76
KARACHI: At least eighteen people have died in the port city of Karachi since Tuesday night due to the consumption of toxic moonshine, DawnNews reported.
“Since last (Tuesday) night, 18 people have died after consuming toxic liquor,” doctor Seemi Jamali of Karachi's Jinnah Hospital told AFP.
The doctors were trying to save the lives of 15 others whose condition was serious, she added.
Inspector General of Police (IGP) Sindh Ghulam Haider Jamali has taken notice of the deaths caused due to the consumption of toxic moonshine and has ordered the authorities to arrest the culprits selling the banned liquor.
Area police chief Akhtar Farooq said that police had conducted raids at illegal liquor factories and arrested three accused while seizing “Katchi Sharab” (home made liquor).
A few days earlier, at least 20 people died in Hyderabad reportedly after consuming toxic liquor.
Also read: Hyderabad toxic liquor tragedy toll rises to 20
Liquor poisoning is common in Pakistan, where the Muslim majority is forbidden to consume or sell alcohol and the sale is tightly regulated for minorities and foreigners.
While higher-income Pakistanis buy bootlegged alcohol at heavily-inflated prices, the poor often resort to home-brews that can contain methanol, commonly used in anti-freeze and fuel, that can lead to blindness, liver damage and death.
Read more
On DawnNews
Comments (76) Closed
Oct 08, 2014 05:28pm
The government should take steps to un-ban consumption of alcohol.I don't understand why they want to force religion on us? I'm Muslim and I'm a regular consumer of alcohol. Every time I want to buy wine or beer (by calling the bootlegger), it makes me feel as if I'm committing a crime! Don't know when will our mentality grow!
Recommend
0
Oct 08, 2014 05:32pm
Non- Muslims have permits and they can buy best quality liquor from government owned or private stores.
But liquor is expensive.
Recommend
0
Oct 08, 2014 05:34pm
There needs to be a crackdown on such things.
Recommend
0
Oct 08, 2014 05:41pm
Since there is no facility in Pakistan to cure addicts, I guess that is the way to go. I bet mullah will have his opinion about funeral prayer for the dead.
Recommend
0
Oct 08, 2014 05:45pm
Toxic liquor?? Wake up ppl, liquor by itself is slow poison. Why blame liquor by knowing this fact?
Recommend
0
Oct 08, 2014 05:47pm
Bad End of A Bad Act!
Recommend
0
Oct 08, 2014 05:55pm
Police raided illegal factories and arrest three persons !!! What a news ? As if the police did not know beforehand about such factories. No such factories or any other illegal trade or work can continue without connivance of the police. They never even try to stop such things because in that case their so-called "extra income" would also stop. All illegal trade and acts are going to continue till such time that the area police is held accountable and punished too.
Recommend
0
Oct 08, 2014 05:57pm
Same old occurrence, and let me tell you the same old story. Drugs cannot be totally stopped. and besides, if healthy normal drinks are available, people would not drink poison. Let some kind of drink be available. And, let God decide if they are sinners. We will have to stop playing God. Let's concentrate on our jobs, and let God do His job.
Recommend
0
Oct 08, 2014 05:59pm
@Ali Rizvi :regular and proud consumer of alcohal! You made me speechless.
Recommend
0
Oct 08, 2014 06:00pm
@Ali Rizvi
Don't force your liberal beliefs on us. Majority still doesn't want to consume it.
Recommend
0
Oct 08, 2014 06:02pm
@Ali Rizvi You mean you are a cricketer but don't want to follow the rules. Will icc allow you to play in shalwar kameez and aluminium bat and instead of bowling you choose to throw like baseball style? Your poor logic is such a shame for all muslim or maybe you are not muslim any way but only using muslim name to insult us.
Recommend
0
Oct 08, 2014 06:02pm
@Ali Rizvi i guess it is a crime according to the constitution of islamic republic
Recommend
0
Oct 08, 2014 06:10pm
GO + WENT + GONE when you cannot ban drinking of alcohol in Islamic Republic of Pakistan. Iqbal Hadi Zaidi
Recommend
0
Oct 08, 2014 06:17pm
Islam has only told us what is good for human beings. If you do not want to follow, you bear the consequences. Many drinkers die because of liver disease and some die or kill innocent people in traffic accidents. Some even kill their own family because they can not think when they are drunk.
Recommend
0
Oct 08, 2014 06:20pm
RIP to those who post lives and hope their families cope with the life. This is where both countries need to focus, their public health and safety and not on border disputes. One incidence has killed more than collective number in border dispute on the other hand one stampede killed similar number of people in India.
Recommend
0
Oct 08, 2014 06:25pm
How would they face Allah when dying in a drunk state. It gives me shivers. May Allah forgive them.
