YouTube to remain blocked 'indefinitely' in Pakistan: officials
161
ISLAMABAD: YouTube will remain blocked 'indefinitely' in Pakistan, a government official said Saturday as experts failed to find a way to filter content deemed offensive and blasphemous.
The video-sharing website has been blocked in the country since September 2012 over its hosting of the “Innocence of Muslims”, a movie that sparked furious protests around the world.
The Supreme Court ruled at the time that the site should be banned until a way was found to block all blasphemous content.
“[The] matter was reviewed several times but the situation effectively remains the same,” the minister for information technology and telecommunication Anusha Rehman told the Senate Friday.
“The government does not want to take any chance and wants to make sure that after the unblocking YouTube, no offensive content remains viewable in Pakistan,” a senior government official said.
“So far no tool or solution has been found which can totally block offensive content, that is why YouTube remains blocked and it will remain so indefinitely,” the official said.
Free speech campaigners have long complained of creeping censorship in the name of protecting religion or preventing obscenity, and have described the ban on YouTube as a violation of civil rights.
In November 2011, the telecommunications authority tried to ban nearly 1,700 “obscene” words from text messages, which included innocuous terms such as “lotion”, “athlete's foot” and “idiot”.
In 2010 Pakistan shut down Facebook for nearly two weeks over its hosting of allegedly blasphemous pages. It continues to restrict thousands of online links.
Read more
On DawnNews
Comments (161) Closed
Feb 07, 2015 05:50pm
This country is run by senseless people.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 05:53pm
Ban on a YouTube is a violation of civil rights.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 05:54pm
Pathetic approach and incompetence to block that movie only instead of blocking Youtube itself
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 05:55pm
With this government. We will be in stone age very soon.....
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 05:57pm
Youtube works on android mobile apps perfectly fine.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 05:57pm
Muhammad pbuH Cartoon is available all over internet and google. Should internet be shut off as well ?
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 05:58pm
This is a mad, mad, mad, mad country.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 06:01pm
my "step brothers" cant even deal with you tube but still want to manage India.
sahi kaha hai..sapne hardam bade dekhne chahiye.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 06:01pm
YouTube has more to offer than few supposedly blasphemous videos
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 06:02pm
When does Pakistan's contract expire to be the self- appointed custodian of religion in the world?
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 06:09pm
".........experts failed to find a way to filter content deemed offensive and blasphemous."
And we, common people, are able to judge all kinds of blaphemous words and deeds and even kill or lynch men and women on that behalf. Humor? The government does not open You Tube, because Nawaz doesn't know what blasphemy is. I would say to the goverment: stop reigning, becasue you don't know what human rights are.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 06:11pm
Why can't we go and live on another planet.What is wrong with you guys. Don't react to what ever material they print.Our Prophet (PBUH) never got angry even when people misbehaved with him.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 06:11pm
yesterday someone was giving lecture to Indian on freedom of speech !!Have a little respect for yourself.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 06:12pm
What idiots!!!! Grow up
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 06:13pm
If you don't react, hate mongers will stop printing their hateful material.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 06:14pm
Does YouTube care if it is Banned or not in Pakistan? How many other countries have banned the site too?
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 06:15pm
When you step outside the house you may experience rain, wind, sun and all kinds of weather unless you cover yourself in iron sheets. In that case, you won't be able to get too far and even survive. Similarly, in this day and age it is ridiculous and counter productive to keep on banning things.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 06:17pm
And then we want to be part of 21st century country.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 06:17pm
The best thing to do is to ban not just you tube, face book but also ban internet fully. Not just that, breakdown all communications work the outside world. Also stop all travel to the western world.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 06:17pm
Very depressing news.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 06:19pm
Keep the people from finding out the truth
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 06:19pm
if these same officials would extend this ban to facebook and whatsapp, people would have alot more productive time on their hands.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 06:21pm
Why don't the government and supreme court prosecute real criminals and terrorists. They should stop being the moral police.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 06:22pm
I don't understand why they are blocking youtube. I know there can be some offensive content on it but who is asking to view it. There are equal number of Muslims in India as in Pakistan but there it is not banned and people also don't have any problem related to any content. If they do have problem then that particular content link can be blocked not whole Youtube.
