Alert Sign Dear reader, online ads enable us to deliver the journalism you value. Please support us by taking a moment to turn off Adblock on

Alert Sign Dear reader, please upgrade to the latest version of IE to have a better reading experience


Welcome to the circus

Published Jul 30, 2012 12:05am


Your Name:

Recipient Email:

IN terms of entertainment value, this country’s media industry must surely hold its own against the best and the brightest.

Barely a day goes by without Pakistan being given reason to gape, yet again, at what our galaxy of television personalities consider suitable viewing and behaviour.

Earlier it was the news side that was considered problematic: too much graphic violence being broadcast, callousness while filming scenes of violence and its victims and so on. But in more recent times, as the news side sorted itself out somewhat with codes of conduct, it is the world of the anchors that has arrived centre stage. And that is a circus.

Consider the programme that is taking up a good chunk of cyberspace these days. A certain female television anchor apparently wanted to give her show a religious flavour. And what better service to do for religion than to broadcast a person embracing Islam.

So it was that prime time viewing comprised of a live broadcast during which a cleric led a young man through the steps of converting from Hinduism to Islam. By the time the credits rolled, the ranks of the army of the faithful had swelled by one. The studio audience called out congratulations and shouted out suggestions about the Muslim name to be adopted; the host, dupatta over her demure head, made meaningless but nauseating observations and the channel, no doubt, congratulated itself on yet another successful episode. (For the record, this was the same anchor who thought that good programming entailed chasing after couples in a Karachi park to ask whether or not they were married to each other and if not, weren’t they ashamed of themselves for dating?)

Any reasonable person must balk at such a breath-taking display of insensitivity and utter tastelessness. Since when did such a private moment become fodder for studio lights and microphones? Since when did religion become currency in the race for ratings and advertisements?

(Well, for a fairly long time. The Western world’s televangelists of the ’90s, primarily in the US, made it their business to create television drama out of religion: love thy God, repent — and make me rich by sending a teeny tiny little cheque to my foundation. While many such charlatans were exposed, a few prosecuted, the reality is that when there’s money to be made few demonstrate any scruples; nothing is too sacred.)

But the problem with this particular episode also was the denigration with which it treats people of other religions in the country — and contrary to what sections of society may like to delude themselves into thinking, there are quite a few. This programme was telling them: you are not of the same status; your belief is not. In the aftermath, Ramesh Kumar, a leader of the Pakistan Hindu Council, told AFP that it would encourage religious intolerance. “We are already intimidated,” he said. “The government gives little heed to the kidnapping of Hindus and forced conversion of our girls. Please don’t do things that make us more alienated.”

I’m not sure which possibility is worse: that, while envisioning it, the host and producers of the show did not realise the implications in a country where religious discrimination is already so lethally entrenched, or that they did and chose to go ahead anyway.

On the other side of the coin, in the weeks leading up to Ramazan, one had reason to be appalled by a promo about a prospective show about repenting hosted by another personality made famous by television — though not an anchorperson. As I see it, the problem was not that this lady’s past reputation and professional life made her someone who, in the eyes of the conservative, could have a fair few matters to repent over. The problem was that the promo hinged on the audience being aware of this ‘contradiction’, so to speak, and invited people to ponder upon the nature of sin in the context of this particular host. What ended up as a laughing stock, at least in the promo, was the idea that the host and the producers had any respect for religion itself.

It could have been that the show would prove to be reasonable, that the lady would prove to be knowledgeable and adept at handling appropriate guests. But we never found out, for on this occasion the creaking edifice of the Pakistan Media Regulatory Authority lumbered into movement. An official told the press that the organisation had received internet petitions calling for the show to be cancelled. A member of the production team said that if the people did not wish to see this show, it would be cancelled. And so, the plug was pulled.

Putting religious programming aside, the media scandal before this concerned a couple of anchors talking between on-air segments to a land baron. These recordings indicated that, at the very least, the ‘hard-hitting’ grilling session they were ostensibly subjecting him to was a sham.

These are just a few of too many examples where different sections of the media industry have demonstrated not just the desire to get ahead — make money — using any means, but also their contempt for their audience. Rarely, if ever, is any action taken; few are the signs of recognition that the media had better put its house in order.

For over a decade now, since the country’s media policies were liberalised during the Musharraf years, commentators have excused slip-ups with the observation that this is a young industry. How long can that defence remain valid? The media business has real, tangible effects on the ground, changing opinions and hardening prejudices.

Pakistan has enough elements leading it towards the dark; at least those that set themselves up as the guardians of the light should actually perform that task — or risk having restrictions placed upon them at some inevitable point in the future.

The writer is a member of staff.


Your Name:

Recipient Email:

Comments (9) Closed

Rafique Wassan Jul 30, 2012 05:46pm
Hajrah, very bold article, the maya khan and her team (Channel) should be banned completely to save Pak from the terrible and dangerous trends in society, her live show of drama is nothing but a religious violence against minorites in Pak. It also exposes the so called 'National Media" ,its violent, intolerant and abusive face in the name of religion. the champions of mainstream national media should look into the real face of it, with due respect, the local media channels ( esp Sindhi) are proud of being liberal and secular in their posture which has always been ignored by this type of mullah oriented mainstream media.
Karachi Wala Jul 30, 2012 10:56am
A wonderful and sensible article by the author but, I am afraid for the most part, it is falling on deaf ears.
Sheikh Siddeeque Jul 30, 2012 02:48pm
If any body needs conversion it is we the Pakistani who need conversion to decency, a civilized behaviour and respect for all followers of different faiths. sheikh siddeeque USA
Ronnie Dsouza Jul 30, 2012 02:19pm
What if this incident was VICE-VERSA, imagine the wrath of the Muslim majority on the Minorities, they would come out with guns blazing upon the poor discriminated minorities.
Sohaib YAHIA Jul 30, 2012 12:45pm
Shame on the nation and mullah brigade! We have made mockery of the beautiful religion using it a tool to terrorize the 2% minority of the country in the name of false glorification. Highly detestable act indeed!
Falcon Jul 30, 2012 03:35am
Hajrah - I am glad you took up this issue. Its really unfortunate what happened. One of the solutions to these media excesses is that people in the civil society like yourself stay vigilant and voice concerns so that remedial action can be taken by production houses. On a side note, I have no idea why the female anchor under consideration keeps inviting trouble.
BRR Jul 30, 2012 04:48am
The last nails in the coffin of the Pakistani minorities is about to be hammered in, thanks to followers of a so called peaceful religion. With such peaceful religious people around, who needs wars?
malik Jul 30, 2012 04:52am
Pakistan is suffering from 'way too much religion' syndrome. The problem is nothing good has come out of it and each time we hear is something outrageous. Individulas may have become better presons but overall the society's morals have deteriorated.
ayaz ahmed Jul 31, 2012 09:53pm
Still we follow the clowns. Who give the circus away!