Recommend
0
Oct 08, 2014 06:29pm
I am a Hindu from Pakistan, moved to US abt 10yrs ago, don't drink alcohol as that is how I was brought up..but I agree w Ali Rizvi, Pakistan needs to separate State from religion. Not saying it should be allowed to be consumed openly in public but if some of these addicts or even occasional drinkers wanted that they had access to buy quality products so the people are not dying from poison. .
Recommend
0
Oct 08, 2014 06:29pm
@Pakistani : Does Islam allow smoking? Many Muslim Friends of mine smoke quite regularly and boast of not drinking where as I drink once a week and do not smoke at all. I can tell you (if you trust me) I'm more healthier then them.
Recommend
0
Oct 08, 2014 06:47pm
@Ali Rizvi
I absolutely agree with you on it. In order to stop all this (death, illegal manufacturing of liquor) the ban should be lifted and if needed put a quota system for all Muslims.
Recommend
0
Oct 08, 2014 06:54pm
if you end prohibition, you won't have these deaths. We tried it in USA and it miserably failed. Have you heard any such deaths in USA? Here we do die of alcohol itself but not from moonshine!
Recommend
0
Oct 08, 2014 06:56pm
@Ariba Who is asking you to consume? By the same token you should not preach to others.
Recommend
0
Oct 08, 2014 06:58pm
I can not find the religion of the victims though Dawn is implying they are non-muslims. Is that true?
Recommend
0
Oct 08, 2014 07:01pm
Quran says you need not follow wat you don't understand. People should be made aware of benefits of not consuming alcohol and also encouraged not to consume but forcing a ban on those who re willing is wrong.. I'm also pure non alcoholic but forcing my personal choice on others is wrong.
Recommend
0
Oct 08, 2014 07:03pm
@Ali Rizvi ... Were you a muslim, ie one who submits his will and life to Allah SWT, you would not touch alcohol, you would stay very far away from it as is Allah's command. May Allah Guide you and may you abandon your infantile behaviour.
Recommend
0
Oct 08, 2014 07:07pm
@M1968 ... Do not go against Allah's Law, its a lose lose situation. You lose in this world and you lose in the hereafter.
Recommend
0
Oct 08, 2014 07:12pm
@Ali Rizvi Feel sorry for those who lost their lives. Hope their families stand strong. I think we need RULE OF LAW before we get to that point (un-ban consumption). Otherwise, every day we will be loosing human lives. A long way to go. Very first step would be... Go Nawaz Go!
Recommend
0
Oct 08, 2014 07:18pm
@Sunny If you don't like the comment, you can express that you disagree. Calling someone a shame, a non-muslim, an insult.. I think there should be better way to express disagreement.
Recommend
0
Oct 08, 2014 07:21pm
Turkey could be a good role model for Pakistan. Alcohol is allowed in Turkey but I have not seen many people drinking it though.
Recommend
0
Oct 08, 2014 07:23pm
@Ali Rizvi alcohol is forbidden in islam its clear mentioned by ALLAH (SAW) in Quraan :They ask you about intoxicants and games of chance. Say: In both of them there is a great sin and means of profit for men, and their sin is greater than their profit. And they ask you as to what they should spend. Say: What you can spare. Thus does Allah make clear to you the communications, that you may ponder: Albaqra 219
Recommend
0
Oct 08, 2014 08:04pm
@Ali Rizvi Hypocritical legacy of General Zia ul Haq regime is causing this.
Recommend
0
Oct 08, 2014 08:09pm
In the light of religion, alcohol is termed as mother of all evils. When the religion of peace is calling it as mother of all evils, we must listen and think why.
Recommend
0
Oct 08, 2014 08:13pm
@ramesh you are right and there is a permit available for non-Muslims. Alcohol is banned in Islam so one should obey the law
Recommend
0
Oct 08, 2014 08:21pm
@Pakistani As if only intoxicated people go around and kill people.
Recommend
0
Oct 08, 2014 08:45pm
I do not feel sorry at all.
Recommend
0
Oct 08, 2014 08:46pm
Seems like Pakistan is the only country where people die on a regular basis from poisoned alcohol - too proud to implement common sense solutions used by the rest of the World?
Recommend
0
Oct 08, 2014 08:49pm
Govt should subsidize alcoholic beverages in Pakistan.
Recommend
0
Oct 08, 2014 09:04pm
@Ali Rizvi um...there are rules for every country. "I'm muslim"- if you say so. Knowingly drinking and saying it as if you are proud of it- Good muslim- not. No-one is forcing their religion upon you.
Recommend
0
Oct 08, 2014 09:07pm
The article is giving the impression that only poor non-Muslims consume this cheap liquor.
All those who can't afford good quality expensive liquor consumes the cheap version.
As Mr. Ali Rizvi has stated above, the bootleeger deliver the product at his doorstep.
I don't drink but liquor is available openly, no country can match us in delivery at home. All my friends who drink get their booz like this.
