EVERY time there is a debate over the proposed creation of more provinces or administrative units in the country, Sindh Assembly is witness to fiery speeches. It is true that, as elected members, legislators are duty-bound to discuss serious matters concerning the present and future of the province. Indeed, the creation of new provinces is an important matter. However, what these very legislators have done to the Sindh that already exists is also a matter that needs a serious debate.

One only has to visit the constituencies of legislators to observe the alarming level of devastation. Crumbling infrastructure and impoverished populations are visible almost everywhere. It is difficult to find an exception. The true touchstone of the love for Sindh must be service to its people. This love demands service, not merely speeches and slogans. The debate over new provinces, therefore, cannot be separated from the political and economic interests of those who currently dominate Sindh’s political landscape.

That may help explain why some of the loudest opposition to proposals for new provinces comes from those whose political influence could be affected by such a change. The creation of new provinces might dent their vote bank, and dilute their hold on political powers. If the love for Sindh is genuine, the most meaningful proof should not be found in speeches about its ‘division’, but in the condition of its people, its schools, hospitals, roads, water and power supply, agriculture and institutions.

Gulsher Panhwer
Johi

Published in Dawn, November 4th, 2026