Lyari turmoil

Published April 28, 2012

Residents of Lyari affected by the operation.—File Photo

ONCE again, there is turmoil in the congested streets of Lyari. A supposed crackdown against ‘gangsters’ in Karachi’s most troubled area on Friday turned into a battle between law-enforcers and gunmen.

Friday’s action was triggered by the shooting to death of a PPP worker in the locality a day earlier.

Violence continued into Saturday, with a number of fatalities reported. Police say ‘terrorists’ of the ‘defunct’ People’s Amn Committee clashed with the law-enforcers; what is alarming is that the gunmen’s powerful armoury matched that of the police. While Lyari is in the throes of violence, the rest of Karachi remains relatively unaffected, indicating there is a disconnect between what goes on in that forsaken corner of the city and the rest of the metropolis.

It is easy for the police to say they are up against ‘gangsters’, but more transparency is needed. Are the law-enforcers up against armed residents of Lyari, or are they facing resistance from the crime lords who rule the area?

Whatever the case, the common people are suffering the most. When politics and crime come together they form a toxic mix, and perhaps that is what we are witnessing in this under-developed, crime-ridden part of Karachi. Some PPP leaders had earlier backed the Amn Committee — widely believed to be a front for criminal elements. Now that the criminals are out of control the party is taking action against the very forces it once apparently patronised.

It is similar to the situation on the national stage, where sections of the establishment once backed jihadi militants as ‘strategic assets’; these very ‘assets’ have now turned their guns on the state. The lesson to be learnt from Lyari is that patronising thugs and criminals to secure street power is not a viable policy; these elements are no substitute for genuine political workers. Also, if the PPP-led government cannot control Lyari — its supposed bastion — what about law and order in the rest of Karachi? It is time the ruling party backed up its stated good intentions with sincere actions to rid Lyari of criminals and provide socioeconomic opportunities for its blighted residents.

Opinion

A changed world

A changed world

The phrase ‘security provider’ sounds impressive but there is little clarity on what it means for the country.

Editorial

Bannu attack
Updated 12 May, 2026

Bannu attack

The security narrative and strategy of the KP government diverges considerably from the state’s position.
Cotton crisis
12 May, 2026

Cotton crisis

PAKISTAN’S cotton economy is once again facing a crisis that exposes the country’s flawed agricultural and...
Buddhist heritage
12 May, 2026

Buddhist heritage

THE revival of Buddhist chants at the ancient Dharmarajika Stupa in Taxila after nearly 1,500 years is much more ...
New regional order
Updated 11 May, 2026

New regional order

The fact is that the US has only one true security commitment in the Middle East — Israel.
A better start
11 May, 2026

A better start

THE first 1,000 days of a child’s life often shape decades to come. In Pakistan, where chronic malnutrition has...
Widening gap
11 May, 2026

Widening gap

PAKISTAN’S monthly trade deficit ballooned to $4.07bn last month, its highest level since June 2022, further...