Amazon France under fire for destroying unsold goods

Published January 15, 2019
Brune Poirson, a secretary of state for France’s ecological transition, said after the broadcast late Sunday that she was “shocked” by the allegations and would render businesses “responsible” for such practices. ─ File photo
Brune Poirson, a secretary of state for France’s ecological transition, said after the broadcast late Sunday that she was “shocked” by the allegations and would render businesses “responsible” for such practices. ─ File photo

PARIS: US online retailer Amazon faced new French government pressure on Monday after a TV report over the weekend showed it destroying thousands of new diapers, toys and other unsold or returned items in perfect condition.

Brune Poirson, a secretary of state for France’s ecological transition, said after the broadcast late Sunday that she was “shocked” by the allegations and would render businesses “responsible” for such practices.

“In the coming months a law will be passed in parliament that will outlaw this type of activity. Companies like Amazon will no longer be able to throw away products that can still be used,” Poirson said.

The “Capital” programme on M6 television showed footage from a journalist who got himself hired recently at Amazon’s distribution centre in Saran, outside Orleans in central France.

He was able to film workers throwing dozens of coffee makers, unopened Lego boxes and brand-name packs of diapers into huge garbage containers, instead of recycling or donating them to charity.

The report also showed drone footage of discarded items headed to incinerators or landfills, which environmental activists denounced as an “ecological disaster.” Destroying unsold goods is allowed under Amazon’s contracts with sellers on its “Marketplace” platform, which hosts third-party retailers who often have stock in Amazon warehouses.

It is often cheaper to destroy the goods than sending them back to producers or organising their distribution to charities, experts say.

Contacted by AFP, Amazon France said it does its best to reduce the number of products that must be returned to third-party vendors.

“For those products that can’t be resold, we work with organisations like Solidarity Giving and the Food Bank so they can be given to people in need,” the retailing giant said.

But Poirson said the government intended to hold Amazon accountable for the proper disposal of unsold goods.

“We want to consider ‘marketplaces’ like Amazon’s responsible by default for the outcome of the products they offer,” she said.

Amazon has faced similar accusations in Germany, where national weekly WirtschaftsWoche and broadcaster ZDF reported last June that huge amounts of as-new and returned goods from mobile phones to refrigerators were routinely destroyed.

Published in Dawn, January 15th, 2019

Follow Dawn Business on Twitter, LinkedIn, Instagram and Facebook for insights on business, finance and tech from Pakistan and across the world.

Opinion

Editorial

Genocide resumes
Updated 19 Mar, 2025

Genocide resumes

It appears that Palestinian people will again be left defenceless in the face of merciless brutality.
Strength in unity
19 Mar, 2025

Strength in unity

WILL it count as an opportunity lost? Given the sharp escalation in militant violence in recent weeks, some had ...
NFC weightage
19 Mar, 2025

NFC weightage

THE NFC Award has long been in need of an overhaul. The government’s proposal to bring down the weightage of...
A new direction
Updated 18 Mar, 2025

A new direction

While kinetic response may temporarily disable violent actors, it will not address underlying factors providing ideological fuel to insurgencies.
BTK settlement
18 Mar, 2025

BTK settlement

WHEREVER the money goes, controversy follows. The PMLN-led federal government, which recently announced that it will...
Sugar crisis
18 Mar, 2025

Sugar crisis

GREED knows no bounds. But the avarice of those involved in the sugar business — from manufacturers to retailers...