LONDON: England may have been the reigning world champions in both 50-over and T20 cricket as recently as two years ago, but they head into the ICC Champions Trophy facing an uphill struggle to reach the semi-finals.

They suffered seven defeats in eight white-ball games during their preceding tour of India, culminating in a crushing 142-run loss in the third ODI in Ahmedabad. That result condemned England to a 3-0 series whitewash, after their 4-1 reverse in the T20s.

The side have now lost more ODIs since their 2019 World Cup triumph than they have won — 32 to 29, with 10 defeats in their last 14.

In England’s favour is that the pitches in Pakistan are set to be more to the liking of both their batsmen and fast bowlers than the spin-friendly surfaces in India. To reach the last four of the Champions Trophy, Jos Buttler’s men must finish in the top two of a group that also contains Afghanistan and South Africa — both of whom beat England during their woeful title defence in the 2023 World Cup.

The recent India campaign was England’s first since Test coach Brendon McCullum also took charge of the white-ball teams.

Former New Zealand captain McCullum enjoyed initial success as England’s red-ball boss, although the team have since failed to qualify for the World Test Championship final.

Many of the criticisms levelled against England’s Test cricket under McCullum have now been applied to the limited-overs teams.

The all-format charge sheet against England includes struggle against quality spin and express fast bowling, while their only response when an aggressive ‘Plan A’ fails appears to be simply to ‘go harder’.

McCullum however was bullish following Ahmedabad loss.“You know what I’m like. Always optimistic. If you go the other way, you’ve got no chance. I have belief in us.”

But whether Buttler remains the right man to oversee an England revamp is an open question. It was limited-overs coach Matthew Mott who lost his job following England’s lacklustre defence of their T20 World Cup last year.

Nothing that has happened since suggests Buttler is providing the charismatic or tactical leadership to inspire England.

The dynamic batsman, speaking after the India ODI series, said: “I think the fact we’re not anywhere near our potential yet or playing individually or collectively where we know we can be gives us something to look forward to, believe we can get there and be a dangerous team in the Champions Trophy.”

Published in Dawn, February 21st, 2025