Weight debate haunts fashion week

Published September 19, 2006

LONDON: London opened its spring/summer fashion week on Monday, but there was more attention on the body size of its models than on what clothes they were wearing. Days of debate about whether some thin women are too skinny for the catwalk because their appearance may encourage eating disorders has pushed the clothes out of the limelight and left organisers begging for a change to the subject.

“Some controversy can be helpful, but what we have seen over the past days is not the way to hold a proper debate on the issue,” Marks & Spencer Chief Executive Stuart Rose, chairman of the British Fashion Council organising the event, told Reuters on the sidelines of an opening show.

Britain’s premier fashion event has found itself under siege after health experts and Culture Minister Tessa Jowell suggested it should consider following Madrid, which last week announced it would ban too tiny women from its shows.

Madrid’s plan, that has already seen some models rejected for its shows — aims to ban models with a body mass index (BMI) — a ratio of height to weight — of less than 18.

In an effort to defuse the weight row, organisers the British Fashion Council cancelled a photocall on Sunday, where some of Britain’s top models were due to showcase London Fashion Week’s shows spanning cult 1960s label Biba to a one-off appearance by Giorgio Armani’s younger line Emporio Armani.

Yet, the debate continues to simmer among fashionistas and designers at the five-day event. While most agree eating disorders sparked by the industry need to be addressed, they say the Spanish solution is not the way to do it.

THINSPIRATION: Some designers and leading fashion journalists have suggested organising an industry roundtable to discuss how to quash the ‘thinspiration’ trend — a term used in pro-anorexia websites to describe skinny celebrities.

Veteran fashion editor Suzy Menkes said anorexia in fashion was a ‘deeply important’ issue that needed to be discussed by the whole industry.

Topshop’s head Jane Shepherdson said the chain, part of tycoon Philip Green’s Arcadia group, steered away from putting very skinny girls on its catwalk because of its broad audience.

“We deliberately wanted the models to be beautiful, healthy-looking girls, there was one model who was a little bit on the thin side, she wasn’t our first choice,” Sheperdson said.

—Reuters

Opinion

Sexual abuse by Israel

Sexual abuse by Israel

Thousands of Palestinian men, women and children are languishing in Israeli prisons in subhuman conditions, with many routinely subjected to sexual abuse.

Editorial

Hormuz gamble
20 May, 2026

Hormuz gamble

The Strait of Hormuz has become the real centre of the confrontation.
The unkindest cut
20 May, 2026

The unkindest cut

SUICIDE, a complex symptom of deep despair triggered by mental health problems, is hardly a moral issue. Punitive...
Ad hoc culture
20 May, 2026

Ad hoc culture

THE Supreme Court’s ruling against prolonged ad hoc and acting appointments is an indictment of a deeply ...
Water win
19 May, 2026

Water win

Besides being a technical and legal win, the ruling validates Pakistan’s argument about the existential stakes involved for it.
Free ride
19 May, 2026

Free ride

THE federal and provincial governments have extended what appear to be major concessions to the retail sector ahead...
Ceasefire in name
19 May, 2026

Ceasefire in name

THE ink on the latest ceasefire extension between Israel and Lebanon was barely dry when Israeli warplanes were back...