A measured response

Published January 3, 2018

US PRESIDENT Donald Trump’s freewheeling Twitter habit has caused a fresh eruption in Pak-US ties in the new year.

Mr Trump’s rough and undiplomatic language has sparked outrage in Pakistan, but it is not clear if the US president was presaging renewed pressure on Pakistan or simply indulging in rhetorical threats that appeal to his isolationist political base at home.

Yet, a hostile, threatening comment by a US president cannot simply be ignored, and Pakistan’s political and military leaderships did the right thing by meeting to discuss a joint civil-military response.

At the very least, Mr Trump’s Twitter salvo aimed at Pakistan suggests that he does not mind further undermining Pak-US ties — a situation that ought to be of concern for all Pakistanis, regardless of whether they view the US with suspicion or relative warmth.

What is also clear is that Mr Trump, like his predecessors since the US-led war in Afghanistan began more than 16 years ago, views Pakistan through the prism of Afghanistan.

With nearly 16,000 US troops in that country, several thousand of whom Mr Trump himself has sent, the course of the war could have a bearing on the American leader’s presidency. It is on that reality that the Pakistani leadership should focus.

Helping find a path to a political deal between Kabul and the Afghan Taliban would help end the war there and obviate the need for the US administration to lean heavily on Pakistan.

Clearly, what has not been achieved in 16 years will not be achieved soon, but Pakistan should not be distracted from creating the conditions, with the US or perhaps without its initial support, for an eventual peace deal in Afghanistan.

There is no scenario in which crumbling ties between the US and Pakistan, because of intemperate remarks by the US president, are good for Afghanistan, Pakistan or the region.

Admirably, the National Security Committee has struck the right note in its response to Mr Trump’s provocation.

Underscoring Pakistan’s contributory role to the regional fight against militancy and avoiding a slanging match with the US, it has emphasised that Pakistan will continue to seek cooperative solutions to regional problems.

In the past, Pakistan has to its own disadvantage stoked anti-US sentiment as a bulwark against US demands. But anti-Americanism, loudest in the extremist fringe, is difficult to contain once an episode between the US and Pakistan is resolved, and creates further problems inside Pakistan while limiting the room for the state to manoeuvre in the complicated relationship with the US.

Perhaps, as other countries are discovering, the Pakistani leadership has recognised a Trump tweet for what it could be: an outburst that may not eventually figure in the US policy process.

It’s more a testament of the trouble the US is in that a presidential tweet can be regarded as incoherent ramblings.

Published in Dawn, January 3rd, 2018

Opinion

Editorial

Afghan flare-up
Updated 07 Dec, 2025

Afghan flare-up

THE fragile ceasefire between Pakistan and Afghanistan has been tested yet again, this time with an exchange of fire...
Neglecting food safety
07 Dec, 2025

Neglecting food safety

FOOD adulteration is a major public health concern in Pakistan — in both remote and major urban centres. A report...
Con jobs
07 Dec, 2025

Con jobs

PAKISTAN’s perfect storm of issues — unemployment, few opportunities and a failing economy — offer a field day...
Fiscal concerns
Updated 06 Dec, 2025

Fiscal concerns

Talks on the 11th Award have opened at a politically charged moment amid attempts by the centre to undo the constitutional protection given to the existing provincial share under the NFC Award.
Hero worship
06 Dec, 2025

Hero worship

IT seems that, like public representatives, our national heroes will also be selected for us. The Senate deputy...
KU institute
06 Dec, 2025

KU institute

THE Sindh government’s decision to separate the Institute for Chemical and Biological Sciences from Karachi...