An unspoken ordeal: Rape and 'forgiveness' in Pakistan's madressahs

Updated November 21, 2017

Email

In this picture taken on May 4, 2017, Saima Khan* comforts her child who was allegedly raped by a religious cleric in Kehror Pakka, Pakistan. ─ AP
In this picture taken on May 4, 2017, Saima Khan* comforts her child who was allegedly raped by a religious cleric in Kehror Pakka, Pakistan. ─ AP

Saima Khan* struggles through tears as she remembers the blood-soaked pants of her 9-year-old son, allegedly raped by a religious cleric. Each time she begins to speak, she stops, swallows hard, wipes her tears and begins again.

The boy fidgets with his scarf and looks over at his mother.

“Did he touch you?” He nods. “Did he hurt you when he touched you?” “Yes,” he whispers.

“Did he rape you?” He buries his face in his scarf and nods yes.

Sexual abuse is a pervasive and longstanding problem at madressahs in Pakistan, an Associated Press investigation has found. But in a culture where clerics are powerful, it is seldom discussed or even acknowledged in public.

Saima* recounts the ordeal of her son in Kehror Pakka, Pakistan. ─ AP
Saima* recounts the ordeal of her son in Kehror Pakka, Pakistan. ─ AP

It is even more seldom prosecuted, according to the investigation, based on police documents and dozens of interviews with victims, families, officials and aid groups.

Police are often paid off not to pursue justice against clerics, victims' families say. And cases rarely make it past the courts, because the legal system allows the victim's family to “forgive” the offender and accept what is often referred to as diyat (blood money).

A tally of cases reported in newspapers over the past 10 years of sexual abuse by clerics and other religious officials came to 359.

Rana Mohammad Jamal talks about an alleged rape attempt on a girl by a cleric in Kahror Pakka, Lodhran. He said, "This is a genuine case but the family took money to not speak about it." His voice and the voices of those who had gathered outside the girl's home grew softer as they spoke about the nearby madressah, which they said was not registered. — AP
Rana Mohammad Jamal talks about an alleged rape attempt on a girl by a cleric in Kahror Pakka, Lodhran. He said, "This is a genuine case but the family took money to not speak about it." His voice and the voices of those who had gathered outside the girl's home grew softer as they spoke about the nearby madressah, which they said was not registered. — AP

That represents “barely the tip of the iceberg,” says Munizae Bano, executive director of Sahil, an organisation that scours the newspapers for such cases.

In 2004, an official disclosed more than 500 complaints of sexual assaults against young boys in madressahs. He has since refused to talk.

Two officials familiar with the madressahs said sexual abuse there happens all the time. They asked to remain anonymous for fear of retribution from militant groups. One compared the situation to the abuse of children by priests in the Catholic Church.

“There are thousands of incidences of sexual abuse in the madressahs,” he says. “This thing is very common...I am not sure what it will take to expose the extent of it. It's very dangerous to even try.”

Denial

Religious Affairs Minister Sardar Muhammad Yousaf dismisses the suggestion that sexual abuse is widespread, saying such talk is an attempt to malign the religion, seminaries and clerics.

He acknowledges that it could occur occasionally “because there are criminals everywhere.”

The Interior Ministry, which oversees madressahs, refused repeated written and telephone requests for an interview.

More than 22,000 registered madressahs in Pakistan teach at least 2 million students, often among the country's poorest, who receive food and an education for free.

Thousands more madressahs are unregistered and operate without scrutiny, like the one attended by Saima's son.

Read: Pakistan’s Hidden Shame: Documentary reveals horrors of paedophilia in KP

When offending clerics pay police off, they refuse to even register a case, according to the victims' families.

The families involved are often poor and powerless.

“We are being pressured to compromise,” says a man from Punjab. His younger brother says he was sexually assaulted at a madressah by a cleric who threatened to kill his family if he told.

Multan Deputy Inspector General (DIG) Police Sultan Azam Temuri denies that pressure from clerics or powerful politicians prompts police to go easy in such cases.

He says cases are investigated when allegations are made. Temuri says his department is trying to tackle child abuse in general with the introduction of gender and child protection services.

Forced forgiveness?

Victims and their families can also choose to “forgive” an assailant because Pakistan's legal system is a mix of British Common Law and Shariah law.

A Pakistani boy who was allegedly raped by a cleric sits before villagers in Vehari. ─ AP
A Pakistani boy who was allegedly raped by a cleric sits before villagers in Vehari. ─ AP

A similar legal provision was changed last year to prevent forgiveness of “honour” killings, where victims are murdered because they are thought to have brought shame on their families. Honour killings now carry a mandatory sentence of life in prison, but clerics in sexual abuse cases can still be forgiven.

Victims and their families often come under intense pressure to “forgive” the crime, or essentially settle for money. Many do, partly because they don't believe they have the power to do anything else.

Sahil offers families legal aid to pursue such cases. Last year, Sahil found 56 cases of sexual assault involving religious clerics. Yet, none of the families accepted Sahil's offer of legal assistance.

Read: Rape and Terror

The story of Saima's son, who says he was raped by his teacher in Kahror Pakka, Lodhran shows how difficult it is to get justice in cases of sexual abuse at madressahs.

At the courthouse in Kahror Pakka, the former cleric waited his turn to go before a judge. A half dozen members of the militant organisation Sipah-i-Sahaba Pakistan (SSP) were there to support the teacher.

The handcuffed cleric who allegedly raped a child stands outside a court in Kehror Pakka. ─ AP
The handcuffed cleric who allegedly raped a child stands outside a court in Kehror Pakka. ─ AP

They scowled and moved closer when an AP reporter sat next to the teacher, who was shackled to a half dozen other prisoners. The whispers grew louder and more insistent.

“It's too dangerous here,” said one person, looking over at the militants nearby. “Leave. Leave the courthouse, they can do anything here.” The teacher had already confessed, according to police, and the police report said he was found with the boy. Yet, he swore his innocence in court.

“I am married, why would I do this?” he said.

In the end, the mother, Saima, “forgave” the cleric and accepted approximately Rs30,000, according to police. The cleric was set free.

*Names have been changed to conceal identities.