As someone said "If it is not my cup of tea then I should not drink it", similarly if something is offensive then don't watch it. Does banning Youtube mean that content is not there on it which people thought was offensive?
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 06:30pm
Pakistanis are fine with news of children being raped and killed or people being burnt alive. But got forbid if they see something offensive on you tube lol
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 06:31pm
There seems to be some hidden ulterior motives behind this youtube ban.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 06:31pm
Yes, let's keep our heads buried in sands because of your insecurities and in-competencies.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 06:31pm
What is government afraid of? Isn't this censorship from Chinese books?
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 06:35pm
Good ! This is helping people do something meaningful.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 06:35pm
Welcome to the bronze age where YouTube remains blocked till infinity and like sheep people flock to mobile companies for biometric verification of sims... Its a travesty considering in 2015 Pakistan adopts policies of bronze age!
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 06:41pm
I dont understand what is the problem now. Youtube has made a proxy site for Pakistan which is www.ytpak.com. This site is under control of Pakistan Government and they able to block all offensive contents on this site. You can not only view all youtube videos but also make and see comments made on youtube. So whats the point of this news?
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 06:44pm
Keep it blocked. Pakistan needs Sharia compliant YouTube
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 06:44pm
And Pakistan thinking that it has got freedom...
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 06:47pm
This is like. If you cant face the insult the just shut your ears and eyes. The people who are suffering becoz of this is only your people not the one who posted it. The best way to react to this is ignore the bad and extract what is good. There is no learning site better then youtube. And if you want to excel in IT its like the secret key to take the explanation. You guys are going back to harrap and mohinjodaro!
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 06:53pm
A very silly decision. Anyone who wants to can access Youtube by using proxies. The government has also to understand that there will always be one percent of people who will put offensive items on any media, and no one can do anything about it. Did murdering the Charlie Hebdo cartoonists stop the magazine? On the contrary, its circulation is now more than 20 times it was before the murders. If we find anything offensive on Youtube (or wherever) the answer is to move to another channel.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 06:55pm
Those who don't accept freedom of thought will remain prisoners of it.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 06:59pm
is it really ? pakistani citizens can;t watch youtube?
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 07:00pm
Freedom of expression is the original right. If you don't have this, none of the others exists either.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 07:08pm
Open your window and let the fresh air come inside. Be healthy and think better. Good Luck.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 07:09pm
But Mubasher Lucman shows Videos from Youtube in his program !!!
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 07:11pm
YouTube is such a rich resource full of how to videos that can help with common problems. Pakistan doesn't need an educational tool I guess, we would rather have madrassahs.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 07:12pm
One way to avoid "offensive" content is by not watching it in the first place... It's not about what's out there, but more to do with what people go out looking for...
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 07:12pm
I hv questions
1. is banning youtube cause any financial loss to youtube or not?
2. Are different proxies getting huge business because of this ban?
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 07:17pm
Govt has once again failed people to appease mullahs. This is rediculous and total insanity.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 07:22pm
YouTube carry millions and millions video which are useful to any student, professional. My Pakistani brothers and sisters are not getting that opertunity. It is very sad. :(
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 07:28pm
Good. Until you don,t find appropriate solution for this don,t open it. We will keep unblocking by using other tools. People of Pakistan are more intelligent than their govt.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 07:29pm
It is out there. What difference does it make if pakistani people see it or not. You are only devoiding your people of valuable information that is necessary in today's age. Pakistan will be left behind as the world marches on.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 07:29pm
Sad. Youtube is the single most useful content website on the Internet. I watch technical conferences, courses, tutorials, news, recipes and just about everything from it.
The logic behind "not want to take any chance is flawed". It is routinely argued that because 99.99% of muslims are peaceful, it is unfair to label the community as a whole. Why isn't the same logic being used on Youtube? The percent of provocative videos is quite small. You don't block the entire website because of a tiny portion of videos. It is not as if anyone is being forced to watch them. The same logic applies to the entire Internet.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 07:33pm
India got independence a day after us, China achieved it more than two years after us, even Bangladesh got independent after us. They all know why their nation were created. They all are working toward betterment.
