ISLAMABAD: A Supreme Court judge on Tuesday recused himself from hearing a set of appeals in chamber against court office’s objections to the petitions seeking a probe into a cipher cited as an evidence of alleged foreign conspiracy to topple the government of former prime minister Imran Khan.

Justice Sardar Tariq Masood, who had taken up the appeals in his chamber, referred the matter back to Chief Justice of Pakistan (CJP) Umar Ata Bandial for placing them before a different judge, citing personal reasons.

The petitions were filed by Advocate Zulfikar Ahmed Bhutta, Syed Tariq Baddar and Naeemul Hassan. During the chamber hearing, Advocate Bhutta argued that the matter was very sensitive since it may threaten the security of foreigners living in Pakistan.

In his petition, Mr Bhutta had requested the apex court to order placing the cipher before the civil and military authorities concerned to investigate the letter waved by the PTI chairman at a public meeting on March 27, 2022.

He had argued that a probe into the issue was necessary as it was a matter of national interest since the indirect message related to the security of the country and might pose a threat to the foreigners and ambassadors living in Pakistan.

The petition feared that the letter shown by the former prime minister had created doubts about some friendly countries and made subject matter of every political gathering as if the affairs of Pakistan were controlled by the foreign countries.

“This is not an ordinary rather an extraordinary situation which may create hatred against foreign countries also endanger their embassies due to the law and order situation. Such a situation is not conducive for maintaining peace and may become harmful and embarrassing and damaging friendly relations with foreign countries,” it contended.

The petition cited Article 40 of the Constitution which asks for strengthening bonds with the Muslim world and promoting national peace.

The provision requires the government to endeavour, preserve and strengthen fraternal relations among Muslim countries based on Islamic unity, support common interests, promote international peace and security, foster goodwill and friendly relations among all nations and encourage the settlement of international disputes by peaceful means.

“The probe into the letter may help in digging out the real purpose and truth behind the cipher,” the petition contended.

Published in Dawn, January 25th, 2023

Opinion

Editorial

Stirring trouble
Updated 08 Dec, 2024

Stirring trouble

The demands put forth this time are simple and doable at little political cost.
Unfairness in cricket
08 Dec, 2024

Unfairness in cricket

HOPES that cricketing ties between Pakistan and India would be strengthened by the latter team’s visit across the...
Syria rebel advance
08 Dec, 2024

Syria rebel advance

CITY after city in Syria is falling into rebel hands as Bashar al-Assad’s government looks increasingly vulnerable...
Threat perception
Updated 07 Dec, 2024

Threat perception

Despite clear proof of the threat posed by malign armed actors, the military and civilian leadership prefers to focus on political opponents.
Humanity at risk
07 Dec, 2024

Humanity at risk

HUMAN trafficking continues to remain an area where the state has utterly failed its citizens. While global...
Banks and larger goals
07 Dec, 2024

Banks and larger goals

THAT banks in Pakistan “prioritise profit over purpose” and promote financial products with limited knowledge of...