Brazilian football: An excess of incompetence

Published
0
“We lack players, we lack a team, we lack a coach.” — AP
“We lack players, we lack a team, we lack a coach.” — AP

SAO PAULO: Brazil's Copa America exit against Paraguay has plunged them into the doldrums again and sparked a well-worn debate about how to restore the national side to its former glory.

A year after they were hammered 7-1 by Germany in the World Cup, the post-mortem following another tournament exit is going over some familiar ground.

The diagnosis, like a year ago, is that with few truly great players and a chaotic domestic game, the system needs remodelling from the ground up.

“Getting knocked out on penalties again can't hide the reality,” newspaper columnist Juca Kfouri wrote in the Folha de S.Paulo on Sunday.

“We lack players, we lack a team, we lack a coach, while at the top there is an excess of incompetence.”

Kfouri, like many other fans, blames the Brazilian Football Confederation (CBF) and Dunga, the coach who took over two weeks after their World Cup humiliation last year.

Dunga's position does not seem in danger after Saturday's 4-3 penalty shootout defeat by Paraguay, but he is hardly popular.

His defensive playing style and a lack of personal charm in what is one of the country's highest-profile jobs have won him few friends.

The same could be said for the CBF. The organisation was criticised after the 7-1 Germany defeat for not pausing to take stock and for failing to understand that Brazilian football has gone backwards.

Critics called in vain for wholesale changes, with a revamped and slimmed down domestic calendar, new blood at the head of the CBF, and an independent league system run by the clubs.

According to former great Tostao, a member of the 1970 World Cup winning team, the cause of Brazil's current problems lies with a new generation of players that lacks the mercurial talents of the past.

“In addition to scant individual and collective quality, the selecao lives with the complex of enormous expectation and responsibility created by Brazilian football's history,” he wrote in the Folha de S.Paulo.

“Players who have no great star quality lack confidence and emotional balance in decisive games. They bottled it.”

Dunga blamed the defeat on a virus he said struck down some players before the match but added that the loss would toughen up his young squad for the upcoming World Cup qualifiers, which begin in October.

Brazil have never failed to qualify for the World Cup and the pressure this time around will be great.

“This tournament was very important in getting players used to playing the qualifiers,” the coach said moments after the loss.

“We wanted to win but it was a great lesson for the qualifiers and that is our main priority.”

Opinion

Editorial

Parliament’s place
Updated 11 Oct, 2026

Parliament’s place

In 2015, the parliament had decided to “maintain neutrality in the Yemen conflict so as to be able to play a proactive diplomatic role to end the crisis”.
Disturbing the peace
11 Oct, 2026

Disturbing the peace

THIS year’s Nobel Peace Prize is well-earned. The winner, South African jurist Dr Navi Pillay, has had an...
A voice in care
10 Oct, 2026

A voice in care

WORLD Mental Health Day this year carries a compelling message. The theme, ‘Lived experiences heard: real voices,...
Midterm break
Updated 10 Oct, 2026

Midterm break

Both the US and Israel need to halt their destructive misadventures in the Middle East.
American barbarism
Updated 10 Oct, 2026

American barbarism

WITH the spectre of defeat in the upcoming midterm elections looming large over the Trump administration, the...