Most of these years, its either a Bhutto or Sharif or someone from military on the throne. Everybody has got their chances, none have done anything apart from throwing the masses into abyss.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 07:34pm
wow seriously? so you will deprive nation of 180Million due that reason? what about the hours of educational content it holds? NO one on this earth can insult our beloved Prophet Mohammad (PBUH), he is rehmat-ul-alameen.
There is no point blocking youtube ..
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 07:36pm
There are open abuses against Hindu deities by Akbaruddin Owaisi still running on Youtube in India. But no ban on Youtube . Neither the offending video was removed nor there was protest by Hindus. The act was condemned by more Muslims than Hindus. If you respect others then you get the same without demanding.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 07:42pm
There is one unintended consequence of this ban. If you type Pakistan into Youtube, all you see is bad news. Pakistanis no longer have any control of the narrative because they are banned from participating in it.
Well... the world still watches Youtube and forms its opinion from what it sees on it. So ban the public from it at your own peril.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 07:43pm
Why can't we handle offensive material?
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 07:45pm
I have learned so much from the youtube...if it was not there I would have completed my complicated mathermatical courses....shame on our government for not letting us learn from new technologies !!
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 07:45pm
Pakistan Govenment is following a draconian concept of censorship. There will always be offensive material, does not matter if its on TV or Internet or even a Book. TOLERANCE, a concept that is non-existant in our culture is what are people need to learn.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 07:47pm
There are so many videos blaming all religion ,culture etc uploaded by more dirty minded people than fanatics and also there are vulgar comments by viewers supporting these videos but compare to good cultural ,educational and religious videos they are negligible .Including India all nations are facing same problems with YT and pornographic films in the net .It is a futile exercise of blocking YT in the internet as new websites will open when one website is closed .
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 07:48pm
It probably also means that pornography is going to continue to remain freely available in our Islamic republic. What a bunch of messed up priorities, if they have any at all.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 07:54pm
@khan
UTube is a very important tool to educate oneself by knowing what is happening around you. Ban it and loose it.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 07:54pm
This is not the only cause of banning Youtube website in Pakistan. There are several other reasons which makes the ban of the most popular video sharing website favourable for these so called authorities. If they could find a way of making all the blasphemous contents unviewable in Pakistan also in that condition they would not lift the ban from Youtube and the probable cause of this action is the availability of thousands of free online tutorial and other educational videos. Many famous educational institutions are bribing the responsible authorities for keeping Youtube blocked in Pakistan.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 07:57pm
Post a video about Holocaust being fake on YouTube, Facebook Twitter. you account will be blocked for rest of life.
YouTube must held accountable for targeting only Muslims.
Pakistan should also block Facebook.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 07:57pm
youtube is also blocked in China and various other countries. I don't see any educational, informational or any other kind of issues arising there due to that.
Its simple we don't need it. Now if only a handful of people can accept the fact and please just get over it.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 07:57pm
Pakistans so called democracy, ps Youtube has many posts on the subject of Pakistans political corruption and baseless policy's, I guess this is one way to cover up the mess.....just block it and hope for the best.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 07:58pm
Pakistan Government can not debar its citizens from the right to information.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 07:59pm
An excellent step, much appreciated.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 08:00pm
@ata maji satakly
What civil rights? We don't want it, sorry.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 08:01pm
The "officials" don't even know how to spell youtube! They are just afraid of removing the ban.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 08:02pm
@Abdul Malik
Never the YouTube culture please, be it 31st century.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 08:03pm
Blocked since 2012. Surprised
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 08:03pm
@Rao
There are other options too.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 08:04pm
Hey! we can export you people all the contents of YouTube in CDs from India. How is the deal?
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 08:04pm
@gohar thanks for letting em know so they can block that too. Oh man
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 08:07pm
What I don't get is that Pakistan is a Muslim - majority country. Why would Muslims go on YouTube and search for videos offensive to their religion?
