Dear reader, online ads enable us to deliver the journalism you value. Please support us by taking a moment to
THE HAGUE: The Dutch prime minister on Friday distanced his government from a cartoon contest being organised later this year by anti-Islam lawmaker Geert Wilders.
Wilders “is not a member of the government. The competition is not a government initiative,” Prime Minister Mark Rutte said at his weekly press conference.
Rutte’s comments came after angry reactions in Pakistan to the proposed contest, which Wilders plans to hold in November in his right-wing Party for Freedom’s heavily guarded offices at the Dutch parliament.
Authorities in Pakistan have lodged a diplomatic protest against Wilders’ plan, calling it an attempt to defame Islam.
Opposition lawmaker Wilders is well known for his fierce criticism of Islam and has previously sparked fury in Muslim nations with a film about Islam. He lives under a round-the-clock guard following years of death threats.Rutte questioned Wilders’ motive for organising the contest, saying “his aim is not to have a debate about Islam. His aim is to be provocative.” However, he added that people in the Netherlands have far-reaching freedom of speech rights.
Published in Dawn, August 25th, 2018
Comments (50) Closed
What else can he say to stay afloat, show that he is at the helm, save his skin, make his presence felt and remain in the limelight?
If the Dutch government is not involved, still they need to take action against Geert Wilders. Saying no relationship is not enough.
PM has a lot of powers to restrain such offensive acts. He must act against wilders.
It is interesting to note why Pakistan is the only Islamic country who always raise voice against such activities. Why don't so called Islamic nations like Saudi Arabia, UAE, Iran or Indonesia raise their voice on such issues ?
What?? Does he mean that his government does not have full writ over his country’s citizens. Hypocrisy at its peak. These “clever” responses won’t fool anyone. You can very well control it all Mr. Dutch Premier so don’t shy away.
where hurts others feelings then it is not a freedom.
@Shahbaz no he doesnt....netherlands is a democratic country....the PM is not a dictator....
Oh I am only the government. It is the people who are misbehaving and are racist! It is always the same.
He is inviting troubles to his country by not acting decisively.
@Naveed maybe because they think that raising voices will further agravate the issue
This is very poor stance by Dutch government. You must stop this great crime aimed at hurting the sentiment of Muslims around the world. "Freedom of expression" doesn't mean Humiliating the greatest Human Being (P.B.U.H). We strongly condemn this act and will boycott Dutch prodi untill they apologize for this cheel act.
Spin media in Europe and USA continues to focus on such things so that they can divert the attention of their own people from thinking about their own problems and issues in life.
Geert Wilders badly lost in the last elections. He’s now just trying to get some attention. Ignoring him will eventually make him shut up, because all he wants is attention.
@Fahd PM doesn’t have the power to silence free speech. You can say anything, and insult anything.
I am living all my life in Netherlands. Indeed geert wilders and his party are not liked by any othet party. They didn't form government and even local news the pm always talks he is totally against the ideology of Wilders however freedom of speech is very important here. Every1 can do and say whatever they want. Wilders is disguisting and disgrace.
@Shahbaz The government is limited in its response. Western countries value free speech especially the Dutch who have a similar view of free speech as the US (nearly absolute). It's not the Gulf where you can jail someone over what they write or draw. You are mistaken if they can or will do anything.
Freedom of speech doesn't mean abuse everyone and everything.
well if you want to do little protest just check what things made in holland you are using and stop using them buy the alternatives.
I will believe in freedom of speech if they also allow similar contest about Jews.By the way I am not antisemite I just want to expose the Dutch/western hypocrisy.
@Fahd He is the PM of Netherlands. They are sworn to protect absolute freedom of speech and Netherlands is not an Islamic republic.
A stupid and weak response. A hijab wearing women doesn't work for the government but Europeans are legislating against them. Hypocrites.
@Naveed To divert the attention from the actual economic crisis and FATF grey listing matter.
Pakistan is a stranger to free expression of speech and thoughts. Islam is a major religion, if one person in the west decided to make a cartoon competition it is not going to make a dent in Islamic believes, please chill Pakistanis.
If there is no law in the Netherlands to prosecute someone for such acts then why can't their security agencies make Wilders disappear for a day or two. Teach him a lesson and then release him.
@Fahd when you can attack other religions why must your religion be an exception
Dutch ambassador must be expelled from Pakistan.
@Naveed, Because they don't want to give undue publicity.
@Fahd Actually he does not.