Recommend
0
Oct 08, 2014 09:12pm
@ramesh Every country has rules. i.e Guns, etc etc. If rules were not there, ther'll be murders, etc etc. Drink Driving and so on.
People do it in the privacy of their homes. People break rules. Thats the way it is.
Recommend
0
Oct 08, 2014 09:14pm
@Ali Rizvi ... the logic of Islam and Religion is to become subservient to God and His orders (conveyed through the Messengers). Don't try to play your own games.. there is no way out really.. in subservience is tranquility and reward.. you have to do it to feel it.
Recommend
0
Oct 08, 2014 09:15pm
But isn't liquor consumption highly restricted if not totally banned in the "land of the pure?"
Recommend
0
Oct 08, 2014 09:17pm
@M1968 - Quota system on Alcohol? seriously. -How is legalising it going to stop death?. More people die from drink driving, Alcohol abuse, than anything else. Legalising it can also create more alcoholics- they'll kill themselves drinking anyways.
Being drunk makes you mindless- probably go home and beat the wife, or the kids, or unknowingly walk in front of a car killing yourself as well as those in the car
Recommend
0
Oct 08, 2014 09:52pm
@Ali Rizvi Hi Ali... I do not understand why people are turning up against you on this discussion. In my opinion alcohol should not be banned. By lifting the ban, people who do not want to drink will not drink and who want to drink will drink! Putting a ban simply means you are forcing someone, who wants to do a particular thing, to not do so... I am a Muslim and I do not consume while living in a country like USA. Hence if the ban is lifted then people like me will not drink and who do want to drink will do so nicely and legally! Why do we have to sabotage basic rights!
And to other readers, having alcohol being sold legally is not a crime! You can choose or not choose to indulge. Please get a life and let others live. We all are responsible for our own-selves, not of others!
Recommend
0
Oct 08, 2014 09:58pm
@ammar what about smoking ?
Recommend
0
Oct 08, 2014 10:03pm
@Nilesh Shah, you know what else is slow poison? Cigarettes! Cause more deaths each year than alcohol. I dare you to try and ban those in Pakistan.
Recommend
0
Oct 08, 2014 10:14pm
Tobacco is an intoxicant as well. So is cabffeine. They aren't banned. There is research to show how human judgement is impared under the influence of both tobacco and caffeine. Why aren't they illegal? Why cherrypick certain things and not others? Is it because tobacco and caffeine are part of our culture
Recommend
0
Oct 08, 2014 10:25pm
Reading the comments on Dawn since two years have made me conclude that, the problem with Pakistan is: it obligatorily links everything on earth with religion.
Recommend
0
Oct 08, 2014 10:26pm
In Malaysia and Indonesia liquor is freely sold everywhere (since Pakistan look towards them as role models) , people there are healthy, honest and have a better approach to life and are result oriented and above all very good humans...any explanation for this double standards
Recommend
0
Oct 08, 2014 10:37pm
@Ali Rizvi LOL you're still able to buy your alcohol, so who's forcing religion on you? Its not about changing mentality, its about knowing whats permissible and what isn't in your religion.
Recommend
0
Oct 08, 2014 10:49pm
I do not understand as to why alcohol is ban in Pakistan whereas it is freely available in Abu Dhabi, Bahrain, Dubai and other UAE being Muslim states. In Sharjah one can consume inside his/her apartment. In Kuwait, Qatar and Saudi Arabia it is available in a restricted manner and can be procured easily. Most ex pat working in these countries make alcohol in their homes or camps. However, due to restrictions most youngster Arabs drink and drive offences can get killed on roads.These countries are putting some kinds of checks on drivers which would help them to reduce accident/causalities.
Pakistan should develop laws to control the abuse of alcohol and remove stringent laws. It should be up to the people to decide.
Recommend
0
Oct 08, 2014 10:53pm
Any habits that harms your body and effects you or your families is prohibited. so why are cigarette's legal in pakistan?. Rules that bends to benefits or pesonal / society gain are not islamic teachings.
Recommend
0
Oct 08, 2014 10:56pm
@Pakistani Well muslims do cigarette and hooka much more than alchohal and they die of lung cancer...btw there are more people dying of cigarettes than liver cancer/cirrosis.
Recommend
0
Oct 08, 2014 10:58pm
@Danish please read it again what I said. If you not follow the law and rules then it's a shame either way. What prove does one have that Ali Rizvi is Ali Rizvi and not kumar or jatindar? It was written in that sense and not insult anybody. If you are not follow the rules then it's inult by itself
Recommend
0
Oct 08, 2014 11:01pm
@Ali Rizvi Will this stop deaths by consumption of toxic local brew? Your comment should be related to the news topic. You can express your wishes through other available means, e.g. Letters to the Editor
Recommend
0
Oct 08, 2014 11:05pm
@Husain Jan I totally agree with you. To stop these deaths, SHO of the area where such liquor is sold and his immediate superior should be made held equally responsible for the crime and punished along with the liquor seller.