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 08:08pm
If it is offensive just don't view it, flag it to stop it. World is full of filth, but you don't stop living in it, you avoid it. This attitude of govt is absurd. People still go to YouTube and whole world has access, including Pakistan.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 08:13pm
By this logic, electricity should be also banned..
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 08:14pm
under-table ptcl hypocrisy
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 08:15pm
Seriously , social sites shows the truth .....and pakistan gov. don't like it do ..bad really bad for em.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 08:19pm
The world doesn't care. The blockage isn't hurting anyone but the people of Pakistan.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 08:21pm
My friend who works in the same ministry told me that Two Video portals other than youtube have a strong lobby within the Minsitry. They are paying bribes to the officials and are making sure that Youtube will remain banned and all search will be directed towards their sites. One site is Pakistan based while the other site is European. Kindly investigate those claims as well.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 08:22pm
A slice of chinazenship.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 08:23pm
Why the dusmani with you tube? Shut down all social media. You are doing more damage to your people by depriving them of you tube. The amount of learning literature available on you tube is simply outstanding.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 08:32pm
To the Pakistan Government which has no clue of the 21st century and to our incompetent and ill-informed Minister Anusha: YouTube can be seen in Pakistan today on all Android devices - it can also be seen on PCs and other smart phones using a free VPN download from the Internet, so your ban has completely FAILED. Secondly, your action to restrict the freedom of people to watch and listen to the content of their choice, is unconstitutional, so you are a violator of the constitution of Pakistan. Now grow up, act wisely and let it go.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 08:39pm
Why TV in Pakistan. Shut down all.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 08:45pm
Won't work. We are in the internet age where restricting information is not possible.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 08:51pm
Thank you Pakistan for making a stand. The attacks on Islamic Civilizations has been going on for too long. From centuries long criminal colonization to invasions of Muslim lands killing millions of people. Creating monsters like ISIS and TTP. Then these same people attack the Muslim religion using mass media demonising the very same oppressed.
This is another chapter in a very long war which have been going on before our time and will sadly continue after our time.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 08:54pm
@Pravin Yes, a very thanks to youtube. It gave a chance to all indian people to know owisi better. Because of his hate speeches now many muslim hates him. Youtube makes people aware about good and bad. Feel sorry about pakistan.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 08:55pm
As an add to my precious post: England and Israel has created a cyper war brigade in their armed forces. Pakistan should also do this to create and control perception management which is as, if not even more, important then armed brigades in present world.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 09:04pm
If U-tube is banned, then it can be access through proxy sites............
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 09:22pm
Youtube is not banned in the Middle East. Pakistan seems to be boxing itself ....
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 09:23pm
Why they just don't ask them to make those objectionable videos unavailable in Pakistan through proper channel, instead of telling them to take the videos off the site completely because they dont cater to the taste of people living in Pakistan?
Youtube has done it for Turkey and Egypt, they'd do it for Pakistan too. Sometimes common sensr beats the Jageerdarana attitude.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 09:24pm
Welcome to 21st century
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 09:27pm
Its blocked because there are so many videos that expose Pakistan policies and people bash it badly...the army is scared of that because people will rise and question them
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 09:28pm
Youtube should be allowed to operate in Pakistan; it's more an education tool than an entertainment. We have deprived our concerned people from the benefits of online education related videos which are mostly posted via Youtube.
Feeling sorrow over the hypocrisy of our ruling elite (and youtube too for their selective freedom of expression version)
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 09:29pm
Why is it so difficult to filter our blasphemous content out of you tube that we could not do it in over two years? There must be some vested interest at work. If our expert cannot do it, hire a foreign agency, instead of blocking out the entire you tube?
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 09:38pm
Hence the citizens of Pakistan won't be able to benefit from a free service that is a tool for education, information and entertainment, all because successive myopic governments and their babus can't see beyond their noses.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 09:43pm
why is this even in the news?
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 09:50pm
A lot of things in the world are offensive. You don't have to see them. I never watched or wanted to watch that stupid film--it was the product of a diseased mind. The fact is that the mullah or mullah mentality still rules in Pakistan. Alas! This could have been a great country.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 09:57pm
“So far no tool or solution has been found which can totally block offensive content, that is why YouTube remains blocked and it will remain so indefinitely,”
On 16 Dec 2014 terrorists killed innocent children firing with AK 47 Kalashnikov Rifles. Why doesn't ban Kalashnikov ?