The Dutch Govt is responsible for spreadind hatred among differemt religons' followers in the world. Freedom does not mean to disgrace other religeon's Holy personalties. The Dutch Govt is senseable enough to anticipate dire consequences of such competition on their soil.
Why only Pakistan has to raise concerns?
The myth of so-called freedom of speech does not have infinite limits but considered as infringement on other rights when anyone tries to ridicule such sensitive subject of religion practiced by others through display of cartoons.In this particular case the incumbent known for his anti Islam venomous,undertaking is bound to hurt the religious feelings of Muslim in Netherlands as well as in other countries and the Dutch govt. must deter this unnecessary public disharmony & creation of undesired bad feelings of Muslim towards Dutch people.We must not provide extremists a prpoganda tool to justify their nefarious designs of creating hatred towards other peaceful communities based on differences in faith,for no rhyme or reason.It is sad to note that only Pakistan is in forefront to lodge its rightful protest against this depictable act while other Muslim countries remain mute,which is highly deplorable to begin with.This issue needs to be vigorously raised by the Islamic world body as well
@Fahd Under Dutch Law, this is not an offensive act. It falls under Freedom of Speech, Assembly and practice.
Why are we the Muslims scared off?
let them do what they want to.
We believe and fave faith, let us remain peaceful and focused on our belief and actions. We shame the doubters by our peaceful, tolerant actions.
The western notion that is called freedom of speech is nothing more than a political tool and nonsense. When in Europe & North America people deny holocaust they are persecuted but insulting someone 's religion is okay in civilized west! why don't west allow white supremacist or Nazi's to spread their message in main stream media?
Its a minor issue. Better to ignore at its best. People will make you provocative you if you respond.
Freedom of speech....what is your speech?? BTW ...what is the difference between Freedom of hate and freedom of war and freedom of speech???
Geert Wilders is not a member of the government. The competition is not a government initiative. Enough said.
@Naveed oil
"people in the Netherlands have far-reaching freedom of speech rights.". Really?. Can I speak my mind about Holocaust in public in Netherlands and stay a free man?
In don't think so.......
@Fahd
It doesn’t work that way. You will never be able to tell someone what they can or can’t draw, nor should you, unless it’s on someone else’s property.
The best way to handle this is to completely ignore them, remain silent. They’re trying to loudly express themselves because there ARE very thin-skinned people in the world that think their religion is above any sort of criticism, and this is what motivates them, so ignore them if you believe your religion is strong enough to overcome criticism. If it isn’t strong enough, then you might try to correct or improve anywhere it needs it. There is no perfect in this world.
We should boycott all the dutch products. Dutch Premier should stop this competition from being organized as it will hurt the sentiments of all the Muslims in the world. Freedom of Speech does not mean you can hurt the sentiments of Billions of Muslims
Wilder you are root cause of hate, terrorism and extremism. You are peace killer. You are attacking on heart of Muslims through blasphemous cartoon.
@Naveed: Because all of them enjoy billions of dollars of investments from the West and have to keep quiet. The are only harsh with Islamic laws agaist 3rd class Muslim citizens of Pakistan, India, Bangladesh. Anoterh facto ris that only poor have nothing to do than to make noise and get rid of their stress when they are living in a failed state.
@Fahd PM has power but HE CANNOT STOP ANYONE FROM SPEAKING THEIR MIND...Its a freedom of speech issue which 3rd world countries find hard to understand.
Calling a spade a spade !!
Use their law to lodge complaint:
Netherlands While Holocaust denial is not explicitly illegal in the Netherlands, the courts consider it a form of spreading hatred and therefore an offence.[57] According to the Dutch public prosecution office, offensive remarks are only punishable by Dutch law if they equate to discrimination against a particular group.[58] The relevant laws of the Dutch penal code are as follows:
Article 137c
He who in public, either verbally or in writing or image, deliberately offends a group of people because of their race, their religion or beliefs, their hetero- or homosexual orientation or their physical, psychological or mental handicap, shall be punished with imprisonment not exceeding one year or a fine of the third category.
Imran is right, Muslims need to unite, be bold and undertake aggressive journalism against such practices.
@RUMI — Seriously Rumi?
Imran Khan ignore him, he wants attention, make Naya Pakistan strong... focus focus focus on the economy.
The Dutch government is involved as they are responsible for letting this go ahead, they have banned the burqa and niqab which wasn't harming anyone.
He is doing his best , past govt, did not even bother to do that.