Kashmir from the global discourse, people of...
Updated 15 Jan 2021

Trump’s impeachment

The impeachment move may well remain symbolic in nature; even then, the symbolism itself is a potent one.
15 Jan 2021

Economic growth

MOODY’S Investors Service expects Pakistan’s economy to grow by a modest 1.5pc in FY2021, much higher than the...
15 Jan 2021

Madressah students

GETTING students of madressahs involved in politics is a bad idea, primarily because seminarians should be...