Why are politicians and their private militias still brandishing these weapons in public.
Has the Government taken all the steps for security of people that it has allowed AK 47?
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 10:16pm
Making dailymotion stronger.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 10:39pm
Remember same logic when Taliban banned computers as people may watch adult movies. In Saudi arabia, women not allowed to drive as it distract other male drivers, women should cover their face as they have tempting eyes.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 10:45pm
ReAlly??? U guys don't have YouTube !!!
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 11:01pm
@sachin Everyone in Pakistan who wants to watch YouTube can watch it. Every schoolchild with an Internet connection knows how to access YouTube through proxies. The whole blocking exercise is a big hoax perpetrated by our rulers.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 11:03pm
if there had been UK or US instead of Pakistan in this news you guys had been entirely opposite comments to these. kindly try to avoid being judgmental for your country. at least we are religious & never forget it.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 11:09pm
@very bad new, the minister of Info Anusa Rehman is not IT professional she is lawyer, therefore we expecting this type of decision. Cong Anusa.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 11:10pm
Come on it's really simple, Youtube gives you snapshots of all videos just fetch them before the streaming and compare with your blocked list or contact me for more solutions.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 11:14pm
I can't believe we are living in 21st century
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 11:15pm
Pakistan govt is denying all educational and learning aspects of Youtube to Pakistani students. Most lectures from big Universities are on Youtube.EDX.org has all it's lectures posted on Youtube. Khan Academy lectures are on Youtube. Pakistan govt is no different from Talibans since both work against educating people.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 11:21pm
I just double checked and whoever claims that mobile version of youtube is available in Pakistan is misleading. It is banned.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 11:25pm
Does The minister not know that even now ( With the blockage of You Tube) if a Pakistan resident wants to view some particular content of You Tube ,it can be done easily.
Maybe , some day a minister will propose to ban Paper and Ink in Pakistan because some publicly available obnoxious printed material is produced
using PAPER and INK ; so ban all Papers and Inks from Pakistan.
By banning You Tube , the then Govt Of Pakistan tried closing doors on a huge source of information & knowledge. Why not that we decide not to
Click on the obnoxious material ,and not to invite it.
It is like Talibans , who say some teachers can teach "bad" things to girls, SO
BAN GIRLS' SCHOOLS.
Let us wake up.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 11:26pm
This is totally ignorant approach people still have access to youtube through proxies and banning it causing loss to Pakistanis only. Banning drags attention to those those videos, letting such things go would be a fair approach.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 11:28pm
Deny education to Pakistani student is no right. Govt should remove ban from Youtube.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 11:29pm
@citizen
And Ban PaperAnd Ink also,for the same reason!
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 11:29pm
Ban on YouTube is the root cause of many problems of Pakistan.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 11:38pm
Not every society is brave enough to listen criticism of its own.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 11:41pm
Why do Pakistanis shy away from a view that probably one in ten million holds? Ostriches do that. Let this video information outlet function and ignore the handful in six billion.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 11:43pm
There is no filter except the human brain.
Censorship is Censorship, and in this case that interference blocking Peoples' freedom is merely for the sake of political expediency. Bending to that outside pressure shows the true state of the nation. It is a step backward. Those who do not want to watch YouTube don't have to go there. You can bet half of those complaining don't even own an Iphone or computer.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 11:44pm
@Burger Baloch
The insane never realize they are insane.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 11:46pm
@Abdul Malik
Sure. There is a lot of rot on YouTube but it hosts other important subjects as well.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 11:48pm
The problem is also that most of the population wants it to remain blocked.
Recommend
0
Feb 07, 2015 11:57pm
What you don't know will hurt you. Nothing breeds ignorance than censorship to keep people of all cultures, ethnicities, and religions from interacting with each other. We as Muslims are so insecure in our skin that the only way we think for us to survive is to shield ourselves from the thoughts of others.
