'Double standards': NA panel takes Twitter's regional head to task over Kashmir policy

Published February 16, 2021
This file combination photo shows Chairman of the Parliamentary Committee on Kashmir Shehryar Afridi (L) and Twitter's regional head George Salama (R). — DawnNewsTV/Twitter
This file combination photo shows Chairman of the Parliamentary Committee on Kashmir Shehryar Afridi (L) and Twitter's regional head George Salama (R). — DawnNewsTV/Twitter

The Parliamentary Committee on Kashmir on Tuesday questioned Twitter's regional head, George Salama, over its policies related to tweets on Kashmir by Pakistani and Kashmiri activists with committee chairman Shehryar Afridi calling out the social media platform for its "double standards".

According to a statement released by the NA Secretariat, the panel "grilled" Salama over "silencing voices of thousands of Kashmiri and Pakistani activists projecting the plight of people of Indian Illegally Occupied Jammu and Kashmir (IIOJK)" on Twitter.

In a special hearing at the Parliament House in Islamabad, Afridi asked Salama about Twitter's policy on human rights and freedom of speech and whether they also conformed to the United Nation's charter on the freedom of speech and freedom of expression.

The regional head, who attended the meeting virtually, informed the parliamentary panel that Twitter "discourages hate speech and upholds freedom of expression", assuring it that "voices of minorities would never be silenced."

When questioned about the violation of Twitter rules by Indian users mentioned in the recently released report by the EU DisinfoLab, Salama replied that "Twitter management always ensures freedom of speech on social media".

"Kashmiri activists are free to raise their voice with legitimate accounts," he added. The official also offered to organise workshops in the country along with the Pakistan Telecommunications Authority (PTA) to raise awareness among Pakistani and Kashmiri activists about Twitter's regulations.

Afridi, however, said that the social media platform had "double standards" because it did not take action against "Indian agents posting tweets aimed at inciting hate and violence in Pakistan".

He alleged that people in occupied Kashmir were "being silenced under influence of Indian employees of Twitter".

The committee chairman also recalled that when he was minister for interior a few years back, some Indians were "generating 80 tweets per minute from Indian cities to incite violence in Pakistan over the blasphemy issue".

That claim was contradicted by Salama who said Twitter has "zero tolerance for hate speech and violence" and it discourages posting misleading content through fake accounts once they are reported.

"Overlapping and duplicate contents are also discouraged by Twitter management," he explained, before going on to iterate that Twitter's position would "remain equal for all parties of the conflict zone".

"We are working closely with PTA to ensure equal opportunities to social media users," Salama added.

Meanwhile, the PTA chairman informed the meeting regarding the suspension of social media accounts under the influence of Indian operators since August 5, 2019, when India revoked occupied Kashmir's special autonomy.

He told the committee that the PTA had raised the issue with Twitter which had replied that users were free to accept or deny Twitter rules.

Referring to the Removal and Blocking of Unlawful Online Content Rules 2020, the PTA chairman said once the authority reported an account to Twitter, the social media platform would have to comply by taking action within 24 hours.

After India revoked occupied Kashmir's special autonomy in Aug 2019, hundreds of Pakistani users had taken to Twitter to report that accounts were being suspended after they posted in support of Kashmir.

The claims came from journalists, activists, government officials, and fans of the military tweeting in support of Kashmir's freedom.

Responding to allegations of censorship and biased moderation on its platform, a Twitter spokesperson had told Dawn at the time that they were founded on the principles of free expression and there was no political bias in its content review teams that determine what content is considered a violation of its rules.

'Pvt TV channels not creating content on Kashmir'

Chairman of Pakistan Electronic Media Regulatory Authority (Pemra) told the committee that TV channels in the country have been "contributing hugely" to raising awareness about the Kashmir issue.

Afridi asked the Pemra chairman whether private channels were also focusing on developing films and dramas on the plight of people in occupied Kashmir, to which he replied that some channels had not altered their logos to black on February 5 (Kashmir Solidarity Day) this year.

The regulatory body would issue show-cause notices to such channels, he added.

The Pemra official sought time to present the report on telefilms and dramas on the Kashmir dispute.

Afridi said that under corporate social responsibility, private TV channels were "bound to project Kashmir dispute, India's illegal occupation of Jammu and Kashmir and plight of the Kashmiris".

The Pemra chairman also informed the committee that the authority had banned the airing of all Indian content on television. "Private TV channels were not developing their own content related to Kashmir but were instead airing content generated by public institutions," he added.

According to the statement, the committee chairman expressed his dissatisfaction over Pemra's performance in overseeing the highlighting of Kashmir issue on electronic media.

A representative from Pakistan Television (PTV) also briefed the committee about the state TV channel's efforts to highlight the Kashmir issue.

Afridi directed chairman Pemra and managing director of PTV to present detailed reports on the role of both institutions in highlighting the Kashmir issue.


For whom the clock ticks
Updated 22 Apr 2021

For whom the clock ticks

Tarin will have to succeed in order to cement his position within the cabinet.
Ending the ‘forever war’
Updated 21 Apr 2021

Ending the ‘forever war’

Regardless of who the adversary was at any point, two generations of Afghans have known only war.


22 Apr 2021

Capping power debt

THE suggested revision in the Circular Debt Management Plan, which aims to cap the flow or addition of new debt to...
22 Apr 2021

Istanbul postponement

WHILE the postponement of the Istanbul peace talks on Afghanistan, which were scheduled to be held later this week,...
22 Apr 2021

No mining precautions

YET another accident caused by a methane gas explosion has been reported from the dangerous coal mines of...
More mishandling
Updated 21 Apr 2021

More mishandling

By its bad decision-making and weak management, the govt has allowed the TLP to garner more importance and heft than it deserves.
21 Apr 2021

Declining FDI

THE sharp decline in FDI in recent months is worrisome. New State Bank data shows that FDI has plummeted by a hefty...
21 Apr 2021

The digital divide

IN the Economist Intelligence Unit’s annual Inclusive Internet Index report, measuring internet inclusion in terms...