Alert Sign Dear reader, online ads enable us to deliver the journalism you value. Please support us by taking a moment to turn off Adblock on

Alert Sign Dear reader, please upgrade to the latest version of IE to have a better reading experience


Thank you Raheel Sharif?

Published Apr 01, 2017 07:06am


Your Name:

Recipient Email:

AFTER the government said it had given its consent to retired Gen Raheel Sharif accepting the offer to head the Saudi-led Islamic Military Alliance to Fight Terrorism, there were two scenarios emerging about what may happen over the coming months.

The lack of clarity and detail is triggering speculation about what this decision actually means and the Foreign Office spokesperson’s assertion that the country is already part of the Riyadh-based alliance is also surprising as this was the first official admission to that effect.

While saying that Islamabad was part of the Saudi-led alliance, the foreign office spokesperson also conceded that the ‘terms of reference’ of the grouping have yet to be decided. So, what exactly has Pakistan signed on for?

Consider the first scenario: Pakistan has finally admitted what many believed to be the case anyway as, given how close (some would say beholden) to the Saudi regime the PML-N government and the armed forces have always been, it wasn’t likely that a parliamentary resolution calling for neutrality in the Middle East would have real long-term viability.

Also, Pakistan’s task may have been made easier by the Saudi regime’s realisation that calling for Muslim nations to join the war it is waging in Yemen, and its efforts to militarily checkmate Iran in other parts of the Gulf may not draw the desired response.

The former army chief had, it was said, set certain conditions before he accepted the reportedly $1million a year job.

Ergo, Saudi Arabia is now saying that the alliance is not being formed to fight in Yemen or to counter Iran in the region but actually to fight the menace of the militant Islamic State group, also known as Daesh, which is seen as a growing threat, despite the recent setbacks suffered by the terrorist group in Iraq and Syria.

That then will remain the official Saudi position till May when, some media reports have suggested, there might be greater clarity as the alliance’s terms of reference and other details will be hammered out at a meeting of key member states.

The second scenario owes itself to the categorical statement of a former three-star general, who is seen as close to the former army chief and has also spoken for him and the security establishment in recent media appearances.

When the news of the appointment first broke, the retired lieutenant general spelt out the specific conditions under which Raheel Sharif would accept the reportedly $1million a year job. Otherwise, he said, the former chief was likely to say no.

The first was that no matter what the circumstances, he would not be willing to serve under an officer belonging to the Saudi defence forces or anyone else from the alliance’s member states as he had had the privilege of ‘serving as the head of one of the best armies in the world’.

The other two conditions were even tougher and, when they were laid out, many commentators thought the matter would go no further as the Saudis were not likely to agree to them. Till May at least it will be impossible to say what has happened on that score.

One of these two conditions, according to the retired lieutenant general, was that Iran be offered a role in the alliance too, even if it was a token one, so that Tehran would be reassured the grouping was not meant to be arrayed against it and remove any other misgivings it may have.

And the final condition sought freedom for Raheel Sharif to take the initiative and mediate in disputes between different Muslim countries as, he believed, these frictions were often the trigger for terrorism.

Assuming that the former army chief’s view has found acceptance in Riyadh, it would be safe to say that upon taking office one of his first tasks would be to offer a place in the alliance to Tehran, even though there is no way of knowing the latter’s reaction at this stage.

He’d initiate an effort to help end the conflict in Yemen where, human rights groups say, the result of the Saudi-led blockade and bombing is creating a catastrophic humanitarian crisis. One can also assume he would try and mediate some sort of a way out of the ongoing human tragedy in Syria.

This one may prove much, much tougher: the civil war in Syria has not just been fuelled by Syrians of different persuasions but also because several Muslim countries, motivated by sectarian considerations, are also neck deep in their involvement.

Even though Russia became an active player and helped turn the tide in favour of the Syrian regime, there seems no end in sight to the conflict. The slightest movement in any of these areas will go a long way in establishing Raheel Sharif’s credibility as a visionary military leader.

On the flip side, it would seem unlikely that his conditions would have been accepted. After all, the burgeoning Saudi defence budget (at more than $50 billion) places the kingdom among the top five global military spenders. A list that suggests only the US, China, UK and India are ahead of it.

This magnitude of spending appears more a statement of intent by Saudi Arabia to assert influence in the region where it feels threatened by Iran, rather than merely to fight terrorism and the terrorists towards whom it is sometimes accused of being ambivalent.

In the best-case scenario, Pakistanis will be joined by the rest of the Muslim world, the Ummah, in saying a vociferous and lasting ‘Thank You Raheel Sharif’. If this is not the case, his detractors will liken him to Alice in Wonderland.

Which will it be? Who knows for sure? I am happy to place my bet in private though.

The writer is a former editor of Dawn.

Published in Dawn, April 1st, 2017


Your Name:

Recipient Email:

Author Image
Abbas Nasir is a former editor of Dawn.

