Alert Sign Dear reader, online ads enable us to deliver the journalism you value. Please support us by taking a moment to turn off Adblock on

Alert Sign Dear reader, please upgrade to the latest version of IE to have a better reading experience


Filmmaker exposes flaws of forced marriages

Updated Apr 17, 2014 07:37am


Your Name:

Recipient Email:

- FIle Photo
- FIle Photo

ISLAMABAD: The Friedrich Ebert Stiftung (FES) aired ‘Poles Apart’, a documentary based on the menace of forced marriages, on Wednesday.

Directed by Samar Minallah, the short documentary focuses on individuals who managed to escape forced marriages amongst Pakistani families across the country and in Norway, to maintain links with their roots or other social cultural reasons.

The movie’s director, who has been highlighting various forms of forced marriage, including compensation marriages such as vani/swara and early marriages, focuses on the parents as prospective agents of change.

Shot in Oslo, Norway, Jhelum, Gujrat and Lalamusa, the production captures glimpses from the life of Khadija, in Jhelum, who dared to return to Pakistan after enduring an abusive relationship with her husband for seven years.

The film shows how she lived now, content in giving driving lessons to girls in her hometown.

The documentary is not just restricted to women’s issues but also shows the impact of forced marriages on men.

It contains shots of Tayyab Chaudhry, in Oslo, who stood his ground when he was also being forced to marry against his will.

With the underpinning that chains can not keep marriages together, the documentary emphasises the importance of individuals involved being given the choice to choose and refuse.

The director supports this message with comments from a former judge of Lahore High Court, Nasira Iqbal, who explained how marriages could only be between freely consenting parties. “This is the true concept of marriage in Islam,” said retired Justice Nasira Iqbal.

The film reveals shocking statistics, stating that around 1,700 individuals were forced into marriages, in 2010, and one third of them were under the age of 18 years.

Samar Minallah explains, through moving images and examples, how in most cases the individuals were forced into marriages when families are trying to improve their station in life.

She gave the example of Najma Bibi, who was married to a man, who was ill and had been married twice before, so that her family could pull their relatives out of Pakistan to settle in a foreign country that presumably offered better living standards.

It shows how dreams turn into bitter reality, not just for the married couple, but they also sever family ties. The production depicts how younger generations walked into the traps and the parents emotionally blackmailed them into marrying persons who were poles apart.

“Young people become victims of values and customs of older generations, who are trying to uphold practices that have become obsolete,” the documentary quotes one victim of forced marriage as saying.

It also reflects on parents who meant well, but misjudged the intentions of others, doing more harm to their children. Mental mismatches and barriers led to divorces within months, or in some cases many painful years later.

The film’s screening was part of FES’s efforts to spread awareness on the gender issues, in an informal atmosphere. The concept was to bring civil society together, to provide a platform and discuss such controversial issues.

Poet and writer Kishwar Naheed, said, “These issues are not resolving and the honor crimes are increasing, day by day. Choice of marriage is not only a crime but it is also considered as a sin.”

The documentary was shown as part of the ‘Movie-log’ initiative of the three cooperation partners, German Political Foundation (FES), the German academic exchange Deustcher Akademischer Austauschdienst (DAAD), and the Centre of Excellence in Gender Studies at Quaid-e-Azam University.


Your Name:

Recipient Email:

Comments (4) Closed

FIZA Soho Apr 17, 2014 08:09am

In an ideal world love should transcend a marriage - regardless of whether it's arranged or not. As for those couples who've been "forced" into marriages due to cultural pressure - this is against the teachings of Islam.

The Imam who's performing the Nikah should ask the bride and the groom w/o the presence of parents/senior family members if each has "willingly" consented to the holy union. Many Imams don't do this- especially if they're from rural, uneducated or ultra-conservative backgrounds. Some Imams don't want to rock the boat, so they just carry on with the Nikah full well knowing that it's wrong yet buckle under the pressure of the parents.

As for abuse in the marriage, this happens among some educated Pakistanis and Western couples who've all married for love. So some of these cases covered in this documentary should be focusing on the other side of this social issue, not just couples from rural areas of Pakistan who's families immigrated to countries like Norway.

Such documentaries should show a more balanced view, and not simply demonize cultural mores without presenting other viewpoints,ie, couples in such marriages who are actually happy and content with their family's decision.

awais Apr 17, 2014 10:36am

A good effort to stop violence of force marriages but i wish if the director can put effort in highlighting the success of arranged marriages as well. Its very pity that such efforts to stop force marriages, club the arrange marriages with it. Also so-called love marriages which which somehow or not, trigger the force marriages; the director must focus on it, and show the demerits of marriages which has no family values but ruin them.

In short we have to project the family values and successful marriages, of generation by generation to curb the effect of force marriages.

Ajay Apr 17, 2014 11:16am

@awais: Arranged marriange needn't necessarily instill family values in us, right? Even in love marriages, if the couples are well educated (in every sense of the word) they are going to respect their family values.

Ajay Apr 17, 2014 11:17am

@awais: Love marriages not forced, no matter what the outcome is, but the arranged marriages are often forced.