Recommend
0
Oct 08, 2014 11:08pm
I believe a person is good or bad are irrespective of whether he drinks or not. Drinking does not make a person morally bad.
@M1968
If needed put a quota system for all Muslims like 1 bottle per person per week. Good idea.
Recommend
0
Oct 08, 2014 11:57pm
This is Islamic Republic of Pakistan !!
Things should/will run according to Islamic laws. (InshAllah)
Recommend
0
Oct 09, 2014 12:53am
But I heard that drinking is not allowed in Islam
Recommend
0
Oct 09, 2014 01:22am
Wow, there are people supporting for its consumption here. Drink as much as you like, you'll know what you are getting into pretty soon.
Recommend
0
Oct 09, 2014 01:50am
The more you restrict a society worst the consequences , freedom to choose and freedom of choice is the key.
Recommend
0
Oct 09, 2014 02:00am
28 people die EVERY DAY as a result of drunk driving in US where laws are 1000 times more strictly enforced than Pakistan.
Those arguing against alcohol prohibition still wants to make alcohol legal in Pakistan ?
Recommend
0
Oct 09, 2014 03:04am
@Abhishek Tomar , Smoking is more harmful, especially passive smoking, than liquor consumption. If Pakistan has to ban anything they shall ban Smoking, Hooka, Cigar and Bidi.
Recommend
0
Oct 09, 2014 04:17am
What a way to go. Such a shame
Recommend
0
Oct 09, 2014 04:18am
@Abbas Ali : "Barq Girti Hai To Bechaare Musalmanon Pr"!
Recommend
0
Oct 09, 2014 04:20am
@Ali Rizvi : The Prohibition of alcohol does not provide a simple solution yet complicates it. The middleman makes the best of it.
Recommend
0
Oct 09, 2014 04:24am
@ThisIsMe: Ali Rizvi spoke the truth and he should be proud of it. In the Islamic Republic of Pakistan, many more sinful activities are practiced everyday.....lying for one! Atleast Mr.Rizvi does not pretend to be a hypocrite.
Recommend
0
Oct 09, 2014 04:28am
@concerned_kashmiri : May Allah forgive you for not minding your own business and being judgemental.
Recommend
0
Oct 09, 2014 04:31am
@Abhishek Tomar : To further the discussion, does Islam allow homosexuality? We have conveniently swept the pedophiliacs under the carpet. If we can't see something how can it hurt us?
Recommend
0
Oct 09, 2014 04:31am
How many Muslims living in the West, where liquor is freely available, drink? Not many. They are a choice. They are not forced to drink alcohol.
Recommend
0
Oct 09, 2014 04:41am
The sale is tightly regulated !! The minorities can't afford to drink it! It the Muslims who drink it!!! Pop over any hotel and you can buy it ! Like buying any thing else!! Rip !!!
Recommend
0
Oct 09, 2014 05:18am
Restriction creats demand, if there is no restriction demand will be low, government cant stop the consumption,its available always as explained by ali rizvi, however there should be crack down on illegal liquour producers.
Recommend
0
Oct 09, 2014 06:23am
@LATIF
Please comment only if you have the facts right.
I am a resident of Sharjah since the seventies. Alcohol is totally banned in Sharjah. People try to smuggle it from Ajman where it is sold illegally, and are prosecuted if they are caught on the way.
Recommend
0
Oct 09, 2014 06:26am
@Ali Rizvi
A Muslim by definition is one who accepts the dictates of Allah and lives his life accordingly and not as per his wishes/desires.
Food for thought.
Recommend
0
Oct 09, 2014 06:27am
I was thinking Pakistanis do not drink being a Islamist state. Not sure why people who drink are tolerated??? Looks like there is demand and no supply which ends up with similar incidents. Banning is not a solution and it does help people who sell in black market. Knowing how the system works Cops must be taking a big cut in illegal liquor sales..
Recommend
0
Oct 09, 2014 07:10am
@Nilesh Shah
Liquor is not a poison, it depends on how much you consume. Two famous Muslim, the founder of Pakistan and Modern Turkey regularly consume liquor but within reasonable quantity and they both achieved higher status in their respective countries. Poet Iqbal was another one who was regular consumer of liquor and today the nation visits his tomb in Lahore.
Americans tried banning liquor in their country and it brought misery and ultimately they withdrew the ban.Point is that those who want to refrain from liquor due to their religious obligation will do that voluntarily and those who want to drink will do that, it does not matter whatever Laws the state will put in force.
Recommend
0
Oct 10, 2014 01:37am
@Ali Rizvi
Consume more and your mentality will grow double speed!!!!
Recommend
0
