Don't malign the judiciary if the verdict is against you: CJP hits out at critics

Published December 16, 2017
Chief Justice of Pakistan Mian Saqib Nisar addresses a seminar in Lahore.—DawnNews
Chief Justice of Pakistan Mian Saqib Nisar addresses a seminar in Lahore.—DawnNews

Chief Justice of Pakistan (CJP) Mian Saqib Nisar on Saturday hit out at the people criticising the judiciary for issuing judgements that they deemed "unfavourable".

Addressing a seminar in Lahore, Justice Nisar said the perception that the judiciary has become a part of a bigger plan or design needs to end.

Referring to the judiciary using the analogy of a baba (village elder), he said: "The judiciary is your baba [...] do not doubt its integrity."

Without mentioning any names, he said, "If a decision is issued against you, don't abuse [the judiciary] by saying the baba has become a part of a design or a grand plan."

"The baba has not and will not become a part [of a plan]."

The chief justice said those against whom a judgement has been issued have the right to criticise the reason behind the verdict, but he questioned the insinuations of the "judiciary being part of a plan" or "being under pressure".

He said that no one dictated the court on what line to take in deciding a case.

Justice Nisar said he wasn't aware that the verdict in the Hudaibya Paper Mills reference appeal would also be announced on Friday — the same day that a SC bench, led by the chief justice, issued the judgement in the Imran Khan and Jahangir Tareen disqualification cases.

He said that the judgements on the petitions against Khan and Tareen were announced on Friday because he has a "passion" to issue verdicts within a month.

"If someone had been able to dictate [the judges], the Hudaibya judgement would not have turned out the way it did," he pointed out.

"All the judges are independent and can take their own decisions."

Referring to the "analysis on TV channels in the evenings", he said that the perception that there was some kind of division within the Supreme Court was false.

He acknowledged the delay in the judicial process, saying some "not very competent judges" are responsible for the delay, multiplication of litigation and expensive litigation in cases. An efficient training programme is necessary for judges, he concluded.

Stressing on the importance of democracy, Justice Nisar said that the judiciary has vowed to protect the Constitution and would continue to uphold democracy.

Justice Nisar said he will get a chance to listen to the underprivileged plaintiffs of the country once the "political dirt gets cleaned by laundry of the Supreme Court".

The judiciary and lawyers will have to make joint efforts to provide cheap justice to the common man, he added.

Opinion

Editorial

Missing in action
17 Mar, 2026

Missing in action

NOT exactly known for playing a proactive role in protecting the interests of Muslim nations and populations...
Risk to stability
Updated 17 Mar, 2026

Risk to stability

THE risks to Pakistan’s fragile economic recovery from the US-Israel war on Iran cannot be dismissed. Yet the...
Enrolment push
17 Mar, 2026

Enrolment push

THE federal government has embarked upon the welcome initiative to enrol 25,000 out-of-school children in Islamabad...
Holding the line
16 Mar, 2026

Holding the line

PAKISTAN’S long battle against polio has recently produced encouraging signs. Data from the national eradication...
Power self-reliance
Updated 16 Mar, 2026

Power self-reliance

PAKISTAN’S transition to domestic sources of electricity is a welcome development for a country that has long been...
Looking for safety
16 Mar, 2026

Looking for safety

AS the Middle East conflict enters its third week, the war’s most enduring victims are not those who wage it....