A deafening silence

Published October 7, 2017

It was a political tour de force, a performance worthy of an information minister in a democratic regime.

Maj Gen Asif Ghafoor’s news conference at the ISPR headquarters on Thursday was remarkable for the ground that was covered — and, crucially, for what was left unsaid.

This much is obvious: the DG ISPR was not riffing, ad-libbing or speaking off the cuff; his remarks were carefully prepared and his answers hewed to a carefully prepared script. Maj Gen Ghafoor’s comments, then, almost certainly reflect the consensus view of the current military leadership on the range of national security, foreign policy, domestic politics and legislative issues that he expounded on. Which in and of itself has raised a profound question: why has the military leadership deemed it necessary to weigh in publicly on such a range of issues at this time?

There may be a temptation to view the intrusion into the civilian domain merely in the context of the current political crisis in the country. But a historical perspective would suggest that the intrusion is nothing new and indeed goes back to the very earliest years of the republic. Rare has been the occasion that the opposite was true.

The resignation of Gen Jahangir Karamat more than two decades ago had suggested that a clearer demarcation of the respective civilian and military domains may be possible, but that incident was soon overtaken by a second-term prime minister Nawaz Sharif’s tinkering with the military high command.

There is also the unfortunate reality that the civilians have at times willingly ceded space — willing to trade constitutional prerogatives for a bit of political longevity. Undoubtedly, the pressure at the very top is intense, but a true democratic leadership would fight harder for principle than self-interest.

For all of Maj Gen Ghafoor’s extensive comments and emphatic clarity, there was puzzling reticence on one matter. When asked why there had been no press release after a marathon corps commanders’ conference on Tuesday, the DG ISPR only offered that “Silence is also an expression”.

Whether by design or inadvertently, the comment set off a storm of political speculation. Is the military leadership suggesting disapproval of the PML-N government and its seeming quest to return Mr Sharif to a front-line role in politics despite judicial misgivings?

Indeed, the perceived significance of the news conference was precisely the intensive military deliberations at a time when Pakistan is facing great uncertainty in its relations with the US and the country has a political government that has effectively stalled.

A deliberate silence should not have been an option. Be that as it may, the PML-N government and the military leadership must independently and jointly recognise that the present level of uncertainty in the country is deeply undesirable and unsustainable. The Constitution is supreme and the Constitution is democratic — and all sides must re-emphasise their loyalty to it.

Published in Dawn, October 7th, 2017

Opinion

Editorial

An inexplicable delay
03 Oct, 2022

An inexplicable delay

AFTER a flurry of activity a couple of months ago, geared towards filling the vacancies in the apex court — an...
Dire situation
Updated 03 Oct, 2022

Dire situation

If there is any time for the civilian leadership to show unity, it is now.
Russian annexation
03 Oct, 2022

Russian annexation

AS Russia and the West play a zero-sum game in Ukraine, Moscow’s official annexation of four Ukrainian regions it...
Spy games
Updated 02 Oct, 2022

Spy games

The audios leaked so far appear to have been carefully curated: they apply pressure but do not do major damage.
‘Geopolitical football’
02 Oct, 2022

‘Geopolitical football’

THE US-China rivalry is by all measures one of the globe’s most dangerous competitions for power and influence. ...
Fuel price reduction
02 Oct, 2022

Fuel price reduction

ISHAQ Dar is back; so are his signature policies. The reduction of a little over 5pc in fuel prices announced by him...