He tweets @abbasnasir59.

The views expressed by this writer and commenters below do not necessarily reflect the views and policies of the Dawn Media Group.

Comments (23) Closed

Khalid Azhar Apr 01, 2017 07:55am

A good analysis and informative piece. I am sure Gen Retd Raheel Shareef will play a significant role in collecting the Muslim World. We should be happy that this high position will be taken by a Pakistani who with his previous clean and illustrious credentials will use all his faculties to bring together of what is seperated due to misunderstandings. Best Wishes for Gen Retd Raheel. Best Regards to Mr. Abbas Nasir

Xyz Apr 01, 2017 09:11am

What has this guy done anyway?

Awaara Apr 01, 2017 09:34am

So Saudis agreed fully with his conditions? Qho knows what was discussed behind the doors. It is a job and there is no job without being reporting to someone.

Jeff L Apr 01, 2017 10:19am

@Xyz U are quite ignorant. Tell us what u have done

haider Apr 01, 2017 10:29am

Its a great honour for Pakistan to lead 39 countries.

Boo ali Apr 01, 2017 10:34am

Don't worry sir, nothing will come out from all this foul play of KSA and company.

Reader Apr 01, 2017 11:04am

Best for Raheel not to go. Why should he or Pakistan get involved in R.S.A. affairs?

Malang jan Apr 01, 2017 11:06am

Regarding the final condition of bringing peace between Muslim countries, how successful have any of our military commanders been in our own back yard, Afghanistan! Shouldn't we be addressing that first, before we go around teaching the way to the entire Muslim world?

SGH Apr 01, 2017 11:32am

The most informative article on this subject. Thank you Abbas Nasir Sahab. I wish, Gen. Raheel gets the job under his conditions, mentioned in this article. Only in this way he can avoid a conflict between Saudi Arabia and Iran. It would be a great mistake to underestimate this conflict. I feel great respect for Gen. Raheel, who has effectively tried to fight terror in Pakistan.

CH. K. A. Nye Apr 01, 2017 01:52pm

@Jeff L... Get to the point Jeff... What's the relevance of what Xyz has or has not done? He's asked a question so contribute a sensible answer if you can.

ABE Apr 01, 2017 02:00pm

Now at least we can see what motivated Gen. Raheel, and why he is keeping his silence!

At the end of the day, everybody has a price. No matter how noble otherwise.

Abdul Gaffar jamal Apr 01, 2017 02:13pm

On the surface People of Pakistan supported this decision notwithstanding minor protests. In the international power politics Pakistan has to navigate very very carefully and can not remain oblivious of any threats and dangers looming nearby

zuk Apr 01, 2017 03:21pm

@Xyz Raheel Shareef got Karachi rid of Altaf, FATA of TTP sanctuaries, gave Baluchistan some sanity against all odds,

Abbas Naqvi Apr 01, 2017 04:10pm

Two major regional players, Iran and Saudi Arabia, should mend fences if the ongoing conflicts in the Middle East especially the Yemen war and Syria crisis are to be resolved. The Saudi-led military coalition headed by the former army chief can achieve little to bridge deep political devisions among the Moslim countries let alone unite the Ummah. Conflicts and crises have always been resolved through political dialog and diplomacy not through military alliances. Pakistan can play its role in reinforcing international peace efforts to resolve regional conflicts.

Zaheer Jafri Apr 01, 2017 04:42pm

@Xyz I agree with you...

irfan uk Apr 01, 2017 04:45pm

General Raheel has done wonders in Pakistan with terrorism going down by 80% within his time and now he can do some good work in Saudi but he must get Iran to join them otherwise there will be more trouble and we cannot afford any more wars in the world especially in Middle East.

Amir Apr 01, 2017 05:19pm

It would be a great achievement if all Muslim nations, who right now are fighting amongst themselves, can unite and bring peace in the middle east, fight the ISIS menace, and able to stabilize Afghanistan

Asad Apr 01, 2017 06:06pm

These conditions are seemingly a drama for sake of diversion. The core question is that who are these terrorists, who are financing them and whose ideology they are following? Former state secretary Hillary Clinton admission must be enough to know all these conspiracies.

farhan Apr 01, 2017 06:48pm

Best of luck Retd Gen Raheel Shareef, we fully support your decision.

ga Apr 01, 2017 07:27pm

@Zaheer Jafri - While you and Xyz were living under a rock, Gen Raheel took the bull by the horn and brought some respite from frequent militant attacks in the country thus earning global recognition. again, while you were living under a rock.

ejaz Apr 01, 2017 09:58pm

From being savior of the country to savior of the world!

mohammed daud Apr 01, 2017 10:16pm

@Xyz Only ignorant and the enemies of Pakistan will not be able to see what Raheel Sharif's contributions are for peace and protection of Pakistan.

pathanoo Apr 01, 2017 11:28pm

Well, at least we know one thing for sure......Raheel Sharif will make a Million Dollars a year.