A YEAR-LONG investigation by the BBC into the state of journalism in India-held Kashmir has ruffled feathers, with the Jammu and Kashmir Police warning of legal action against the UK’s public broadcaster, The Wire reported on Saturday.

Local police have taken umbrage at the BBC News report by Yogita Limaye, titled ‘Any story could be your last’ —India’s crackdown on Kashmir press’, which details a “sinister and systematic campaign to intimidate and silence the press”.

According to The Wire, J&K Police said the report “unfairly castigates law and order efforts” as “biased against journalists.”

The report details the story behind the detention and prosecution of Kashmiri journalists Asif Sultan, Fahad Shah, Sajad Gul and Irfan Meraj, among others.

More than 90pc of the journalists BBC spoke to said they had been summoned by the police at least once, many of them multiple times over a story. “Some said the tone of the police was polite. Others said they were met with anger and threats,” the report said.

Journalists from held-Kashmir told the UK broadcaster the Indian government is trying to shut down reporting related to separatist movements and militant groups, but also any coverage critical of the security forces or the administration, even on day-to-day civic issues.

According to The Wire, an official spokesperson of J&K Police said on X, formerly Twitter, that the State Investigation Agency “reserves the right to initiate further legal action” against the BBC for “misreporting facts in a case which is sub judice.”

However, police didn’t clarify what they meant by “misreporting of facts”.

In its rebuttal, the J&K Police said that its “actions” against journalists “have stood the test of law and judiciary and changed the security environment in the union territory immensely.”

A BBC spokesperson told The Wire, “We would simply say that the BBC stands by its journalism.”

Published in Dawn, September 3rd, 2023

Opinion

Editorial

A positive note
Updated 10 Feb, 2025

A positive note

With govt unable to press growth accelerator without upending fragile recovery, sufferings of low-middle-income households are unlikely to disappear soon.
Justice for all
10 Feb, 2025

Justice for all

ALONG with his domestic agenda, Donald Trump is busy ripping to shreds the post-World War II ‘rules-based...
Held back
10 Feb, 2025

Held back

IT is a crying shame how women are conspicuously absent from Pakistan’s civil services. Despite comprising half ...
Race against time
Updated 09 Feb, 2025

Race against time

While some bright spots emerged at Breathe Pakistan moot, we must streamline our climate governance.
Open door
09 Feb, 2025

Open door

THE door is still open for talks, National Assembly Speaker Ayaz Sadiq has reminded the PTI. What matters, however,...
Football suspension
09 Feb, 2025

Football suspension

ONCE again, Pakistan has been ousted from the global football family. FIFA recently suspended the Pakistan Football...