Horrific!!! Keeping the people ignorant and institutions corrupt.

pathetic and horrible. may we as a nation, learn to condemn such horrible acts and mindsets

Such cases were registered in the past but without any result

Shame on the panchayat and on the people of that area who did nothing to stop this heinous crime.

Stone age tales. just sad.

it seems totally barbaric and jungle Law ,

we didnt learn much from Mukhtaran mai's case. no education no end to social injustice

How can people watch such horrific act?

Dreadful Incident. It reflects the societal attitude towards women. It also reflects the absence of rule of law, less trust of citizens' on institutions the gap between the state and citizens.

How can this still be happening in this day and age. These panchayats need some formal training

Salute to police officers

"raped before the men and her parents." what a disgusting society we live in. There is no law and order in our country, laws and punishment are for only poor and weak, wealthy and powerful escape the justice and yet our rulers cannot stop chanting empty slogans and rhetorical nonsense.

They givr the orders how to treat others but are so coward themselves hiding now.

Illiteracy, poverty and weak implementation of laws in the country are the main reasons behind such evil acts. Such incidents reflect the complete failure of the state and non-existence of rule of law. Non-state actors such as Panchayats and Jirga system must be declared illegal and banned. Chief Justice of Pakistan should take stern action against this parallel judicial systems in the country.

In our country Pakistan, poor and helpless women have always become victims of such parallel judicial systems and weak implementation of laws.

When poor illiterate people start trusting such wicked elders instead of law of land.

Any chance to make FIR system online? To verify the hand written FIR by police when it was written and cant be undone?

condemn we all but it is not going to work. The hammer of law should come down very hard on the perpetrators of such crimes while at the same time institutions building like local bodies at the gross root level must be done to rid the people of illegal and illiterate councils or panchaits.

Such pathetic plight of women is barbaric

such harmful crimes must be non bailable and should be decided in 7 days. the culprit should be punished in next 7 days after judgement. no bails, no mercy...

absolutely inhuman, this kind of behavior will only stop if people know what the consequences of such behavior will be. The culprits should pay a heavy price for this crime.

many of these panchayats decisions go un-noticed because people are afraid to stand up against them since they have yo live among them

What an irony.

@Akram wrong, your silence is why crimes continue and you know it. you're no different.

@The end is near Wrong, silence is.

O my God ! no... Reading the heading I thought Panchayat has just ordered this rubbish decision and police has filed case against them, but reading the news... it is too bad. Barbaric, demonic, no word is sufficient. I am frightened. I wish my sister recovers soon.

And the parents had to watch while their innocent daughter was violated by these disgusting savages! They must have died a thousand deaths.

Supreme court should take suo motto action, and accord exemplary punishment.

Education, education, education people we need to get our poor people educated so they know their rights.

@Qamar Cases are registered and maybe some people are arrested. Then after a while when people forget the incident, everyone goes back home.

Girls suffered.......in both the cases :(.....

We have to change our way of seeing things and that is the only solution. Just college and universities will not change much as most of these culpirits are well educated but do such things to exercise their control and power on local people.

This case should ideally be registered against the police officers who failed to identify such events in areas under their observance.

All the members of this wretched panchayet should be given life imprisonment.

These ignorant elders should know better that two wrongs don't make a right! Down right disgraceful, inhumane and anti Islamic!

Utterly disgusting and horrific! Shows the extreme moral decay in some of our rural areas where it's usually the woman that ends up paying the price for crimes committed by men close to her. Why not employ fundamental rules of justice and punish the actual perpetrators? The tribal justice system in these rural communities must not be allowed to try such sensitive cases. The state justice system must send a strong message by handing these panchayat members the punishment they deserve.

Disgusting and inhumane. People has to change their mindset to avoid such incidents. If more of religion and tradition gives this than may be society is better off without them. Worst in front of other people a small girl is raped as if it's normal. This tells lot about the society.

Ignorance, lack of education, local culture and revenge are some of contributory factors that initiate such shameful incidents. Also, having weak juderial system plays a part and encourage such incidents. We need to educate, create more awareness, provide protection and court facilities to change preset mindsets, and it's a slow process and not going to be easy. But we have to start from somewhere to change backward thinking!

What a panchayat! That shows the collective wisdom of the people in the area. Now multiply this kind of collective wisdom a few hundred times and you get to know the caliber of the Pakistani people. That should explain why Pakistan is in such a mess.

Put these uneducated panchayat guys in jail and keep them there forever.

Unacceptable. Disgusting. May God Almighty bring these twisted men to justice.

Deals all persons with iron hands according to the Law

Inbred peasants - wake up- it's 2017

Beyond the horror, it's important to look into the reasons why such things happen in Pakistan. Reason 1: lack of education Reason 2: No rule of Law (if the people had any confidence in the justice system of Pakistan, why would there be a panchayat in the first place)

From mukhtaran Mai case to this horrific incident, such crimes are increasing alarmingly , particularly in this south Punjab region . Most important thing is to find the causes of such mind set , what are factors which turns humans into wild animals. Government, please try to give education , add moral sciences as a subject in our curriculum,

Not only does the law need to to be visibly implemented to deter such barbaric acts, We also need better legislation to punish pedophiles... these acts are not only in contradiction of our religious and national norms, they also are in contradiction of humanity...

But then we also need non-corrupt polititians to formulate legislation and a judicial system that atleast appears to work!

@imran thanks for raising ur voice.

This is all because of lack of education. What are the chances that these council people will be made an example out of? Feeling bad for both girls.

@Tribal Malik That's the horrible truth you said. People are afraid to raise their voice against panchayat of their wrong doings as theyvthey've to live among them. The day Police start giving confidence to the people this whole nonsense will end. Politician's, Police Officials talk about people not coming to them to complain about the injustice but they never think that why these people are not coming to report the injustice done to them. We all blame the system for this mess but never do we think that this system was made by us(people), for our own greed we have let the whole system rot. The saddest part of all is that we expect someone else to do the necessary cleanliness work of the system but not ourselves by standing together & the keyboard warriors saying that this should be done & that shouldn't be done. The day we stand together will be the last for these crooked people on Earth. For your information, I'm an Indian. Hope this doesn't happen to anyone else in future.

@Pakistani Education doesn't mean that you're better. It's the inner conscience of one that matters. Even educated people acts are worse most of the time.

Punishing the weakest for the crimes of the strong and calling it justice. These men cannot be equated even to beasts.

We all Pakistani women and girls are waiting for the result of this very bad incident.these kind of Punchaits must be banned by the state.Female is the victim in both shameful incidents.

When will such barbaric practices end ?

Hope Governments will justify with her.... That's type of cases day by day increase government should take stable action on it, its major responsibilities of Law and order.

Sad story. Don't know how the system allows back-to-back incidents of this kind. If this goes unchecked by the authorities, it is going to take forever to fix the system and public confidence goes to gutter.

We often talk about education, but what kind of education should we get nobody talks about that. We often cite lack of education as a reason for such heinous crimes against humanity. But was Mashal murdered by uneducated? No, he was murdered at an institution of higher learning and education. The problem is not that we are not education but we are illeducated. For example, we have always equated democracy with elections and having the prime minister complete the tenure etc. we have never thought beyond that nor our media have helped us educate in this regard and teach us that democracy also means emancipation, equality, egalitarianism, freedom etc to name just a few. The responsibility, as always, falls on the government to provide the right education so as to empower its young citizens.