Avenfield case full of mistakes, legal procedure not followed, Maryam's lawyer tells IHC

Published October 13, 2021
PML-N Vice President Maryam Nawaz speaks to the media outside the IHC on Wednesday. — DawnNewsTV
PML-N Vice President Maryam Nawaz speaks to the media outside the IHC on Wednesday. — DawnNewsTV

The lawyer for PML-N Vice President Maryam Nawaz told the Islamabad High Court on Wednesday that the legal procedure was not followed in the Avenfield apartments reference, which he said was not based on any evidence and saw numerous mistakes being committed at the pre-trial stage.

A two-judge bench, comprising Justice Aamer Far­ooq and Justice Mohsin Akh­tar Kayani, had taken up an appeal filed by Maryam against her conviction in the Avenfield properties case, in which she claimed that she had been persecuted at the behest of "certain people".

Advocate Irfan Qadir argued on the maintainability of Maryam's latest application, in which she had sought to present “extremely relevant, simple and clear-cut facts” to support her appeal against the conviction.

He said "numerous" mistakes had been made during the pre-trial stage of the case and that there were many irregularities in the case proceedings.

Qadir said although the National Accountability Bureau (NAB) had first filed an application seeking the conclusion of the appeals within 30 days, it had now filed a request seeking cancellation of Maryam's bail.

As Qadir criticised NAB's policy to readily arrest suspects, Justice Farooq remarked: "These days NAB arrests anyone, whether there is any proof against them or not. Now NAB officials function like a thana (police station) too."

Qadir informed the court that Maryam's new application had talked about political engineering in her case, saying "certain incidents took place which gave rise to many doubts and suspicions."

The counsel argued that the accountability court did not have the authority to hear the Avenfield case. "This is a case in which no evidence exists," he said, adding that the legal procedure had not been followed in the case.

He noted that in a criminal case, the benefit of even the smallest doubt was given to the suspect. "In the Avenfield reference, there is not little but a lot of doubt," he remarked.

Reading out the charges in the reference, Qadir said Maryam had been accused of being a beneficial owner of the Avenfield flats in London.

Referring to a document signed by Maryam written in Calibri font, the lawyer said: "A lot of people made fun of the Calibri font [issue]. Today I will tell you its reality as well."

Maryam was declared the beneficial owner of the properties based on a trust deed, Qadir said, adding that a "big mistake" had been committed by the Supreme Court, accountability court, Panama Papers joint investigation team and the NAB.

According to the counsel, the Sharif family was "very wealthy" even before Nawaz Sharif entered politics. Qadir questioned how this case was turned into one about a public officeholder.

Justice Kayani sought the document showing the ownership of the Avenfield flats, to which Qadir responded that no document existed that showed Maryam and Nawaz as the apartments' owners.

When the judges asked NAB to produce the ownership documents, NAB deputy prosecutor Sardar Muzaffar Abbasi informed the court that the Avenfield properties were owned by offshore companies Nielson and Nescol.

At this, the court inquired how the two offshore companies were linked to Maryam or her father Nawaz. It was told by the NAB lawyer that Maryam had been found to be the beneficial owner of Nielson and Nescol companies.

Qadir interjected and said Maryam was not a public officeholder, but added that she had the potential to become one "in the future". He said Maryam had been accused of abetting Nawaz Sharif's crime.

The lawyer further said Maryam's husband retired Capt Mohammad Safdar had been convicted in the case even though "he had no role" in the reference.

He argued that the reference had not been filed by the NAB chairman, saying as per the law, the court could not fix a reference for hearing if it had not been filed by the NAB chairperson.

Qadir further said only one reference concerning the Sharif family's assets should have been filed, instead of three.

"This is a unique case in the country's 70-year and NAB's 20-year history," he remarked, saying Maryam had received the punishment in the case "as inheritance".

"If no case had been instituted against Nawaz Sharif, there would have been no case against Maryam either," he said, adding: "NAB should be asked against how many families it started more than one assets cases."

After hearing Qadir, the court directed the NAB to present its arguments at the next hearing. The case was adjourned until November 17.

Last week, the IHC had overruled admi­n­istrative objections raised by the registrar office on Maryam's application seeking to place factual records before the court to substantiate her claim that she had been dragged into the Avenfield apartment reference and subsequently convicted not because of legal grounds but for other reasons.

However, the court had observed that it would decide the maintainability of the application aft­er hearing the NAB.

On Tuesday, the NAB filed a petition in the IHC, seeking cancellation of the bail granted to Maryam and her spouse retired Capt Mohammad Safdar in the Avenfield reference.

'Don't try to become Nawaz Sharif'

Addressing the media outside the court premises today, Maryam fired a broadside at Prime Minister Imran Khan, saying he should not try to become Nawaz Sharif who she said was elected as premier after years of struggle.

Without naming anyone, Maryam said the entire country was suffering "because you want to retain one person who runs your government".

She also accused the premier of "hijacking" Nawaz's mandate that he had acquired through public trust.

The PML-N vice president underlined that her party wanted to undertake a joint endeavour with people to bar the entry of people like Imran Khan into politics in future.

Maryam said Pakistan was bound to become an object of universal derision due to the tactics through which the country's affairs were being run.

"God help the country of 220 million people when its decisions are being taken through such tactics," she added.

During her tirade against the PTI government, she claimed that "magic" also played a role in how Prime Minister Imran was running the country.

She said the government must divert its focus to resolve public issues and growing inflation that had taken a toll on the masses.



More than economics
Updated 05 Oct, 2022

More than economics

Ishaq Dar’s appointment is but a sign of the paradigm shift in economic policymaking.
Dens of corruption
05 Oct, 2022

Dens of corruption

MOST prisons in Pakistan are a microcosm of the inequitable and exploitative world outside their walls. A probe by...
Football tragedy
05 Oct, 2022

Football tragedy

SPORTS arouses the rawest of human emotions. Football is no exception — in fact, the passions on display at...
Cipher inquiry
Updated 04 Oct, 2022

Cipher inquiry

Inquiry will likely end nowhere, or, worse, be used as a tool of victimisation.
Further delay?
04 Oct, 2022

Further delay?

KARACHI Administrator Murtaza Wahab’s announcement that the second phase of Sindh’s LG polls — primarily...
Losing to England
04 Oct, 2022

Losing to England

AFTER tantalisingly close finishes in the fourth and fifth matches against an England side visiting the country for...