Justice Isa case

Published
25

THE 174-page detailed judgement of the 10-member Supreme Court bench on the reference filed against Justice Qazi Faez Isa lays bare some severe deficiencies in the government process. The court held that President Arif Alvi did not form a considered opinion under Article 209(5) of the Constitution, hence the reference against Justice Isa “suffered with multiple defects”. It also said that since there was no valid authorisation for the investigation, the tax records of Justice Isa were illegally accessed.

In clear terms, the judgement said that although the preparation and framing of the reference were not patently motivated by malice, the scale and degree of the illegalities were such that the reference was deemed to be tainted with mala fide in law and therefore quashed.

This is serious critique from the highest court in the land and it requires a thorough probe into how these “multiple defects” happened and who is responsible. It is a travesty that an investigation was ordered against a judge of the Supreme Court — who will serve as the chief justice of Pakistan in the near future — without due authorisation from the president or the prime minister and instead such authorisation was obtained from the law minister. This aspect requires being investigated so that the people responsible for this grave irregularity are identified and taken to task.

Randomly authorised investigations against judges by the executive must not be allowed, and a clear message must be sent to all concerned that such abuse of power has consequences for those who indulge in it. This also applies to the illegal accessing of Justice Isa’s tax records. The government has crossed many lines that are not meant to be crossed.

Delving into the tax records of a serving judge of the Supreme Court illustrates the weakness of our system and of those who manage it in government offices. How is it possible that no one in a long line of people who were involved in authorising access to Justice Isa’s tax records, and then providing the access via the department that holds this data, could muster the courage to call out the orders as illegal? This matter must not be brushed under the carpet as is the norm.

At the same time, discomfort persists around the Supreme Court order for the FBR to further probe the sources of funds for properties owned by Justice Isa’s family. Every care must be taken that this does not turn into a witch-hunt. The entire issue has reeked of intentions that may not be entirely honourable and this has created an unnecessary controversy around the person of a respected judge. Now that the Supreme Court judgement has identified the illegalities in the process initiated and followed through by the government, those involved must be held accountable for these misdeeds.

Published in Dawn, October 26th, 2020

Opinion

Editorial

Muddled hierarchy
Updated 15 Nov, 2026

Muddled hierarchy

The jurisdiction of the two courts and a mechanism for settling disputes between them should be spelt out in law, not left to judges to fight over.
Growing crisis
Updated 15 Nov, 2026

Growing crisis

Calling population growth a national emergency is easy. Ensuring that the response reaches the people who need it is the real challenge.
Organised rackets
15 Nov, 2026

Organised rackets

ON the International Day against Transnational Organised Crime, observed today, Pakistan finds itself in a tight...
Referendum talk
Updated 14 Nov, 2026

Referendum talk

Unless the PPP is deliberately using Sindh as a bargaining chip, it should issue a clarification with a clear, consistent position on new administrative units, not one tailored to protect its home turf.
Mineral wealth
Updated 14 Nov, 2026

Mineral wealth

Minerals should not be presented as a solution to Pakistan’s long-term economic difficulties. The aim should be to build an industrial base rather than export raw materials.
Late diagnosis
14 Nov, 2026

Late diagnosis

AS we mark World Diabetes Day today, Pakistan faces a troubling question: how many people are living with diabetes...