People often cite the golden period of Islam, but fail to understand that the golden period of Islam did not occur in vacuum. It was a result of Muslim philosophers, mathematicians, and scientists studying the works of Greek philosophers, Indian and Chinese mathematicians, etc. that was being ignored by Europe.
Recommend
0
Feb 08, 2015 12:01am
No adorable kitten videos for you Pakistan !
Recommend
0
Feb 08, 2015 12:09am
First, USA influenced Pakistan. Now its Chinese style. When are you going to learn?
Recommend
0
Feb 08, 2015 12:32am
Ok go ahead....in next ban Facebook, Twitter, Google, Yahoo...Instead of banning JuD, Haqqani, JeM etc...
Recommend
0
Feb 08, 2015 01:03am
The government bans Youtube, but leaves out Qadri, Gazi, etc. What a country this is.
Recommend
0
Feb 08, 2015 01:18am
Wow what a bold and competent move..... Not!!!!
Recommend
0
Feb 08, 2015 01:20am
We are in year 2015!....people should be allowed to decide what to watch over the internet....if you dislike something, on youtube , just dont look at it.It may disturb you, but not others...
Recommend
0
Feb 08, 2015 01:46am
The block never bothered me. I used VPN to stay current with the world.
Recommend
0
Feb 08, 2015 01:55am
Incompetent govt made another poor decision. Scared of backlash if they lift the ban.
Recommend
0
Feb 08, 2015 02:00am
Great news-I care about blasphemous content-we have to protect our society at all costs.
Recommend
0
Feb 08, 2015 02:01am
In the west....when we have a problem we get together and write and call our elected officials. They have the power to change things. And if they don't listen to people the people vote them out next time.
Majority in Pakistan agrees that YouTube should Not be banned. Why doewnt anyone start a partition and get 1 Million Signatures and send it to PMs office? I bet they would have to look at it.
Exercise your rights people !
Recommend
0
Feb 08, 2015 02:02am
Then block internet and cables
Recommend
0
Feb 08, 2015 02:06am
This week I have used YouTube here (USA) to investigate some interests in history, music, philosophy, world news, and family heritage. I used it also to see some software applications, some travel videos, and to stay abreast of recent developments in two favorite hobbies.
From viewing, I came away with an enhanced respect for what humans have done, are doing and can do, and with hopes for the world we are giving to our future generations.
I did not look at anything vulgar -- not because somebody decided to prevent me from looking, but because I have learned that in life there are more enduring and important things to do.
Recommend
0
Feb 08, 2015 02:10am
Next ban TV, then Radio, then singing in public, then singing in bathrooms .... You sure will reach your glory and nirvana some years from now !! Pakistan Paindabad !!
Recommend
0
Feb 08, 2015 02:10am
Ban internet too! What grave mistake/ sin we committed to be granted such "leaders"?
Recommend
0
Feb 08, 2015 02:15am
I suspect the You Tube ban has more to do with the anti Pakistani Military content than anything to do with religion.
Recommend
0
Feb 08, 2015 03:10am
you tube,facebook and other web site ban is perfect if you are working for best after life. Most people want to show just how pious they are, but otherwise are normal people. They do not really believe in after life and want to see everything.Rulers and clergy want to control people. I am 100 percent sure internet will bring down the influence of clergy and then one day youtube ban will be lifted.
Recommend
0
Feb 08, 2015 03:28am
Good. Now ppl can spend their time pursuing meaningful things.
Recommend
0
Feb 08, 2015 03:40am
@Akbaruddin Ansari He is allowed to bypass it using tor.
Recommend
0
Feb 08, 2015 03:44am
Close every thing so you can enter stone age quickly, you are getting there anyway.
Recommend
0
Feb 08, 2015 03:51am
@umer "I hv questions 1. is banning youtube cause any financial loss to youtube or not? "
No.
Recommend
0
Feb 08, 2015 05:12am
It is really simple. If you don't like something on youtube don't watch it.
Recommend
0
Feb 08, 2015 05:16am
WOW, Pakistani "experts" say content cannot be filtered!!!
