Alert Sign Dear reader, online ads enable us to deliver the journalism you value. Please support us by taking a moment to turn off Adblock on

Alert Sign Dear reader, please upgrade to the latest version of IE to have a better reading experience


Politics and polio


Your Name:

Recipient Email:

HERE’S a suggestion for Pakistani politicians. For just a couple of days, forget the usual political rhetoric. Take a break from bashing each other or America, railing against a clash of institutions, or making predictions about political developments over the next few months. Instead, focus on a problem that is of real and immediate relevance to ordinary Pakistanis: the serious threats to the campaign for the eradication of polio. Tuesday’s shooting in Karachi of a UN doctor working on polio immunisation followed the refusal over the last couple of days of the Taliban and some tribal leaders to allow polio vaccinations in parts of Fata, where the problem is most acute. If the immunisation campaign that ends today is extended by a few days, and if all major political parties focus on the issue, with the JI, the JUI and the PTI joining hands with the PML-N and the ruling coalition, there is a decent chance that something will give. This will not do away with opposition to polio vaccination overnight. But it should give health workers, local officials and supportive clerics more ammunition to negotiate with those who are resisting, and it might encourage parents to take risks to get their children immunised. At the very least it will demonstrate that our politicians are concerned with more than just politics.

The mistrust of polio immunisation should not be dismissed as being entirely ignorant or unjustified. Dr Shakeel Afridi and the CIA did no favours to the project when they used a fake vaccination programme to try to track down Osama bin Laden. Other elements of the US-Pakistan relationship, particularly drone attacks, are being positioned as reasons to block the state-run campaign. None of this is helped by long-held suspicions among some communities that polio vaccination is un-Islamic or designed to weaken Muslims. In this scenario, what is needed is high-profile messaging that can counter deeply ingrained perceptions.

Given the threat to the lives of campaign workers, the problem is also one of the state’s failure to protect them and, in Fata, of it no longer having control of chunks of territory. But the containment of polio cannot wait for better policing or the restoration of the state’s writ in the tribal areas. In the immediate term, what could help is rhetoric that approves of vaccination and positions the issue as one that should not be held hostage to politics and American policies. But it will go unnoticed as long as it isn’t coming from the top of the food chain. At this point, it is worth giving persuasion from the highest levels a try.

Comments (6) Closed

cautious Jul 18, 2012 11:08am
Seems to me the real issue is that you don't really control the tribal territories so even if all your politicians agreed that eliminating polio was a great thing they don't have the ability to do much about it.
raika45 Jul 18, 2012 12:08pm
Holding childrens future health in a sort of blackmail because of differences between adults regarding their political, religious,or political power feuds is a heinous crime.Innocent lives well being sacrificed for personal selfish reasons is a complete and total abomination in ANY RELIGION.
Agha Ata Jul 18, 2012 12:51pm
Imagine this thing happening in any other civilized country of he world, and see what the government would have done.
Pathanoo Jul 18, 2012 06:11pm
Humbug. If the Government and all political parties sincerely came out against these terrorists and the tribal elders; they would blink. But then, you don't expect the chickens to take on wolves, do you?
Imran Jul 19, 2012 01:04am
Blaming only the political leaders would be unjust. A major part of pie goes to public health experts of Pakistan that unfortunately is lead by physicians. Physicians who are interested in their personal gains and do not care of those who need their help. The direction of the program has been incorrect. Our vaccination policy makers have always gone after money and nothing else. The participation of our public health leaders has been as followers and not leaders. The leaders who are convinced that we have a problem, we need to solve it and here is the modality to address the problem. Instead they have blindly followed what has been told to them by 'international experts', without realizing the reality on the ground.
Prashant Jul 19, 2012 01:24am
very pretty situation in Pakistan. Extremists or anti-Americans should understand that children are future of any country.Moreover this anti polio campaign is funded by the U.N. which is a world organisation of more then 190 countries including Pakistan. It is not an American or western organisation.