Too bad that the Pakistani government technical "experts" must be totally unaware that EVERY OTHER MUSLIM COUNTRY has arranged for YouTube to install Localized Hubs in their respective countries so that content could be filtered/censored!!!
In fact more than 50 countries world wide have installed Localized Hubs OVER THE LAST DECADE!!!
Recommend
0
Feb 08, 2015 05:32am
@goa!!! very appealing comments. But there should be limitations in internet to avoid blasphemy / contempt to all religions and societies.
Recommend
0
Feb 08, 2015 05:38am
Google, youtube's parent organization, has the monetary muscle to bear the losses because of this ban. Let's see who's the first to budge from their claims, youtube or Pakistan.
Recommend
0
Feb 08, 2015 05:50am
No light at end of the tunnel
Recommend
0
Feb 08, 2015 06:01am
They should block PORN SITES FROM PAKISTAN RATHER THAN YOU TUBE !!!!!!
Recommend
0
Feb 08, 2015 07:04am
Burning the house down to kill the rat.....
Recommend
0
Feb 08, 2015 07:06am
@Temo Shanko It can, and it does!
Recommend
0
Feb 08, 2015 07:08am
Unfortunately in Pakistan governance does not exist and hence there is no one in power who is educated or has forsight so adopted the easiest option to ban it. Pakistan is not the only Muslim country trying to redress a balance between censorship and access, it does not have to look further than UAE where offensive websites are banned but a total ban is preposterous.
Recommend
0
Feb 08, 2015 07:14am
It would be wise to ban everything in Pakistan except Maulvis and braindead Politicians
Recommend
0
Feb 08, 2015 07:23am
I didn't know this. I really pity my Pakistani friends. They are deprived of an important right to information and amusement.
Recommend
0
Feb 08, 2015 08:17am
But there are a million porn sites and new ones coming up daily. Will the govt shut down the Internet? They will need to have a Pakistani internet.
Recommend
0
Feb 08, 2015 08:18am
Most Pakistanis see a lot of porn daily.
Recommend
0
Feb 08, 2015 08:22am
More patriotic than King attitude is deplorable. Is Pakisthan more islamic than other countries in Ummah ?You tube is available in all muslim countries including Saudi. Who gave Pakisthan the divine right to moral police the muslims ?..Ultimate looser will be people of Pakisthan only..You tube will be least bothered about this ban..
Recommend
0
Feb 08, 2015 03:53pm
you cannot stop the march of progess bethay.
Recommend
0
Feb 08, 2015 06:09pm
Why don't you also ban/block internet, mobile devices which could be used to share things you don't like? Anyways you have been killing all those who do not agree to your thoughts!!
Recommend
0
Feb 08, 2015 06:31pm
Your obscurantism is better for us
Recommend
0
Feb 09, 2015 02:27am
@akhthar I agree with you brother.
Recommend
0
Feb 09, 2015 02:38am
I got into data science and got my first job in IT by simply learning from an ocean of tutorials on YouTube. Banning YouTube is a loss for our students, teachers, scholars or anyone who is interested in learning from how to hit a nail with a hammer to advanced fields in science and technology.
we all now that people who have authority to ban such a beneficial platform have hit the peaks of knowledge, but please, we still have a lot to learn and I think banning YouTube is not a right thing to do.
Recommend
0
Feb 09, 2015 06:46am
by watching you tube we observe that many are happy with indian society,progress made by us and every now and then they compare with what pak. achieve since independence, they openly not happy with the rulers of govt.so many highly intelligent persons have confessed that govt. have done so many illegal activity with bangladesh and india and in afghanistan too. as a result we have been remain backward in all sector, and also labbele of terrirism sponsored country.giving sheltered to internationaly criminals govt.. suffered more till date nd no body trust us.people are getting more details of 1965, 1971 and kargil war to mumbai attck also indian parliament attack, where govt. agencies involvement.
Recommend
0
Feb 09, 2015 12:30pm
Indefinite ban implies indefinite stupidity
Recommend
0
Feb 10, 2015 03:22am
This is a non starter. You can access all youtube videos via any proxy server. However this shows the stupid mindset of this government.
Recommend
0
